Glen Earrach pumped storage hydro has secured support from Highland councillors after a split committee vote was decided by the chair’s casting vote.
The South Planning Applications Committee resolved on 7th October 2026 to raise no objection to the Section 36 application for the major pumped storage hydro scheme above Loch Ness, subject to additional safeguards sought on blasting hours and the visual treatment of the dam wall.
For the pumped storage hydro project, the council is a statutory consultee rather than the final decision-maker. Because the project is being promoted under section 36 of the Electricity Act 1989, the ultimate decision sits with Scottish Ministers.
Glen Earrach pumped storage hydro clears Highland Council stage
Glen Earrach pumped storage hydro is proposed on land west of Inchtellach at Bunloit, above Drumnadrochit. The project would use Loch nam Breac Dearga as an upper reservoir and Loch Ness as the lower reservoir.
The developer describes the scheme as a 2GW pumped storage hydro project with 34GWh of storage capacity. Water would be pumped uphill when electricity is abundant and released through turbines when the grid needs power.
Highland Council’s committee agenda for 7th October listed application 25/01599/S36 with an officer recommendation to grant support, or more precisely to raise no objection to the Scottish Ministers.
The committee did not reach that position easily. Members were split on whether to support or oppose the development, leaving chair Councillor Paul Oldham to use a casting vote in favour of raising no objection.
Extra controls were sought on blasting and the dam wall
The committee’s support was qualified. Councillors sought tighter controls on the hours during which rock blasting could take place, reflecting concern about disturbance during the lengthy construction period.
They also wanted the colour and finish of the dam wall to blend more effectively into the surrounding Highland landscape.
Those details may sound small beside the scale of a multi-gigawatt energy scheme, but they go directly to the local planning impacts that councillors are expected to scrutinise. Large infrastructure can be nationally important and still create very local noise, landscape, traffic and amenity effects.
The council’s role is therefore not to decide whether Scotland needs energy storage in the abstract. It is to advise Scottish Ministers on whether this particular project, in this particular landscape, should proceed and under what safeguards.
Why pumped storage matters to the electricity system
Pumped storage hydro acts as a very large rechargeable battery. When electricity supply is high and demand is lower, pumps move water to the upper reservoir. When demand rises, the stored water is released to generate electricity.
That ability to move large amounts of energy between time periods becomes more valuable as wind and other variable renewable generation make up a larger share of the system.
Glen Earrach’s developer says the project would provide 34GWh of storage and could materially reduce future grid balancing costs. Those are developer claims rather than planning findings, but they help explain why the project is being promoted as national energy infrastructure rather than a conventional local development.
The project website says the scheme has a head height of about 480 metres and is designed to provide long-duration energy storage on a very large scale.
Loch Ness location brings obvious environmental scrutiny
The strength of the energy case does not remove the environmental issues. The scheme sits in a landscape of exceptional scale and sensitivity around Loch Ness, with construction requiring extensive engineering works, tunnelling, excavation, access routes and spoil management.
Landscape and visual effects, ecology, peat, water environment, forestry, traffic and construction disturbance have therefore been central to the assessment.
NatureScot and the council’s ecology officers submitted responses ahead of the meeting, and the committee papers included detailed environmental material alongside the main planning report.
For major energy projects, this is where the practical planning challenge lies. The public benefit case may be substantial, but the environmental effects are equally site-specific and often irreversible if not properly designed and conditioned.
The council decision is not the final consent
It is important not to confuse Highland Council’s vote with planning permission.
The application has been made to the Scottish Government under section 36 of the Electricity Act 1989. Highland Council is a consultee in that process. Its decision to raise no objection is influential, especially because local planning impacts have been examined in detail, but Scottish Ministers remain responsible for the final determination.
That distinction is similar to other nationally significant energy regimes across the UK, where local authorities can play an important advisory role without holding the final consent.
The Scottish Government will need to consider the council’s position alongside statutory consultees, environmental information, public representations and the wider energy policy framework before deciding whether consent should be granted and what conditions should attach.
A casting vote underlines the planning tension
The split committee is arguably the most interesting part of today’s decision.
It shows that the project cannot be reduced to a simple contest between renewable energy and opposition to change. Members were weighing national energy and climate benefits against very real local landscape and construction impacts.
A casting vote does not weaken the formal resolution, but it does demonstrate how finely balanced the local political judgement was.
For the developer, securing a no-objection position removes one important source of risk. For objectors, however, the Scottish ministerial process still provides the final decision point and the council’s requested conditions could still become important if consent is granted.
What happens next
Highland Council’s consultation response will now feed into the Scottish Government’s determination of the Section 36 application.
The developer will continue to promote the scheme as part of Scotland’s long-duration storage infrastructure, while ministers will need to decide whether the national benefits justify the environmental effects and whether those effects can be controlled through design requirements, mitigation and conditions.
The council’s vote means the project goes forward without a formal local authority objection. That is significant, but it is not the same as a green light to start construction.
Planning Geek view
Glen Earrach is a useful reminder that major energy planning increasingly turns on scale rather than principle.
Few people dispute that a renewables-heavy electricity system needs storage. The harder question is where that infrastructure goes and how much local environmental change is acceptable to deliver it.
Highland councillors have now answered that question locally by the narrowest possible margin. Their position is that the project can proceed to ministers without a council objection, provided tighter safeguards are built around some of the most visible and disruptive effects.
The Scottish Government still has the final call, so this story is not finished. But the casting-vote decision removes a potentially serious local obstacle from one of the UK’s largest proposed pumped storage schemes.

0 Comments