Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Burford barn appeal fails after radical rebuild

An agricultural-use certificate failed despite an Inspector rejecting the council's original reasoning, and the council's separate costs claim also failed.

The Burford barn appeal has failed after a Planning Inspector decided that rebuilding a former agricultural structure had effectively extinguished its previous lawful use. The decision issued on 9th October 2026 is especially notable because the Inspector rejected the council’s original reason for refusal.

In the Burford barn appeal, the applicant at Sturt Farm, Oxford Road, Burford, argued that a building previously used for deer and livestock storage retained an agricultural use. West Oxfordshire District Council maintained that an adjoining residential conversion had opened a new planning chapter and removed any earlier rights.

In the Burford barn appeal, Inspector David Jones disagreed with that explanation, yet dismissed the certificate appeal after examining the physical transformation of the barn. In a separate decision, he refused the council’s application for its appeal costs, producing two different outcomes from the same dispute.

Unsure whether an agricultural building retains its lawful use? Planning Geek can review its planning history and physical alterations. Contact Planning Geek to discuss an evidence-based appraisal.

Burford barn appeal turns on building identity

The section 191 application, reference 25/01131/CLE, was made on 30th April 2025 by Mr S Fitzsimmons of Sturt Farm Burford Ltd. It sought a certificate establishing the existing agricultural use of a building in the farm courtyard. The council refused the application on 11th September 2025.

Sturt Farm once contained several agricultural buildings. Many had been converted into dwellings, leaving relatively few apparently agricultural structures. The appeal building was a blockwork structure with an asymmetrical pitched roof and a small enclosed area of land to the front.

The previous owner provided a June 2016 statutory declaration recording that the building had housed livestock between August 1999 and that date. The appellant said it had originally sheltered deer, subsequently storing feed and bedding for pigs, chickens, sheep and cattle. More recently it had stored tools and building materials associated with neighbouring residential conversion works.

That historic use was relevant. However, an existing-use certificate concerns the lawful use of the particular building and land at the date of application. The crucial question became whether the current structure was the same building and what activity had actually taken place in it.

Why the council’s first ‘planning chapter’ argument failed

For the Burford barn appeal, the council’s stated refusal reason relied on a 2019 prior approval, reference 19/01515/PN56, to convert barns 8, 10 and 12 into four dwellings. Drawings attached to that approval showed the disputed building as due to be demolished. The council argued that implementation of the conversion created a new planning chapter which extinguished the agricultural use.

In the Burford barn appeal, the Inspector instead considered a retrospective full planning permission issued in November 2024, reference 24/02076/FUL, which authorised the completed conversion of neighbouring Barn 8. Crucially, that later permission left the contested building outside the red line and did not require its demolition.

On the plans and the site evidence, the Inspector found that Barn 8 had been authorised and completed under the 2024 permission. That meant the 2019 prior approval was not the controlling consent for the actual development and could not, by itself, determine the lawful use of a separate structure.

The refusal reason had therefore misidentified the relevant planning sequence. This illustrates why consultants should scrutinise successive permissions and red lines at converted farm complexes rather than assuming the earliest approval governs everything that exists today.

Nevertheless, defeating the council’s only stated reason was not enough to secure the requested certificate. The Inspector had to decide whether agricultural use of the building now standing had been demonstrated on the balance of probabilities.

A substantially reconstructed building was not the original barn

Photographs taken in February 2020 showed a comparatively modest farm building. The appeal structure had since been transformed. Its height was raised, an entirely new asymmetrical roof was constructed, and the rear was extended so that the building physically joined the adjacent residential conversion.

Some fragments of the earlier walling appeared to remain, but the Inspector considered that most of the external blockwork was new. The building had insulation, a domestic-style window and glazing, new openings and internal walls forming separate spaces. It also contained a toilet, sink and electrical fittings.

The appellant characterised the works as re-roofing, blocking openings and internal alterations. Comparing dated photographs with his inspection, the Inspector decided that description did not capture the scale of reconstruction. In practical terms, the original structure had ceased to exist, notwithstanding the retention of limited pieces of fabric.

The decision applied principles considered in Oates v Secretary of State [2018] EWCA Civ 2229, including the loss of lawful use rights where an original building ceases to exist and is replaced. It also discussed Jennings Motors Ltd v Secretary of State for the Environment [1982] 2 WLR 131 and the circumstances in which physical and functional change opens a fresh chapter in a site’s planning history.

The Inspector found that the replacement building’s altered appearance, glazing and interior were inconsistent with continuation of the original livestock use. He concluded that lawful use rights attached to the original structure had been lost when it was replaced in substance.

Storage for building works did not prove existing agriculture

A second weakness was the lack of direct evidence of farming within the rebuilt structure. The council’s visits in February 2024 and June 2025 recorded materials and tools connected with conversion work, not animals or agricultural supplies. The appellant said the non-agricultural storage was temporary, but that did not establish an actual agricultural use of the replacement building.

The Inspector considered section 55(2)(e) of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, which specifies certain uses of agricultural land and associated buildings that do not amount to development. Even though lawful agricultural use may be available in principle under that provision, it did not show that the structure had the claimed existing agricultural use at the application date.

The historic declaration supported farming activity in the earlier building. It could not by itself establish continuous agricultural use in a building that did not then exist in its present form. Without adequate evidence about the replacement, the certificate test was not met.

Accordingly, the appeal was dismissed under section 195. The council’s refusal stood, but on materially different grounds from the single reason given in its decision notice.

West Oxfordshire’s application for appeal costs rejected

In the related costs decision, the council sought a full award against the appellant. It argued that the certificate appeal was so weak that it had no reasonable prospect of succeeding and that pursuing it was unreasonable.

The Inspector rejected that argument. The applicant had responded to the council’s original refusal reason, had produced evidence on the subject and had actually persuaded the Inspector that the reason was unsound. Additional concerns about physical reconstruction and current use were developed later in the council’s appeal statement.

The Inspector also remarked on the length and repetition of parts of the council’s statement of case. He found that the appellant’s arguments had not been unreasonable merely because the evidence was ultimately insufficient to secure a certificate.

Costs in planning appeals concern unreasonable conduct causing unnecessary or wasted expense. An unsuccessful case does not automatically satisfy that test. Here the applicant’s decision to appeal had a reasonable basis, even though the overall statutory burden was not ultimately met.

Implications for farms, Class Q sites and lawful-use applications

Owners should prepare a photographic and measured chronology of alterations whenever they intend to rely on an earlier agricultural use. If a structure has been largely reconstructed, the identity of the building may itself be decisive before questions about the use class are reached.

Evidence of current use matters separately. Dated agricultural records, livestock or feed information, leases, contemporaneous photographs and an explanation of stored materials can help distinguish agriculture from construction-related storage or other activities. A broad history of the farm does not prove the status of every building.

When neighbouring barns have been converted, check each approval, later variation and implemented red line. Do not assume a prior approval for one structure necessarily affects rights over an adjacent building, and do not assume retention of a small amount of fabric preserves every historic use entitlement.

The Inspector’s analysis is fact-specific, not a blanket rule that substantial refurbishment always extinguishes rights. The combination of physical reconstruction and lack of evidence about agricultural use of the resulting building drove this particular decision.

National lawful development certificate guidance remains the starting point for the burden of proof. For further discussion, see Planning Geek’s agricultural planning guidance and change of use resources.

Main decision and costs ruling

Both decisions relate to Burford barn appeal APP/D3125/X/25/3375634, decided on 9th October 2026. The official Planning Inspectorate case record provides the appeal reference. The Inspector’s decision should not be confused with a binding court judgment, although it applies existing court authorities.

0 Comments

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news