Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Bonsall listed building appeal wins over PV slates

A Bonsall listed building appeal allows PV slates and extra rooflights after renewable energy benefits outweigh low-level heritage harm.

A Bonsall listed building appeal has allowed photovoltaic slates and extra rooflights on a Grade II listed former barn after an Inspector found that the renewable energy and daylight benefits outweighed a low level of heritage harm.

The linked appeals, references 6008049 and 6008081, concerned The Range, High Street, Bonsall in Derbyshire. One appeal sought a section 73 variation to an earlier planning permission for conversion of the barn to a dwelling. The second challenged refusal of listed building consent for the associated internal and external alterations.

The Bonsall listed building appeal is useful because the Inspector accepted that the PV slates and rooflights would introduce overtly modern features into a prominent historic roofscape. Even so, the harm was found to sit at the low end of the scale and was outweighed by site-specific public benefits, including renewable energy, reduced reliance on artificial lighting and the prospect of supporting the long-term repair and maintenance of a building on the council’s at-risk register.

Why the Bonsall listed building appeal mattered

The Range is a substantial stone barn in the centre of Bonsall. The building is Grade II listed and sits within the Bonsall Conservation Area, so both the listed building itself and the wider historic roofscape had to be considered.

Planning permission and listed building consent had previously been granted in 2023 for conversion of the barn to one dwelling, together with a separate stable and carport building. The later applications sought a number of amendments to that approved scheme.

Most of those changes were not controversial. They included a relocated staircase, revised internal walls and bathrooms, alterations to doors and windows, a repositioned flue, a heat pump and changes intended to retain double-height spaces.

The dispute centred on the roof. The proposal added five rooflights, repositioned three already approved rooflights and introduced integrated photovoltaic slates across the south-facing roof slope. Derbyshire Dales District Council considered the roof changes harmful to the listed building and conservation area and refused the applications. The appellant then pursued both the planning and listed building consent routes together.

The rooflights and PV slates were modern interventions

The Inspector did not minimise the heritage effect. The proposed PV slates were modern products, made from toughened glass and aluminium and designed to sit within the roof rather than above it. The additional conservation-style rooflights were also plainly contemporary features.

For the Bonsall listed building appeal, the south-facing roof was particularly sensitive because it formed the principal elevation and was prominent in short-distance views through the village. The Inspector also considered that PV slates could weather differently from traditional clay tiles, making the contrast more noticeable over time.

That led to a finding of heritage harm. The proposals would not fully preserve the special interest of the listed building and would also harm the character and appearance of the conservation area. But the degree of harm was crucial.

The roof had already lost its historic covering and was clad in modern concrete tiles. The earlier permission itself proposed wholesale replacement of that roof covering, together with three rooflights. No historic roof fabric would be lost as a result of the appeal scheme.

The building’s strongest heritage characteristics would also remain legible. Its long two-storey form, prominent gables, stone walls and surviving historic fabric would continue to dominate how the building was understood. The Inspector therefore placed the effect at the low end of heritage harm rather than treating the proposal as a fundamental erosion of significance.

Public benefits tipped the heritage balance

Once harm to designated heritage assets had been identified, the decision turned on whether public benefits were sufficient to outweigh it. The appellant argued that the rooflights would improve daylight to the upper-level living space.

The Inspector had visited on a cloudy, rainy day and found that part of the interior gloomy. Deeply recessed windows, the building’s layout and nearby buildings all restricted natural light. Additional rooflights could therefore reduce the need for artificial lighting and its associated energy demand.

The PV slates carried a separate benefit. The August 2026 National Planning Policy Framework gives substantial weight to the benefits of clean energy and recognises the contribution that small-scale renewable energy can make to cutting greenhouse gas emissions.

The appeal evidence did not quantify the expected electricity output. Even so, the Inspector accepted that the system would support energy conservation and renewable generation at the property.

The fact that the building was identified on the council’s listed buildings at risk register also carried weight. The Inspector considered that lower energy costs and improved efficiency could assist the owner’s ability to invest in the building and keep it in good repair.

In the Bonsall listed building appeal, those benefits were specific to the appeal building and its circumstances. Taken together, they were enough to outweigh the low level of harm to the listed building and conservation area.

The decision does not say that solar technology or rooflights automatically outweigh heritage harm. It shows how the statutory heritage duties and national policy balance can work where the harm is limited and the benefits are clearly connected to the future use and maintenance of the building.

Section 73 and listed building consent had to work together

The planning appeal was made under section 78 against refusal of a section 73 application. The applicant wanted to replace the approved-plans condition attached to the 2023 planning permission so that the revised design could be implemented. The statutory distinction was central to the Bonsall listed building appeal.

The listed building appeal was separate in law. Listed building consent has its own statutory regime, so the Inspector had to address both decisions even though the schemes concerned the same building and were assessed together.

That distinction matters in practice. Amending a planning permission does not automatically amend listed building consent, and securing listed building consent does not remove the need to ensure that the planning permission and its conditions also authorise the intended works.

Planning Geek’s listed building consent appeal guide explains the appeal route, while our heritage significance and harm guide looks at how the decision-making balance is approached.

Conditions will control the final roof treatment

The appeals were allowed, but the approval was not unconditional. For the planning permission, the Inspector required full details of the type and colour of the PV slates, including the frame, to be approved before installation. Other conditions deal with roofing materials, stonework, windows, chimneys and rooflights.

The Inspector rejected a suggested condition requiring the PV slates to be removed when they were no longer needed. That wording was considered imprecise because no replacement roof material had been identified and any later roof change would itself require listed building consent.

The Bonsall listed building appeal therefore offers a further practical lesson on conditions. They should deal with a clear planning purpose and be capable of precise compliance. They should not create a vague future obligation simply because the technology involved may one day become obsolete.

Planning Geek’s solar panels planning guide covers the ordinary planning position for solar equipment, but listed buildings require a much more site-specific assessment because planning permission, listed building consent and heritage significance can all interact.

The appeal is not a blanket green light for solar on listed buildings

The Bonsall listed building appeal should not be treated as a general green light for solar on listed buildings. The Inspector expressly found harm to both the listed building and conservation area. The appeals succeeded because the harm was limited and because the public benefits were strong enough in the particular circumstances.

The existing roof had already been altered. The PV slates were integrated rather than mounted above the roof plane. The main historic form and stone fabric remained dominant. The rooflights were small and flush, and their detailed design could be controlled by condition.

Different facts could produce a very different result. Historic roofing material, a more intact principal elevation, more intrusive equipment or weaker energy and conservation benefits could shift the balance against approval.

For applicants, the practical message is to make the heritage case specific. It is not enough to say that renewable energy is desirable. The submission should explain the significance of the building, identify exactly where harm would arise, show how design has reduced that harm and demonstrate the real benefits that remain.

For councils, the decision is a reminder that identifying heritage harm is not always the final step. Where the harm is less than substantial, the decision-maker still has to carry out the policy balance and give proper weight to public benefits.

The full appeal decision covers both planning appeal 6008049 and listed building appeal 6008081. The Planning Inspectorate case record is also available online.

Planning Geek view

The Bonsall listed building appeal is a useful modern heritage decision because it avoids two lazy extremes. It does not treat renewable energy as an automatic trump card, and it does not treat every visible modern feature on a listed building as unacceptable.

The Inspector identified real harm, gave that harm considerable importance, and then asked whether the specific public benefits were enough to outweigh it. On this building, with this roof and these alterations, they were.

The stronger application strategy for listed buildings is therefore not to argue that there is no harm unless that position is genuinely credible. A more robust case may be to identify the harm accurately, minimise it through design and then evidence why the remaining public benefits justify the intervention.

0 Comments

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news