A Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL) calculation appeal has failed after an appointed Valuation Office decision-maker rejected an attempt to use a negative office figure to reduce a hotel charge. The CIL calculation was disputed because office and hotel floorspace attracted different charging rates. HM Revenue and Customs published the redacted decision on 29 October 2026. Although it was decided on 3 September, its reasoning has only now been placed in the public collection of Community Infrastructure Levy decisions.
The dispute concerned a mixed-use scheme involving part conversion of Class E offices to a Class C1 hotel, retained affordable workspace, facade improvements, an altered fifth floor and a two-storey extension with roof plant. The location, parties and actual liability were redacted, so the case cannot responsibly be described as a decision about a named building or council.
For developers and their advisers, I would keep the practical point narrow: this is about the treatment of different CIL charging rates. The appointed person held that a negative result for retained office floorspace was not a transferable credit against positive hotel liability. That is different from saying that existing floorspace deductions have no value, or that every negative result must be ignored in every possible calculation.
Why the CIL calculation appeal failed
The dispute is recorded as CIL appeal 1894440. Planning permission had been granted for the proposed mixed hotel and office development. The charging authority issued a liability notice, and the developer first requested a review under regulation 113 of the Community Infrastructure Levy Regulations 2010. After the authority maintained its assessment, the developer brought a regulation 114 appeal.
At first, two points were disputed. One concerned the gross internal floor areas taken from the planning drawings. The other concerned the correct treatment of the results generated for retained office space when a different rate applied to the new hotel element. During the appeal, the developer withdrew the challenge to the floor area inputs and accepted the values used by the authority for the statutory calculation.
That withdrawal is important. The appointed person did not rule on whether measurements from the approved drawings were preferable to the separate area survey offered by the developer. The CIL calculation appeal therefore decided a narrower legal and arithmetic issue: could the negative amount generated at the office rate be deducted from the positive charge at the hotel rate?
What the law says about different CIL rates
In England, regulation 40 requires the collecting authority to calculate the chargeable amount under Schedule 1 to the 2010 Regulations. Paragraph 1 calculates separate amounts at each relevant charging rate and then aggregates amounts chargeable at those rates. It also provides a minimum-charge rule. These are not discretionary calculations invented by a particular council.
The formula uses gross internal area of the development, the area subject to a particular rate, qualifying retained parts of existing buildings and eligible demolished space. The inputs commonly labelled G, GR, KR and E perform different jobs. Our CIL calculation guide explains the wider method, while the CIL change of use guide considers existing buildings and conversion schemes.
Here, both parties accepted that applying the Schedule 1 formula generated a negative deemed net area for the office component and a positive result for the hotel component. The developer said the negative office sum should form part of the aggregate, reducing the total bill. The charging authority said the regulations did not create a negative CIL liability or a credit transferable between rates.
The appointed person considered the argument that the legislation does not expressly require every negative interim figure to be reset to zero. They accepted that no such express instruction appeared in Schedule 1. Nevertheless, they concluded the statute did not provide for that negative office figure to be carried across as a credit against the hotel rate. The distinction between the mathematical output and an amount actually chargeable was central.
Why the developer’s argument was rejected
The CIL calculation decision examined the sequence required by Schedule 1. Before the figures can be aggregated, an amount chargeable at each relevant rate must be established. The developer’s interpretation would effectively use a negative result from one land use to reduce the liability calculated for another use, even though no provision describes that negative figure as a credit, repayment or transferable amount.
In paragraph 52, the appointed person said the regulations “do not provide for the negative office result to be applied as a credit”. The appeal was dismissed and the original liability notice was upheld. That is a clear outcome, but it remains an individual statutory appeal decision, not a High Court judgment or a generally binding precedent.
The decision does not identify the amount of the assessed levy, the gross areas or the local charging schedule. All of those details are redacted. It would therefore be misleading to calculate a hypothetical saving or claim the developer lost a specific sum. The public decision supports the point about methodology, not a comparison of actual financial outcomes for this scheme.
What mixed-use development teams should check
If I were checking a project combining offices, hotels, retail or other uses, I would test the CIL calculation at each relevant charging rate rather than treat it as a single net floorspace exercise. Retained lawful floorspace, eligible demolition and the classification of the approved development all matter. The correct calculation will depend on the actual permission, the in-use evidence, the charging schedule and the version of the regulations applying to the case.
The appeal also shows the value of resolving basic measurement questions early. The developer ultimately withdrew the floor area dispute, leaving only the interpretation of the formula. Plans, measured surveys and documented lawful occupation can all be important evidence when a liability notice is reviewed. Our existing buildings and CIL floorspace guide explains the evidence requirements in more detail.
A negative interim result should not automatically be treated as a portable credit simply because the arithmetic produces a minus sign. Equally, teams should not read the outcome as a reason to disregard legitimate deductions for existing buildings. The correct question is where the particular deduction operates within the prescribed formula and whether the legislation permits the claimed adjustment across separate rates.
Appeal route and wider significance
There is a formal route for disputing a CIL chargeable amount, but it is different from appealing a planning refusal. Under regulation 114, an eligible appellant must first request a regulation 113 review. The legislation places limits on when a chargeable amount appeal can be brought, including a 60-day period from the original liability notice and rules relating to development commencing.
This CIL calculation appeal is therefore useful to developers, viability specialists and council CIL teams well beyond the anonymous appeal site. It illustrates why they need to separate evidential disputes about areas from legal disputes about how the results are combined. It also gives a concrete example of the difference between a negative input, a negative intermediate output and a recognised chargeable amount.
The publication date deserves equal care. The decision was made on 3 September 2026 but first added to the government’s public collection on 29 October 2026. It is not a new law taking effect today. It is newly available reasoning on an existing charging formula, and it should be applied cautiously to other schemes with their own permissions, rate categories and floorspace facts. For the practical appeal procedure, see our CIL appeals guide.

0 Comments