A pond curtilage appeal in Leicestershire has been dismissed after a Planning Inspector decided that excavating a substantial pond was an engineering operation and that the paddock in which it stood was not part of a house’s domestic curtilage. The owner therefore failed to establish that the works were lawful under permitted development rights.
Inspector A Berry issued the decision on 19 November 2026 in appeal APP/Y2430/X/25/3368675. It concerned land at Willowmead in Twyford, where Melton Borough Council had refused an application for a certificate of lawful existing development for a natural pond and associated landscaping.
The pond curtilage appeal is important for anyone proposing ponds, landscaping or other substantial works on land adjoining a house. The issue was not simply whether the owner regarded the field as a garden, or whether the whole property was in one ownership. The Inspector examined what had actually been built and how the land related to the dwellinghouse.
Excavation was an engineering operation
The application concerned an excavation said to be about one metre deep. Material removed from the ground had been deposited around part of the perimeter to form a mound. At the Inspector’s site visit the excavation was dry and work had been paused, with a liner intended to retain water later. The decision therefore dealt with physical works already carried out, rather than an assessment of a completed ornamental pond.
Section 55(1) of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 includes engineering operations within the definition of development. This does not require a qualified engineer to have been employed. The Inspector considered the planning, scale and likely mechanical work involved, and concluded that “the pond constitutes an engineering operation”. That is a finding about the characteristics of these particular works, not a rule that every small garden pond automatically needs permission.
The pond curtilage appeal accordingly moved to the next question. Even if excavation amounted to development, was it covered by an applicable permitted development right? The appellant did not establish that Part 6 agricultural rights applied. The council said agricultural necessity had not been shown and the appellant maintained that the land was not agricultural.
Why the pond curtilage appeal failed
The remaining argument concerned Part 1 of Schedule 2 to the General Permitted Development Order 2015, which depends on the land being within the curtilage of a dwellinghouse. Whether a particular parcel is inside that boundary is a question of fact and degree. Lines on an Ordnance Survey plan, the planning application red line and the extent of land in residential use do not settle it on their own.
The house and the surrounding land were under the same ownership. But the excavated pond stood a substantial distance from the house in an area with the appearance of a field or paddock. The Inspector saw separate areas of grassland, recently cleared domestic land, an outbuilding and changes made during renovation. Photographs and sales details helped reconstruct what the property looked like before these alterations.
That earlier evidence showed a more clearly defined garden, outbuilding and hardstanding enclosed by fencing and hedges, with paddock land beyond. The sales particulars described a smallholding of around seven acres with fenced grass paddocks. The field had previously been grazed by sheep belonging to someone other than the property’s owner, making its historical function especially important.
The Inspector was not persuaded that the paddock was sufficiently associated with the house. The decision says it was “not intimately associated with the dwellinghouse”. Although boundary treatments had been removed and planting altered, those later changes did not demonstrate that the wider field had historically formed part of the domestic curtilage.
The court authorities behind the decision
Two existing authorities featured in the Inspector’s reasoning. The Inspector cited Burford v Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government [2017] EWHC 1493 (Admin) for the principle that what constitutes the curtilage of a dwellinghouse is a question of fact and degree and primarily a matter for the decision maker. That distinction remains particularly relevant to large gardens, recreational paddocks and outbuildings.
The Inspector also referred to Methuen-Campbell v Walters [1979] 1 QB 525. Its established part-and-parcel approach looks at whether land is so closely associated with the building that it properly belongs to its curtilage. Ownership, use, enclosure and physical layout all contribute to that factual judgement.
There is a wider lesson in this pond curtilage appeal. A paddock may be used alongside a dwelling and still fall outside its curtilage. The property’s current appearance may also be less persuasive than older photographs, sale documents, historic boundaries and evidence of who used each part of the land.
What the lawful development certificate could establish
The application was made under section 191(1)(b) of the 1990 Act. The burden was on the applicant to show, on the balance of probability, that the works would have been lawful at the date of the application. The Inspector found that the excavation constituted development and that the appellant had not demonstrated an applicable permitted development right.
This was a lawfulness appeal, not a conventional planning application assessing whether permission ought to be granted on its merits. The council raised matters including flood risk and ecology, but the Inspector expressly said those planning considerations did not determine this certificate appeal. The dismissal should not be read as a finding that a properly made planning application for a pond must inevitably fail.
The pond curtilage appeal was decided alongside a separate enforcement notice appeal concerning the same works, APP/Y2430/C/25/3368766. Inspector A Berry dismissed that appeal too, although the Inspector corrected the description of the breach and substantially simplified Melton Borough Council’s notice. An earlier dismissed appeal involving a replacement house and other works, APP/Y2430/W/25/3368765, was a separate matter and did not determine either of the pond decisions.
Enforcement notice upheld after changes
In the related enforcement appeal, the Inspector found that the council’s original allegation included material that was not itself development. The Inspector replaced it with a concise allegation covering the excavation and formation of the pond. That correction did not mean the works had become lawful. The enforcement notice survived, subject to the Inspector’s changes.
The original notice also demanded that use of the land in connection with the pond should stop. But no material change of use was alleged, so, in the Inspector’s words, “there is no use to cease”. The Inspector deleted that requirement and an overly wide demand to remove all associated materials, structures and equipment. The excavated soil might itself be needed to return the land to its previous condition.
The remaining requirement is to “Return the land back to its former condition prior to the unauthorised development occurring”, with an eight-week compliance period. The appellant’s grounds (c) and (e) challenges failed: the evidence did not establish that the works were lawful, and the enforcement notice was served in time. The parallel decisions confirm that an enforcement notice can remain effective after important drafting corrections. The separate enforcement decision is also available on AppealBase.
The practical lesson for rural landowners
Our guide to planning permission for ponds explains why scale, excavation and location matter. A substantial excavation in an adjoining paddock is a different planning question from a small domestic garden feature. Before digging, owners should establish whether the works are development and, if so, exactly which permission or permitted development provision could authorise them.
It is equally important to assemble the right evidence for the land itself. Old estate-agent particulars, historic aerial images, fencing plans, records of grazing and dated photographs can all help demonstrate how the house, garden and wider holding have been used. Our curtilage guidance explains why the planning unit and domestic curtilage should not be confused.
For a certificate, the test is what can be proved, rather than what might be acceptable development. The pond curtilage appeal shows how an apparently domestic landscaping project can fail where substantial engineering works have taken place in land with a separate paddock history.
The full Inspector decision is recorded under appeal APP/Y2430/X/25/3368675 on the Planning Inspectorate case register. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase. The quoted decision wording is Planning Inspectorate material under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

0 Comments