A Toton housing appeal has been allowed for up to 420 homes on land west of Stapleford Lane, following a public inquiry into road capacity and the infrastructure needed for wider development. Inspector Joanna Gilbert granted outline planning permission on 2 November 2026, subject to 17 conditions. Access is determined, but the remaining detailed matters must return for approval.
The Toton housing appeal concerned Bloor Homes Limited and Broxtowe Borough Council, which had not decided application 25/00371/OUT within the prescribed period. The council’s committee said in July that it would have supported the scheme once objections from National Highways and Nottinghamshire County Council were removed, with suitable conditions and a legal agreement in place. The inquiry continued because the transport authorities still required assurance about cumulative traffic.
This decision matters for more than the 420 homes themselves. The new permission helps unlock a strategic growth area around Toton, but it depends on detailed modelling, mitigation and legally secured contributions for homes, schools and transport. It should not be mistaken for approval of the neighbouring Toton North, Toton East or Chetwynd Barracks developments, or for permission to start building immediately.
Why the Toton housing appeal succeeded
The Inspector identified three principal questions: whether the development could operate safely on the highways network, whether supporting infrastructure was secured, and whether the overall planning balance favoured development. It is a substantial environmental impact assessment scheme covering fields beside the B6003, with the Toton Lane tram stop and park-and-ride close by.
The proposal already sat within an allocated growth area, so the central difficulty was not simply the principle of housing. Traffic movements from Toton West would interact with the A52, Bramcote and Bardills roundabouts, the proposed Toton Link Road and development on surrounding land. The impact of each component had to be assessed against what might eventually be delivered across the wider growth area.
A52 traffic objections and the strategic mitigation condition
Modelling of the 420-home site on its own was eventually accepted by the highway parties. Their remaining objection concerned the combined effects of Toton West, Toton East, Toton North and Chetwynd Barracks, particularly the timing, phasing and funding of the future link road and its connection to Chetwynd Barracks. The Toton housing appeal therefore turned on whether a practical mechanism could secure further work and appropriate improvements before later phases progressed.
The parties agreed a Strategic Highway Assessment and Mitigation Strategy, known as SHAMS. This requires the cumulative impacts across the wider area to be modelled, building on the earlier assessments, and the necessary road improvements, funding responsibilities, phasing and trigger points to be identified. The Inspector considered that a condition could secure the strategy adequately, with the highway authorities consulted as the details are considered.
The decision also sets a limit on occupation of no more than 300 dwellings until the strategy has been approved. The Inspector said no reserved matters application could be approved until SHAMS had been submitted to the council. This distinction is important: a substantial outline consent does not give an unconditional right to occupy every home before cumulative transport issues are resolved.
Why a planning condition mattered more than the undertaking
The developer had offered a unilateral planning undertaking dealing with the same strategic highways mechanism. But the Inspector concluded that an enforceable condition was sufficient. Because the separate obligation was not necessary to make the scheme acceptable, it failed the first statutory test in regulation 122 of the Community Infrastructure Levy Regulations 2010 and was given no weight.
That is a useful practical point from this Toton housing appeal. A section 106 agreement is not automatically the better means of securing a commitment, even for a strategic proposal. Where an appropriately worded condition meets the policy and legal tests, duplication through an obligation may not be justified. Our section 106 agreement guide explains why obligations have a distinct legal role.
Thirty per cent affordable housing and education contributions
The principal legal agreement includes on-site affordable housing at 30 per cent, split between 66 per cent Affordable Rent and 34 per cent intermediate housing. If registered providers cannot be secured, the agreement provides a stated financial alternative of £85,000 per dwelling. The final mix and actual delivery remain subject to the agreement and subsequent detailed approvals.
Education contributions include £4,179 per dwelling for primary provision, £4,829 for secondary places and £489 for special educational needs and disabilities. Other commitments cover open space management, bus services, community transport, cycling and walking links, bus stops, monitoring and undergrounding overhead electricity lines. The Inspector accepted these contributions against the statutory planning-obligation tests.
The Toton housing appeal also underlines the importance of viability and tenure at an early stage. A 30 per cent affordable housing commitment on a maximum 420-home scheme could represent up to 126 affordable homes, but that is a calculation based on the stated percentage, not a separate permission for exactly 126 units. Read our affordable housing planning guide for the wider policy considerations.
The housing supply balance in Broxtowe
Inspector Gilbert recorded Broxtowe’s five-year housing land supply at 4.85 years. The Inspector gave substantial weight to providing new market and affordable homes, describing the benefit as up to 420 homes within the next five years
. The estimated construction employment, accessible location, undergrounding of overhead power lines and public transport measures also weighed in the scheme’s favour, although the proposal would change an agricultural landscape.
The Inspector found limited environmental harm from the loss of some best and most versatile farmland, but considered the wider benefits more persuasive once transport and infrastructure mitigation were secured. A neighbourhood plan point also mattered: the relevant plan did not contain allocations meeting its identified housing requirement, reducing the weight of the specific protective provision in the revised national policy framework.
What happens after the Toton housing appeal?
The outline permission does not approve the eventual appearance, layout, scale or landscaping. Those details require reserved matters decisions, and conditions require, among other things, environmental management, surface-water drainage, archaeology, tree protection, access works, noise controls, a bus stop strategy and a travel plan. The statutory biodiversity gain plan must also be approved before development begins unless an exemption applies, which the Inspector said was not the case here.
For developers and objectors, the Toton housing appeal shows why highway objections can be overcome through detailed evidence and a credible phased delivery mechanism, but not through vague assurances. For residents it offers a route to new housing while preserving control over access, environmental details and key infrastructure. It remains necessary to examine later council decisions and the actual discharge of conditions.
The official Broxtowe public inquiry page sets out the hearing background and evidence. The Planning Inspectorate appeal record 6006412 provides the official case reference. Inspector Joanna Gilbert’s decision, issued on 2 November 2026, is the primary source for this report. The quotation above is drawn from Planning Inspectorate material reproduced under the Open Government Licence v3.0. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase.

0 Comments