The Bishops Lodge appeal has been allowed for a storage development on a former poultry site near Billericay, Essex, after a fresh Planning Inspectorate hearing. Inspector I Dyer issued the decision on 16 November 2026, granting permission for five new storage buildings and the conversion of a remaining poultry shed to Use Class B8.
The application had already been through an earlier appeal. The Inspector’s decision of 19 December 2025 was quashed by order of the High Court, so this was a new determination on the planning merits rather than an appeal against that Inspector. The parties were able to address the revised August 2026 National Planning Policy Framework.
The Bishops Lodge appeal is especially revealing because both sides accepted that the land was grey belt, yet the proposal still failed the Framework’s sustainable-location criterion. It succeeded instead through very special circumstances, with binding conditions restricting the size and number of vehicles visiting the rural site.
Why the Bishops Lodge appeal was decided again
The site at Broomwood Lane, Ramsden Heath, had been used for poultry farming. The proposal involved demolishing five poultry sheds, erecting five new buildings for storage and distribution, converting one existing shed for the same B8 use, and providing security fencing and gates. Chelmsford City Council refused application 25/00253/FUL and the applicants, Mr J Murphy and Corporate Spec Ltd, appealed.
The earlier appeal decision was set aside by the High Court. The decision letter does not identify the High Court parties, neutral citation or detailed grounds of the challenge, so its reasoning cannot safely be attributed to a named judgment. Inspector Dyer explained that the previous decision was treated as though it had not been made and that the merits were assessed afresh.
Following the High Court order, a hearing took place on 9 September 2026. The parties commented on the updated national policy and agreed a revised statement of common ground. This mattered because Chelmsford’s adopted local policies predated the definition of grey belt and were therefore less aligned with the new Framework.
Grey belt agreed, but not enough
The Bishops Lodge appeal did not involve a dispute about whether the former poultry farm satisfied the grey belt definition. The Inspector agreed that it did not strongly contribute to the relevant Green Belt purposes, and that its development would not fundamentally undermine the remaining Green Belt in the plan area.
That was only the first of the necessary criteria under Policy GB7(g). The Inspector still had to consider whether there was a demonstrable unmet need for this type of development and whether the scheme was in a sustainable location. Those two questions, rather than the grey belt classification itself, determined the result of the policy test.
On need, the Council argued that existing and emerging employment allocations would provide adequate floorspace. The Inspector examined employment land evidence and concluded that future supply from outline permissions and the emerging plan remained uncertain, particularly for B8 storage. Inspector Dyer concluded that “a demonstrable unmet need for B8 uses exists”. Readers considering emerging allocations may find our guide to the weight of emerging Local Plans helpful.
Why the rural transport test failed
The Bishops Lodge appeal site is reached by narrow rural lanes, without convenient footways, lighting or practical public transport alternatives. The Inspector described the location as unsuitable for a generic warehousing or distribution operation, where heavy vehicles and staff movements might otherwise be expected.
The Inspector found that the site was not a sustainable location for the proposed development under Policy TR3. Consequently, it failed the transport element of GB7(g), even though grey belt status and unmet B8 need were established. That failure meant the scheme was inappropriate development in the Green Belt, requiring very special circumstances to justify approval.
The scheme also involved considerably taller storage buildings than the former poultry sheds. Although their footprints were similar, the increased height and bulk would reduce spatial openness. Some buildings and fencing would be visible from nearby lanes and paths, and mitigation could only reduce rather than eliminate that Green Belt harm.
How very special circumstances were established
The decisive distinction was between a generic B8 warehouse use and the particular operation that could be secured by conditions. The appellants intended a low-intensity storage business with limited trips, no permanently based staff and security patrols already operating in the area. The Inspector accepted that carefully framed conditions could make the actual traffic impact no worse than the lawful agricultural fallback.
The Bishops Lodge appeal conditions limit vehicular movements to 12 per day, require a movement log available to the Council within 24 hours of a written request and cap vehicle lengths at 8.01 metres. A service management plan is also required. Operational trips are limited to daytime weekday and Saturday morning hours, apart from security visits. These controls are fundamental to the planning balance, not optional operating advice.
The Inspector also considered the remaining lawful agricultural use of the site, including potential open storage, when comparing what might happen without the scheme. Our guide to fallback positions in planning explains why an alternative lawful scenario can materially alter the assessment of harm.
Despite continuing harm to Green Belt openness, the Inspector gave significant weight to the economic benefits and substantial weight to bringing the largely unproductive site into use under enforceable limits. The Inspector concluded that the other considerations clearly outweighed the substantial Green Belt harm. Accordingly, the required very special circumstances existed.
What the decision means for other Green Belt sites
It would be wrong to describe the Bishops Lodge appeal as blanket support for warehousing on grey belt land. The scheme actually failed the grey belt exception for sustainable location. What tipped the balance was the particular unmet B8 need, the assessed agricultural fallback, constrained site operations and enforceable vehicle limits.
The Inspector also considered the retrospective elements of the works. The Inspector found no evidence of a deliberate attempt to evade planning control, with the parties agreeing that an error had been made through unfamiliarity with the system. The retrospective aspect was therefore neutral in the Inspector’s assessment, rather than an added planning benefit.
Other conditions cover gate and fencing details, building materials, ecology, lighting, tree protection, on-site turning and parking arrangements. The decision permits the scheme subject to those safeguards, but it does not establish that unrestricted B8 use would be acceptable in a similar rural location.
The Bishops Lodge appeal is a timely example of why readers need to distinguish a site’s designation from all the separate tests required by national policy. The Inspector’s full decision is published on the Planning Inspectorate appeal page for APP/W1525/W/25/3371126. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase.

0 Comments