Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Forge lawfulness appeal fails after concealment findings

An Inspector rejects a Devon forge lawfulness claim, finding contradictory occupation evidence and deliberate deception. Both parties also lose their costs applications.

A forge lawfulness appeal in Mid Devon has failed after a four-day planning inquiry examined conflicting evidence about residential occupation, commercial storage and possible deliberate deception. Inspector Andy Harwood dismissed the appeal on 29 October 2026 and upheld the council’s refusal to issue a certificate of lawful use.

The decision concerns Meadow Forge at Hillside Barn, Cadeleigh, near Tiverton. The appellant, Dean Aggett, claimed that a mixed use combining a blacksmith’s forge, residential accommodation and outdoor storage had become lawful through the passage of time. Mid Devon District Council disputed both the evidence of continuous use and the immunity claimed.

This forge lawfulness appeal is important beyond Devon because the Inspector considered two separate obstacles. He was not satisfied that the asserted mixed use had continued for the necessary ten years. He also concluded that positive deception in dealings with the council would, in any event, prevent the appellant from relying on the normal enforcement time limit.

Why the forge lawfulness appeal failed

Planning permission granted in December 2009 allowed the retention of a change of use from agriculture to a blacksmith’s forge. Conditions restricted the building to use as a forge and prohibited storage outside. The appellant later sought a certificate for an allegedly established composite use that went beyond those restrictions. The dispute was not an ordinary planning application inviting a fresh judgement on whether the activities were desirable.

Under section 191 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, the central task was to establish the lawful status of the claimed use on the date of the application, 9 October 2025. In this case, the Inspector analysed whether a material change of use had occurred and whether that use had continued for at least ten years. Evidence of occasional overnight stays did not automatically establish the broader residential use claimed.

The Inspector also used the Gravesham judgment as a reference point for deciding when residential use begins. A kitchen or bathroom does not, by itself, prove that somebody lived there. Equally, the absence of some facilities does not necessarily disprove residential occupation.

The Inspector considered the 2009 permission, the nature of the forge activities, photographs, statutory declarations, planning contravention notices and oral evidence. He found important contradictions. The appellant claimed longstanding residential occupation, yet earlier responses to formal council enquiries had denied residential use. In the Inspector’s words, his case is riven with contradictions. That was an assessment of the evidence in the planning appeal, not a criminal conviction.

What did the evidence show about the mixed use?

The forge lawfulness appeal turned partly on how the site had developed over time. Aerial imagery from 2010 depicted a comparatively clear and orderly area, while later material showed much more substantial storage and activity. The Inspector considered when those activities started, how they related to the permitted forge and whether they formed one new mixed planning unit.

He found that the current combination of activities could not simply be treated as the original permitted blacksmith’s use with a few incidental additions. The change of character and scale required a proper analysis of the planning unit, rather than an assumption that everything within the land ownership boundary must share one lawful use.

The decision referred to Burdle and another v Secretary of State for the Environment, the established authority concerning how the planning unit is identified. For the broader practical position, Planning Geek’s guide to planning units and incidental uses explains why physical and functional relationships matter.

In the end, the Inspector could not establish a sufficiently precise start date for the current mixed use or reliable continuity for the necessary period. The forge lawfulness appeal therefore failed on the evidential test, quite apart from the later discussion of concealment. A claimant needs credible material that covers the relevant use and period, not just proof that somebody occasionally stayed or worked there.

Deliberate deception and the Welwyn Hatfield principle

The most consequential part of the forge lawfulness appeal concerned the council’s planning contravention notices. The Inspector analysed earlier written assurances that no one was living at the site against the appellant’s later claim of long-term occupation. He concluded that the responses and conduct went beyond passive omissions and were intended to prevent the authority from appreciating the true use when considering enforcement.

The decision applied Secretary of State v Welwyn Hatfield Borough Council [2011] UKSC 15, commonly called the Beesley case. The Supreme Court recognised an exceptional public-policy answer to attempts to obtain immunity through positive deception integral to the planning process. It is not a blanket rule that every inaccurate statement defeats lawfulness.

The Inspector considered that the appellant would benefit directly if the statutory time limit prevented enforcement after representations designed to frustrate the authority’s normal process. On those findings, he concluded the normal protection under section 171B should be disapplied. The ruling is fact-sensitive and should not be treated as permission for councils to disregard statutory immunity merely because evidence is disputed.

Planning Geek’s guide to concealment and planning enforcement orders explores the legal position. The Inspector also referred to Titchfield Festival Theatre, but regarded that case concerning enforcement and reversion to earlier lawful use as materially different from the disputed mixed-use certificate. The Inspector’s decision appears to miscite Titchfield as (2016) EWCA Civ 784. The correct Court of Appeal citation is [2026] EWCA Civ 368; [2016] EWCA Civ 784 relates to Kestrel Hydro, a different judgment.

Both parties’ applications for costs were refused

The forge lawfulness appeal included an unusual separate costs decision. Mid Devon District Council sought its costs from the appellant, while Mr Aggett sought his costs from the council. Both applications were refused. The Inspector held that neither side had shown the combination of unreasonable behaviour and unnecessary or wasted appeal expense needed for an award.

The inquiry sat on 8, 9, 10 and 24 September 2026. A fourth sitting followed a dispute about alleged prompting of a witness while giving evidence. Witnesses gave conflicting accounts and the Inspector found no clear picture of improper prompting. Although the procedural disruption was regrettable, he did not find that it proved unreasonable behaviour by the council sufficient for costs.

The costs decision also acknowledged aspects of both parties’ conduct open to criticism. That did not justify an award where their substantive cases were advanced reasonably and the relevant procedures followed. A dismissed appeal does not automatically entail a costs penalty. Equally, a successful defence by a council does not necessarily entitle the authority to recover its expenses.

What this means for lawfulness applications

For people considering a lawful development certificate, the forge lawfulness appeal reinforces the need to identify the exact use being claimed, the correct planning unit, the dates on which relevant activities started and the evidence showing continuity. Historic permissions and conditions must be analysed carefully. A certificate is a legal determination about what was lawful at the relevant date, not retrospective permission based on planning merits.

It also illustrates the risks of giving materially inconsistent answers in formal planning enquiries. Applicants should disclose evidence candidly and ensure later accounts can be reconciled with earlier documents. Inspectors consider the whole evidential picture and may attach little weight to statements contradicted by contemporary records.

Appeal decision and legal sources

Inspector Andy Harwood’s decision is dated 29 October 2026, appeal reference APP/Y1138/X/26/3378579. The case concerns Mid Devon application 25/01406/CLU. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase. The short quotation above is from the Planning Inspectorate’s decision, published under the Open Government Licence v3.0. The separate costs decision refused both parties’ applications.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news

Gateway 2 approvals reach 92%

Gateway 2 approvals reach 92%

New Building Safety Regulator data shows 40 new-build approvals covering 9,453 homes as overall Gateway 2 approval rates reach 92%.

!-- Google tag (gtag.js) -->