Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Pub HMO enforcement notice amended

Havering's notice against a Romford pub flat HMO is upheld with one access requirement deleted for ambiguous wording

A pub HMO enforcement notice in Romford has been amended after an Inspector ruled that Havering Council’s demand for “free and unfettered access” between the pub and an upstairs flat was too imprecise to enforce. The rest of the notice, requiring the unauthorised HMO use to cease and related internal fittings to be removed, was upheld.

Inspector A Hunter issued the decision on 19 November 2026 in appeal APP/B5480/C/25/3372055. It concerns Flat 2 above the Durham Arms on Brentwood Road, where the council alleged an unauthorised change from accommodation ancillary to the public house to a small house in multiple occupation, Use Class C4.

The pub HMO enforcement decision makes an important distinction. The appellant did not obtain planning permission for the HMO, and most of the requirements of the 31 July 2025 notice survived. But one particular instruction failed because its wording did not tell the recipient clearly enough what compliance would involve.

Why pub HMO enforcement succeeded only in part

The appeal was brought under ground (f) of section 174(2) of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990. That ground concerns whether the steps required by an enforcement notice exceed what is necessary to remedy the breach of planning control, or the injury to amenity it has caused. It is not a general opportunity to obtain retrospective planning permission.

No ground (a) appeal was before the Inspector. That meant arguments about the planning merits of the accommodation could not determine the case. Inspector Hunter treated the notice as seeking to remedy the unauthorised change of use, rather than merely securing improvements to its amenity impacts.

The council’s notice identified four sets of steps: cease the C4 HMO use, remove internal furniture and facilities associated with that use, provide access between the accommodation and the public house downstairs, and clear resulting debris. The appellant accepted that the use had ceased and did not challenge the first or final requirements.

Kitchen, bathroom and locks still had to go

In the pub HMO enforcement appeal, the appellant argued that removing the kitchen, bathroom and door locks went too far. It said the upstairs rooms had since been repurposed as welfare facilities for staff, with a space for rest and meals, drinking water and toilet facilities. The appeal therefore raised the distinction between undoing an unlawful residential use and providing facilities lawfully ancillary to a pub.

On the site visit the Inspector found a kitchen, a bathroom with a bath and shower, a separate toilet, and locks on internal doors. There was no evidence that those items existed before the unauthorised HMO use commenced. The claimed staff welfare arrangement was a subsequent use of the accommodation, so the Inspector did not accept it as proof that the council’s removal requirement was excessive.

The appellant also argued that removing the toilet door lock would compromise privacy. But the requirement extended to removal of the toilet itself, so that argument did not change the conclusion. The Inspector noted that a separately lawful ancillary staff facility might later have its own kitchen or bathroom fittings. That possibility did not establish that the existing installations could be retained without first complying with the notice.

Health and safety arguments did not alter the Inspector’s approach. The appellant supplied no statutory basis proving that these particular facilities were legally required, and did not explain why other facilities elsewhere in the premises could not be used. This was a decision about the evidence and the particular notice, not a general prohibition on staff toilets or kitchens in pubs.

Why the access requirement was deleted

The decisive finding concerned the wording of the third requirement. Havering wanted “free and unfettered access” between Flat 2 and the public house on the ground floor. The Inspector found three intervening doors, two of which had locks, but the instruction did not specify exactly how the access ought to be arranged.

As the decision puts it, “It is not clear to me what is meant by ‘free’ access”. The Inspector also considered that “unfettered” did not accurately define the access sought. A recipient could therefore be left uncertain about how to comply. This was a problem with the instruction itself, not a finding that a separate HMO use had become lawful.

The pub HMO enforcement notice was consequently varied to delete that third requirement in full. The final debris-removal requirement was renumbered and adjusted to refer only to the remaining steps. The notice was otherwise upheld, including the requirement to remove the relevant internal fittings.

The lesson for councils is straightforward: enforcement requirements must identify actions that can actually be understood and carried out. Broad expressions that sound robust may create ambiguity if they fail to say which doors, locks or physical connections must be changed. Our guide to establishing a lawful HMO considers the evidence and legal status of existing accommodation.

A second Durham Arms appeal, not the same flat

This is a separate decision from the October 2026 appeal over Flat 1 at the same premises. In that earlier case, Inspector L McKay dismissed appeal 3372051 concerning the conversion of ancillary pub accommodation into an independent Class C3 flat, with questions of pub viability and the living conditions of occupiers.

Our earlier report, Pub enforcement appeal fails over Romford flat, covers that Flat 1 decision. The new pub HMO enforcement case concerns Flat 2 and a Class C4 HMO, with the appeal confined to the steps required by the enforcement notice. Confusing those two findings would obscure both the difference in use class and the limited ground of appeal.

The Inspector expressly determined the new case on the basis that the ground floor had a lawful public house use. Havering had queried whether it had changed to a restaurant, but that issue was not part of this enforcement notice. The appeal decision should not be presented as determining the lawfulness of a separate restaurant operation.

What property owners should take from the decision

An appeal under ground (f) can succeed against a defective or disproportionate step without removing the underlying notice. Owners should distinguish between showing that a use is lawful, asking for planning permission, and challenging how a council has required a breach to be remedied. Each route has a different statutory test and different evidence needs.

The pub HMO enforcement decision also shows the danger of assuming that stopping an unauthorised use ends every obligation. Where the notice lawfully requires associated building fittings to be removed, complying with the use requirement alone may not be enough. A new ancillary use may need separate consideration rather than being treated as retrospective justification for all the existing works.

Our HMO planning guidance explains the differences between small and larger HMOs and the importance of the lawful starting use. Our change of use guide deals with the wider planning principles that can affect commercial premises and accommodation above them.

The Inspector’s formal decision in APP/B5480/C/25/3372055 was to vary the notice and uphold it as varied. The Planning Inspectorate register identifies the appeal. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase. The quoted Inspector wording is Planning Inspectorate material under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news