Jet wash noise has defeated an appeal over a petrol station redevelopment in Midway, near Swadlincote, after an Inspector found that a proposed acoustic assessment underestimated the disturbance likely to reach neighbouring homes. The decision was issued on 2 November 2026.
The dispute concerned a self-service jet wash at Midway Save on Burton Road. South Derbyshire District Council had refused to approve details required by a noise condition on an earlier planning permission. Inspector D Harris-Watkins dismissed the appeal, leaving those submitted details unapproved.
The jet wash noise decision is significant for commercial operators because the refusal turned on the assumptions made in an acoustic report, rather than simply the presence of a proposed sound barrier. A ten-minute-per-hour operating assumption and uncertain claimed fencing performance were central to the Inspector’s reasoning.
What the jet wash noise appeal was about
The 2024 planning permission, reference DMPA/2024/0880, authorised redevelopment of an existing petrol station, including a jet wash. Its condition 6 required a scheme for controlling and mitigating noise to be submitted and approved before the first use of the permitted development, with the measures then maintained over its lifetime.
The operator, Khalid Mohammed, submitted a Noise Management Plan under application DMOT/2025/1514. The council refused approval on 30 March 2026, and the operator appealed under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990. The appeal was about the details needed to meet condition 6, not about granting a new permission for the whole petrol station.
The jet wash had already been installed and used. Following enforcement action, the appellant indicated that it would not operate until the condition details were approved. The Inspector deliberately left questions of planning lawfulness to the lawful development certificate process and confined the decision to whether the proposed mitigation was good enough.
Why ten minutes an hour was not convincing
The submitted acoustic assessment treated ten minutes of jet wash operation as a busy hour. That assumption mattered because the report averaged a corrected sound pressure level over an hour. On its calculation, the hourly level was equivalent to the jet wash being switched off.
Inspector Harris-Watkins was not persuaded that this represented realistic operation. Customers pay to use the self-service equipment, and ten minutes would allow roughly one customer an hour. With the filling station located on an A-road next to a relatively large built-up area, the Inspector considered it unreasonable to treat that as a busy period.
The Inspector observed: “No justification is provided for why ten minutes has been selected.” The weakness was not that a professional acoustic consultant had been used, but that the operating assumptions were insufficiently explained and led the assessment to understate the likely effects on neighbours.
This is the key point in the jet wash noise appeal: the accuracy of an environmental prediction can be undermined if the expected hours or intensity of use are not supported by convincing evidence. An assessment must be based on plausible operating conditions, particularly when equipment is capable of repeated use by members of the public.
An acoustic fence was not enough
The appellant proposed a tall acoustic fence, above the existing boundary treatment beside neighbouring homes. The Inspector nevertheless questioned the amount of noise reduction attributed to it. There was limited justification for the claimed attenuation, given the height of the fencing, the typical height of the noise source and the way noise travels around the edges of a barrier.
Although the houses were already affected by traffic noise from the busy road and petrol station, the Inspector considered the jet wash to be a different, closer source of disturbance. The equipment would not operate at night, when background noise was lower, but that did not sufficiently mitigate the harm that would occur during the daytime.
The council’s Environmental Health Officer had provided a competing appraisal that accounted for those matters. The Inspector gave it greater weight, concluding that the proposed mitigation would not adequately protect nearby residents. On that basis, condition 6 had not been satisfied and the proposal conflicted with South Derbyshire Local Plan policies BNE1 and SD1.
The jet wash noise reasoning connects to a broader planning issue. Our guide to noise in planning applications explains the role of noise assessments, amenity and proportionate conditions when a business operates near homes.
A different condition submission had already succeeded
There was a further procedural wrinkle. After the refusal now under appeal, another application, reference DMOT/2026/0659, proposed meeting the same condition on the basis that the jet wash would not operate. South Derbyshire District Council had approved those alternative details.
That separate approval did not decide the appeal over the earlier operational proposal. The Inspector considered the appealed Noise Management Plan on its merits, and dismissed it. Operators should therefore not treat approval of a later condition submission as retrospective approval of every version of an earlier management scheme.
Planning conditions can control not just whether development is permitted but how and when it may be used. Planning Geek’s discharge of conditions guide covers the process for demonstrating compliance with requirements attached to planning permission.
Previous use offered no reliable fallback
The appellant suggested that a jet wash had previously operated in a similar position and that the new equipment would be an improvement because of restricted operating hours and acoustic fencing. The Inspector had little information about that earlier jet wash beyond two Google Earth screenshots, in one of which it did not appear to be operational.
There was no substantive proof that the former jet wash had been lawful or could have been reconstructed lawfully, and the former equipment was no longer there. The suggestion that the proposal was better than an earlier installation consequently carried little weight. The jet wash noise assessment still had to stand on its own evidence.
In commercial planning, arguments about a fallback use can be useful, but the existence and lawfulness of that fallback must be established. Simply pointing to equipment that once stood on the site is unlikely to answer a current noise condition where the operation and impacts have not been evidenced.
What businesses should learn from the decision
The jet wash noise appeal is a warning against relying on optimistic assumptions about customer demand. The assessor needs to explain how the likely worst realistic operating period has been chosen, not merely pick a short interval that produces a convenient hourly average.
Where fencing is proposed, the actual position, height, likely source of sound and potential routes around a barrier need technical justification. Hours of use and the existing noise environment are relevant, but neither automatically cancels the impact of a different source much closer to residents.
For councils, the decision shows the value of a specific Environmental Health response addressing the methodology and the reality of the operation. For applicants, it illustrates why resolving those points before a condition-discharge decision can be more effective than depending on an appeal to correct an underdeveloped assessment.
Inspector D Harris-Watkins dismissed appeal 6013060 on 2 November 2026. The original planning permission was DMPA/2024/0880 and the refused condition application DMOT/2025/1514. The quotation above is from the published Planning Inspectorate decision under the Open Government Licence v3.0. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase.

0 Comments