A Hinckley BNG appeal for two semi-detached homes has been dismissed after the Inspector found the submitted biodiversity metric unclear and illegible. The decision, dated 11 November 2026, concerns Moorbeck in Butt Lane Close, where the appellant also proposed alterations and an extension to the existing house.
Inspector K Craddock concluded that the material did not establish the required baseline biodiversity value. The prospect of bats using the roof area or nearby trees also called for a survey before permission could be granted, rather than an investigation deferred to a planning condition.
The decision matters beyond this small residential site. The council could not demonstrate a five-year housing land supply and the land was accepted as previously developed, but the Inspector concluded that unresolved ecological and statutory information failures outweighed the benefits of the additional homes.
Why the Hinckley BNG appeal was dismissed
The application, reference 25/01058/FUL, sought extensions and alterations to the existing dwelling alongside the erection of two semi-detached dwellings. Hinckley and Bosworth Borough Council refused permission and the developer appealed under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990. Inspector Craddock dismissed appeal 6011672 on 11 November 2026 after considering protected species and statutory biodiversity net gain (BNG).
There was no dispute about the principle of residential development within the settlement boundary. The site had also benefited from earlier planning permissions, but those permissions had expired. The Inspector therefore assessed this proposal using the information and policies relevant to the new application, including a statutory BNG regime which had not applied to the previous consent.
An unreadable biodiversity metric was decisive
The Hinckley BNG appeal exposed a basic but serious problem with the application evidence. Both parties agreed that the development was subject to mandatory biodiversity net gain and did not fall within an applicable exemption. The dispute was whether enough information had been supplied to identify the site’s biodiversity baseline and demonstrate that the statutory requirement could be satisfied.
The Inspector acknowledged that the appellant had submitted a statutory metric, but described it in particularly clear terms: it is poorly formatted and the information within it is unclear and illegible
. Without a usable calculation, the Inspector could not be satisfied that the pre-development habitat value had been calculated robustly. It was not possible to work out the 10% uplift required from that baseline.
That finding was grounded in the application-stage information duties under Article 7 of the Town and Country Planning (Development Management Procedure) (England) Order 2015 and Schedule 7A of the 1990 Act. It did not mean every detail of the eventual biodiversity gain plan had to be approved before permission. It meant the minimum information required to assess the proposal was missing.
Our guide to biodiversity net gain explains the pre-development information, exemptions and later gain-plan process. An applicant who expects to discharge the statutory biodiversity gain condition after permission still needs to provide the information required at the application stage. An illegible or incomplete metric cannot safely be treated as a detail to sort out later.
Why a bat survey could not wait
The other main issue in the Hinckley BNG appeal concerned protected species. The roof of the existing house and trees around the site created a reasonable likelihood of bat roosting or disturbance. The Inspector referred to Natural England guidance, planning practice guidance and Circular 06/2005 when considering whether further investigation was justified.
The appellant argued that the site had limited ecological value and proposed that survey work could be required by condition. Inspector Craddock rejected that approach because the possible presence of protected species and the risk of harm had not been established with an up-to-date preliminary ecological appraisal or other proportionate survey evidence.
The distinction matters. Conditions can control how an approved development proceeds, but they are not a substitute for establishing whether the development is acceptable in principle where protected species could be affected. The Inspector could not rule out disturbance or unacceptable harm to bats on the evidence provided.
Planning Geek’s protected species guidance and preliminary ecological appraisal guide explain why survey scope depends on the site, the likely species and the works proposed. The Hinckley decision is a reminder that a small urban housing site is not automatically too modest to warrant a bat survey.
Housing need did not rescue the proposal
The council accepted that it could not demonstrate a five-year housing land supply. The Inspector also accepted that the appeal site constituted previously developed land and that two additional homes would help increase housing stock. Under the August 2026 National Planning Policy Framework, the Inspector gave substantial weight to the housing benefit despite the modest number of dwellings.
Even so, the Hinckley BNG appeal failed under the Framework’s decision-making approach. The Inspector applied Policies S3 and S4 and considered the development’s conflict with Policy N2 on the natural environment and Policy DM1(2) on necessary application information. The Inspector found that the benefits would be substantially outweighed by the adverse effects.
The appellant said surveys had not been undertaken because legal access to the land and building had been unavailable. It also pointed to roost assessments associated with earlier schemes. The Inspector considered those explanations but found that neither removed the need for current, adequate evidence about protected species and BNG.
The decision therefore does not suggest that a small housing shortfall is irrelevant, or that all schemes near trees should be refused. It shows that housing-policy weight does not itself remedy an application that cannot demonstrate compliance with mandatory environmental requirements.
Practical implications for BNG submissions
For designers and agents, the Hinckley BNG appeal highlights three distinct pre-submission checks. Confirm whether the statutory condition applies to the particular application and its submission date; calculate and present a readable pre-development habitat baseline; and establish whether likely protected species require survey work before determination. These are separate questions and a favourable metric does not eliminate protected-species duties.
The current exemption rules have changed since some earlier applications were made. A new small-site exemption introduced in August 2026 is subject to its own conditions and transitional provisions, so it should not be assumed to govern an application made in 2025. In this appeal, both parties accepted that BNG applied. Our comparison of the 2024 and 2026 national policy frameworks explains the wider policy context.
The Hinckley BNG appeal is also a reminder to check whether older permissions relied on by the applicant remain extant. Expired consents may help explain why a site was considered suitable in principle, but they cannot automatically overcome new statutory duties or evidential gaps in an entirely fresh proposal.
The decision is recorded as appeal 6011672. The Planning Inspectorate appeal record contains the published decision.

0 Comments