A carbon offset appeal at a Berkshire garden centre has succeeded after a planning Inspector rejected a council’s demand for a £7,560 payment towards net zero carbon. The ruling turns on the difference between an adopted local plan policy and a more demanding supplementary planning document.
Inspector E Worley allowed proposals to extend and refurbish Stubbings Nursery and Café at Stubbings Estate, near Maidenhead, on 18 November 2026. The Royal Borough of Windsor and Maidenhead had refused permission because the applicant had not entered into a section 106 agreement to pay for carbon offsetting. A separate application for appeal costs was refused.
The carbon offset appeal is important because it does not dismiss climate-change measures or the principle of developer contributions. Instead, it asks whether the particular financial requirement was supported by a sufficiently clear adopted policy and met the statutory tests for a planning obligation.
What the carbon offset appeal was about
Application 24/03128 proposed the demolition of existing outbuildings, improvements to the nursery and café, additional toilets and service facilities, two new entrance porches and an opening through a wall. The changes were to an established commercial operation at Stubbings Estate, where the nursery and café also occupy part of a walled garden beside a Grade II listed building.
The main issue before the Inspector was not the general acceptability of a nursery extension. It was whether the scheme contained suitable measures to reduce carbon emissions, and in particular whether the council could insist on a cash payment under its July 2024 Sustainability Supplementary Planning Document (SPD).
Local Plan Policy SP2 requires development to demonstrate measures to adapt to and mitigate climate change, referring applicants to supplementary guidance. The SPD goes further by seeking an energy statement and, where on-site measures cannot deliver net zero carbon, a payment to offset the remaining emissions through a section 106 obligation.
The appellant submitted an Energy and Sustainability Statement identifying design measures and on-site renewable technology. The council nevertheless calculated that £7,560 would be needed to achieve its net zero objective. The carbon offset appeal therefore focused on whether that demand had a sound policy and legal basis, rather than whether the extension should take any energy-saving steps at all.
Why the £7,560 contribution failed
The Inspector pointed to national Planning Practice Guidance on planning obligations. Policies creating developer contributions are expected to appear in examined development plans. Supplementary planning documents can explain an adopted policy, but cannot introduce a new formulaic planning-obligation requirement that has not been tested through that process.
That distinction was decisive in the carbon offset appeal. Inspector Worley found that Policy SP2 did not expressly require net zero carbon emissions and did not itself say that applicants must make a financial payment where on-site measures fell short. The more demanding payment obligation originated in the SPD.
As the Inspector put it, the adopted policy did not expressly require development to achieve net zero carbon emissions
. The Inspector gave limited weight to the additional requirement contained in the supplementary guidance because it was not clearly derived from the local plan.
The council’s wider Environment and Climate Strategy was relevant as a material consideration, but it was not itself part of the development plan either. Nor did the national objective of net zero by 2050 cure the gap in the particular policy basis for this contribution.
The carbon offset appeal also required the Inspector to apply Regulation 122 of the Community Infrastructure Levy Regulations 2010. A planning obligation must be necessary to make the development acceptable, directly related to the development, and fairly and reasonably related in scale and kind. Here, because the underlying policy did not establish the need for the contribution, the council had not demonstrated that the payment satisfied those tests.
Planning Geek’s guide to supplementary plans and SPDs explains how supplementary guidance differs from development-plan policy. Its section 106 planning obligations guide also explains why every requested contribution must satisfy the statutory tests, even if a council has adopted a formula for calculating it.
Carbon reduction still secured through conditions
Allowing the appeal did not mean that the applicant could abandon the sustainability measures it had proposed. The Inspector found that the extension would incorporate measures to reduce emissions and so accord with the aim of Policy SP2, notwithstanding a degree of conflict with the SPD’s advice on carbon offset payments.
Conditions require the development to follow its submitted Energy and Sustainability Statement. They also require an on-site waste management plan and construction strategy, including attention to the waste hierarchy, locally sourced low-carbon materials, recycled content and embodied carbon.
Further conditions require details of the air-source heat pumps and an assessment under the relevant installation standard before development proceeds above ground level. The pumps must then be installed before first use and retained. This makes the carbon offset appeal a good example of an Inspector distinguishing enforceable on-site carbon measures from a financial obligation without a demonstrated policy foundation.
The Inspector also considered the setting of Grade II listed Stubbings House. The council had not identified heritage harm from the proposed extensions and works, and the Inspector agreed that they would not prejudice the listed building’s setting.
Why the costs application was refused
The appellant also sought a full award of costs. It argued that the council had acted unreasonably by seeking the payment despite other appeal decisions that appeared to reject similar requirements. Costs do not automatically follow an allowed planning appeal: the applicant must show unreasonable behaviour that caused unnecessary or wasted expense.
The Inspector was critical of the extent to which the council had engaged with the appellant’s argument about Policy SP2 and the SPD. But the council had relied on several appeal decisions which it considered supported its approach. Although it had not been shown that those decisions were directly comparable, the Inspector found that they demonstrated the council’s approach had been accepted in other cases, so it was not unreasonable for the authority to follow that line. The separate costs application was therefore refused.
That distinction deserves attention. Winning the carbon offset appeal establishes the outcome of this planning application; it does not establish that the council was automatically liable for the expense of contesting it. The decision on costs was a separate judgment about procedural behaviour, not a reversal of the planning merits.
What developers and councils should take from it
The most useful practical lesson is to trace any requested carbon-offset payment back to the wording of the adopted development plan. Does the policy actually require net zero carbon and a financial contribution? Does the supplementary document merely explain an existing policy, or has it added an obligation that the plan itself does not contain?
Applicants should then test whether the particular payment is necessary and proportionate under Regulation 122, rather than assuming an SPD calculation settles the point. Councils should make sure adopted policies give a transparent foundation for the contributions they seek, and that supplementary documents are not being asked to do the work of an examined plan.
The Stubbings ruling is specific to the wording of Windsor and Maidenhead’s Policy SP2, the evidence before Inspector Worley and the particular development. It does not mean carbon-offset contributions are unlawful everywhere. Authorities with different adopted policy wording or stronger evidence may be in a different position.
The appeal was allowed under reference 6008865, with conditions. The separate costs claim was refused. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase. Relevant national guidance can be read in the government’s planning obligations guidance and plan-making guidance on supplementary planning documents.

0 Comments