East Malling homes proposals for up to 1,300 dwellings in Kent have reached an important new stage after Tonbridge and Malling Borough Council withdrew a heritage objection ahead of a December public inquiry. The decision was taken on 11 November 2026 and made public on 13 November.
For the East Malling homes application, the council will no longer defend the setting of the Grade I listed Church of St James the Great as a standalone reason for refusing the scheme. It has not withdrawn its objection concerning the potential loss of Hythe Formation Ragstone beneath the proposed development land, and no planning permission has been granted.
The East Malling homes case matters because it shows how an authority can reassess its position before an inquiry without abandoning every concern about a development. It also exposes the tension between national housing policy, historic buildings, safeguarded minerals and the infrastructure needed for a new neighbourhood.
East Malling homes: what councillors changed
The council’s published record of decision, minute PL 26/87, relates to outline application 24/00372/OAEA. Members considered legal advice in private on 11 November, following changes to national planning policy and a review of the available evidence by the council’s appointed professional advisers.
The public decision says the heritage objection “could no longer reasonably be defended as a standalone reason at the inquiry”. Councillors resolved to withdraw that reason from their case, retain the minerals reason, and continue considering identified harm to heritage assets within the overall planning balance.
That final point is easily missed. Withdrawing a discrete reason for refusal does not amount to a finding that the proposed road or housing would cause no heritage harm. The authority is changing the argument it will advance, not declaring the scheme acceptable in every respect. Nor should the committee resolution be mistaken for an Inspector’s conclusion or a ministerial grant of permission.
Why a large housing proposal reached this position
The outline application covers land east of Kiln Barn Road and west of Hermitage Lane, in the Aylesford area adjoining East Malling. It proposes up to 1,300 dwellings, including affordable housing, a village centre, a primary school, commercial and community space, employment floorspace, open areas and drainage infrastructure. Access is the principal detailed matter at this stage.
A key part of the scheme is a Sustainable Movement Corridor running from New Road in East Malling to Kiln Barn Road. Its relationship with the listed church and its setting had formed the main heritage dispute. The 11 November record also notes discussion of the corridor’s bus provision and the need to prevent it becoming a general-purpose route for vehicles.
In July the Planning Committee had been minded to refuse the application despite an officer recommendation to approve it subject to a Section 106 agreement and conditions. The council’s 30 July minutes identify two grounds: harm to the Grade I listed church from the corridor and the sterilisation of the site’s ragstone resource.
Those minutes are especially useful because they demonstrate the original legal stage. The committee was minded to refuse, but could not simply issue a refusal notice because the proposal fell within the 2026 consultation direction for certain residential schemes of 150 homes or more. The Secretary of State subsequently called in the application, leaving the final decision to central government following an inquiry.
Mineral safeguarding remains the live objection
The remaining concern is not about whether the proposed houses are attractive or whether more homes are needed locally. The council’s July reasons identify substantial deposits of Hythe Formation Ragstone and argue that insufficient technical evidence had been supplied to show prior extraction would be impractical or uneconomic.
There is a planning consequence to building over minerals that might otherwise be worked. Once homes, roads and other permanent structures occupy the land, extracting the resource later may become impracticable. The council cited policy DM7 of the Kent Minerals and Waste Local Plan 2024-39 and the mineral safeguarding provisions of the National Planning Policy Framework in its original position.
Under the revised East Malling homes inquiry case, that minerals dispute remains to be tested while the heritage concern becomes one factor in the broader planning balance. It would be premature to conclude that the surviving reason will necessarily defeat the proposal. The inquiry evidence and the ministerial decision will determine the outcome.
Heritage and affordable housing remain relevant
The revised approach illustrates the distinction between identifying harm to a heritage asset and deciding how much weight it should carry in an overall decision. Planning Geek’s guide to heritage significance and harm explains why the level of harm, the asset’s significance and the public benefits must be addressed carefully rather than reduced to a simple yes-or-no checklist.
Affordable housing was also an issue for the East Malling homes proposals during the July committee debate. Members questioned whether the cost of the Sustainable Movement Corridor was reducing affordable housing delivery and whether resources might be better deployed. However, the council’s minutes record that officers had presented independent viability evidence and advised on compliance with policy. Affordable housing was discussed as part of the balance, rather than adopted as one of the two formal reasons for the proposed refusal.
This matters to developers and local authorities facing expensive enabling infrastructure. Transport measures may be necessary to make a large scheme acceptable, but their cost can affect the affordable homes or other obligations that a development can sustain. Those trade-offs require sound viability evidence and a defensible policy judgement, not assumptions based only on the headline dwelling number.
Public inquiry dates and what happens next
The council has published a public inquiry registration page showing hearings on 8, 9, 10, 11, 15, 16 and 17 December 2026. The venue had not been confirmed on that page. It identifies the application, describes the mixed-use development and invites people who expect to attend to register their interest.
The East Malling homes application is a called-in planning decision, not an approval arising from the November committee meeting. The distinction is explained in Planning Geek’s guide to called-in planning applications and recovered appeals. The inquiry will examine the evidence before the Secretary of State makes a decision, with no guarantee of the outcome.
For practitioners, the immediate lesson is that an objection can become difficult to defend as policy and evidence change, even when substantial planning concerns remain. The council has now clarified the case it intends to put forward: minerals safeguarding will be contested, while heritage harm remains relevant to the planning balance. That is a material procedural development, but it is not the end of this 1,300-home application.


0 Comments