Appeal validity rates improved substantially in the latest Planning Inspectorate statistics published on 19 November 2026, but a significant minority of written-representation appeals still take more than a year to reach a decision. The official figures apply to the Inspectorate’s work in England and Wales. They measure whether appeals are properly lodged and how quickly decisions are made, not the proportion of appeals that succeed.
For appeals received between April and June 2026, 66.7 per cent were recorded as valid on first submission, compared with a revised 52.3 per cent for the same quarter in 2025. That improvement is encouraging for applicants and advisers. However, 13.5 per cent of appeals decided wholly by written representations during the 12 months to September 2026 took more than 52 weeks from validation to decision.
The contrast matters commercially. Developers and landowners need an appeal that is correctly submitted as well as a realistic timetable for a decision, because the statutory right to appeal is only the beginning of a potentially expensive wait. The latest appeal validity rates also conceal wide differences between types of appeal and the limitations of the Inspectorate’s underlying data.
Appeal validity rates rise for four consecutive quarters
The Planning Inspectorate’s 19 November ministerial measures release gives quarterly first-submission validity figures of 52.3, 53.3, 59.3, 65.2 and 66.7 per cent, from April to June 2025 through April to June 2026. That represents an improvement of 14.4 percentage points over the year. These figures are revised as appeals are validated, so they should not be compared uncritically with unrevised figures quoted in earlier bulletins.
Appeal validity rates measure acceptance at the first submission stage. They do not measure how many appeals are allowed, whether a planning argument is persuasive, or whether an appeal meets a particular legal deadline. The measure also excludes cases that have not yet been validated from the denominator, and 224 duplicate cases were removed from the relevant period. The figures should therefore be used as an indicator of administrative performance rather than a precise forecast for an individual appeal.
The accompanying background quality report explains that the Inspectorate uses a proxy based on the dates on which appeals are received and validly received. A defective submission corrected on the same date could be counted as valid first time. This may slightly overstate first-submission success, and the publication remains classified as Official Statistics in Development.
Why enforcement and planning appeals perform differently
The annual breakdown from July 2025 to June 2026 highlights why the overall appeal validity rates should not be treated as a single rule of thumb. Only 37.6 per cent of enforcement notice appeals were recorded as valid first time, across 2,543 received cases. The comparable figures were 61.0 per cent for ordinary planning appeals, involving 9,490 cases, and 72.4 per cent for householder appeals, involving 4,022.
Lawful development certificate appeals showed 78.3 per cent first-submission validity across 970 cases. Tree Preservation Order appeals recorded 46.8 per cent. These are different legal and procedural routes with different supporting evidence and deadlines, so the disparity does not by itself prove that one set of appellants is more careful than another. It does indicate where thorough preparation and a final document check could be particularly valuable.
For enforcement proceedings, the appeal must normally be received before the enforcement notice takes effect. An appellant cannot safely assume that extra time will be offered to correct a defective notice of appeal. Our guide to enforcement notices and appeal grounds explains the different routes, while Planning Geek’s planning appeals guide distinguishes the various statutory appeal deadlines.
Long-running written appeals remain a problem
The new publication gives an 18-week median for appeals decided wholly by written representations during the 12 months from October 2025 to September 2026. Yet the 90th percentile was 66 weeks and the maximum recorded duration was 392 weeks. The extremes reflect a long tail of cases and should not be mistaken for the expected duration of a new, straightforward planning appeal.
A separate table divides those written-representation decisions into elapsed-time bands: 59.7 per cent took no more than 20 weeks, another 13.6 per cent took between 20 and 26 weeks, 13.2 per cent took between 26 and 52 weeks, and 13.5 per cent took more than 52 weeks. Those categories total 100 per cent. They explain why a reasonably quick median does not remove the commercial risk of a much longer case.
For hearings, the median during the same 12-month period was 23 weeks, and for inquiries it was 26 weeks. These are measured from a valid appeal to its decision, not from the date a developer first considers whether to challenge a council. Applicants should therefore allow separately for preparation, any validation issues, the appeal itself and the work needed after a decision.
Recent decisions show improving consistency, but not certainty
The overall median for all appeals decided from July to September 2026 was 18 weeks, and the 90th percentile stood at 61 weeks. That compares with a 90th percentile of 71 weeks in January to March 2026 and 69 weeks in April to June. The narrowing of the spread is a useful development, although cases in different quarters are not necessarily identical in difficulty, complexity or procedure.
The same publication reports that 1,046 appeal cases were quality assured during July to September 2026, roughly 26 per cent of the 4,099 decisions issued in that period. This includes supervisory reviews and routine scrutiny of decisions prepared by appeals officers and trainee Inspectors. It is not a finding that the other cases were defective, nor does the percentage tell us how many individual decisions were legally wrong.
For customer satisfaction, the Inspectorate says: No new valid customer satisfaction score is available for this reporting period.
That is an important gap when evaluating how effectively the service works for applicants, councils and interested residents. The release also identifies missing procedure information for some cases, so its tables have stated limitations.
What appeal applicants should take from the figures
The practical lesson from the appeal validity rates is to treat an appeal as a properly assembled legal submission, not simply the electronic equivalent of posting a planning statement. Identify the correct appeal route and deadline, ensure the relevant decision or notice is properly described, check what information must accompany the application and confirm that the submission has actually been received.
Applicants should also make a financial allowance for delays beyond the headline median. A long-running appeal can affect land purchase options, development appraisals, funding agreements and the timing of professional reports. Some costs may need to be revisited if evidence or policy changes while a case is pending. This is a programme-management point, not evidence that an appeal will succeed or fail.
The appeal validity rates reported on 19 November are encouraging, but they do not remove the need to distinguish submission validity, lawful deadlines, procedural stages and the eventual planning judgment. The Inspectorate’s statistics provide a valuable national benchmark; an individual site’s planning risk must still be assessed from the application history, reasons for refusal, evidence and relevant policy.

0 Comments