Flattery and Japanese Parts Centre Ltd v Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government and Nottinghamshire County Council [2010] EWHC 2868 (Admin)
The Flattery planning case concerns the legal status of a use claimed to be lawful in the face of enforcement proceedings, and whether informal assertions or previous council conduct could establish a binding planning entitlement. The High Court considered challenges to decisions concerning a former farm used for vehicle dismantling and scrap storage.
Mr Justice Lindblom gave judgment in the Administrative Court on 18 November 2010. The case was brought by Thomas Flattery and Japanese Parts Centre Limited against the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government and Nottinghamshire County Council. The neutral citation is [2010] EWHC 2868 (Admin), under court references CO/3354 and CO/3363 of 2009.
The case is relevant when an applicant relies on past discussions with a local planning authority instead of establishing a land use through the statutory procedure for a certificate of lawful use or development. Its application must be understood within the precise planning history and evidence of the case being considered.
Important legal note: Planning Geek is a planning consultancy, not a law firm. This page provides general planning information and is not legal advice. Case law must be read in its factual and legal context and may be affected by later judgments, legislation or policy. Where the original judgment is available, it remains the authoritative source. If the outcome matters to a live case or dispute, take advice from an appropriately qualified planning solicitor or barrister.
Copyright and licensing: Crown copyright and other rights in judgments and source material remain with the relevant rights holders. Where a judgment is reproduced from Find Case Law, it is used under the Open Justice Licence and the source should be acknowledged. Material obtained from other sources is reproduced only where the applicable terms permit it. Planning Geek does not claim copyright in the text of court judgments.
Background to the Flattery planning case
The dispute involved Twitch Farm at Balderton, near Newark in Nottinghamshire. Mr Flattery purchased the site in 2005. Applications were made for certificates under section 191 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 in relation to an asserted scrapyard operation, storage and associated structures.
The county council also issued enforcement notices alleging unauthorised uses and operations. After an inquiry, a planning Inspector allowed the certificate appeals only in a limited respect relating to the skeletal frame of a Dutch barn, which had existed long enough to be immune from enforcement. She otherwise refused the claimed lawful uses and upheld the enforcement notices, subject to corrections and variations.
Mr Flattery challenged the Inspector’s decisions using section 288 and sought permission to appeal on enforcement issues under section 289. The High Court examined alleged errors in the Inspector’s treatment of the evidence, the notices, procedural fairness and the claimed legitimate expectation that the scrapyard use would be accepted.
Informal assurances and statutory lawfulness
A central argument was that historic statements and actions by planning authorities recognised a scrapyard use, such that the owners could legitimately expect it to continue. The important distinction is between the weight of an officer’s communication as factual evidence and the legal effect of a formal statutory decision.
Planning control is a statutory public-law system. The leading House of Lords authority R v East Sussex County Council, ex parte Reprotech (Pebsham) Ltd [2002] UKHL 8 explains why private-law estoppel and informal assurances do not substitute for formal planning determinations. The Flattery litigation applied that principle in the context of claimed lawful use and enforcement.
Mr Justice Lindblom rejected the grounds challenging the Inspector’s decisions. The section 288 application was dismissed and leave to appeal under section 289 was refused. The Inspector’s decision to refuse a costs award was also upheld. The court’s role was to decide whether legal errors had occurred, not to reweigh the evidence of historic site activities simply because the claimant disagreed with the Inspector’s factual conclusions.
How later inspectors have applied Flattery
The Flattery planning case was expressly cited by Inspector Grahame Kean in a November 2026 lawful-development certificate appeal involving a water tower in Goodworth Clatford, Hampshire. The applicant relied on a council officer’s 2020 email suggesting that agricultural use had remained lawful.
The Inspector treated that communication as insufficient to establish the necessary statutory use or agricultural history, and held that informal correspondence could not take the place of a formal lawful-use determination. The applicant still had to provide adequate evidence under section 191 and the agricultural-use conditions in Class R of the General Permitted Development Order.
That is a practical example of the principle without extending the 2010 judgment into a rule that councils’ statements are always irrelevant. They may form part of the evidence. What an informal email cannot do is conclusively determine the statutory lawfulness of a development when the legislative conditions have not been demonstrated.
Practical importance and limits
For an applicant, the critical questions are which planning use actually existed, when it existed, what statutory time limits or permitted development rights apply and what contemporary evidence proves the necessary facts. A historic officer email, lack of earlier enforcement or informal understanding should not be treated as a replacement for that proof.
For a planning authority, the case underlines the importance of separating informal advice from a formal decision and of accurately recording the evidence relied upon. When an issue is genuinely one of lawfulness, the proper statutory route is a determination under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990.
Full judgment and Gold download
The complete 25-page text of the High Court judgment, checked against the neutral citation, parties, judgment date and final paragraph, is held securely in the Planning Geek Case Law library. The locally hosted complete judgment is available through the Gold-protected download below.





