Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Hoo housing appeal allows 450 homes despite landscape harm

A major Hoo housing appeal allows 450 homes despite landscape harm, with Medway's severe housing shortfall proving decisive.

by | 10th November 2026 11:38 | AppealsPlanning Policy

A Hoo housing appeal has allowed up to 450 new homes on land west of Hoo St Werburgh in Medway, Kent. Inspector Phillip Ware granted outline planning permission on 10 November 2026, despite finding landscape harm and acknowledging concerns that the development would narrow the gap between Hoo and Chattenden.

Taylor Wimpey Strategic Land appealed against Medway Council’s failure to decide application MC/24/2022 in time. The council subsequently indicated it would have opposed the plans, while The Independent Group participated in the public inquiry. The proposal also includes commercial and community floorspace, public open space, sports provision and supporting infrastructure.

The Hoo housing appeal matters because it applies the August 2026 National Planning Policy Framework to major housing outside a settlement. With Medway’s deliverable housing supply agreed at only between 2.3 and 2.7 years, the Inspector gave substantial weight to housing delivery, even while identifying a conflict with parts of the development plan.

Why the Hoo housing appeal succeeded

The scheme allows up to 450 dwellings, with 10 per cent affordable housing, and up to 500 square metres each of commercial and community floorspace. Associated plans include recreation space, landscaping, sustainable drainage, ecological mitigation and biodiversity net gain of at least 10 per cent. The appeal decision grants outline permission, with all detailed matters except access left for later approval.

The council supported the principle of residential-led development on the land, but disputed whether the layout and landscape buffer adequately protected separation between Hoo and Chattenden. For the Inspector, the central question was not whether there would be any harm. It was how much harm would follow and whether the benefits of the development justified allowing it.

The land lies west of Hoo, with Chattenden further to the south-west. Housing extending towards Chattenden could change the experience of travelling between the settlements and diminish their perceived separation. Local objections were therefore about a recognisable geographical and landscape effect, not simply opposition to new homes in general.

Inspector Ware found that the Hoo housing appeal would cause moderate harm to the character and appearance of the area. However, the Inspector considered that the additional harm associated specifically with coalescence between the two settlements was very limited. Inspector Ware was not persuaded that the new development would read as an extension to Chattenden.

Landscape separation and the earlier refusal

A notable part of the decision concerns the previous appeal for up to 475 homes on the same general site, dismissed in September 2016. That earlier proposal was similar in many respects but differed, especially in the land closest to Chattenden, and it was determined under a different policy framework. The Inspector considered the older decision but did not treat its outcome as decisive a decade later.

The revised Hoo housing appeal was assessed against the Medway Local Plan, the neighbourhood plan and the emerging development plan. The emerging plan identifies this location for up to 450 homes, with a concept that retains the identities of Hoo and Chattenden. Inspector Ware gave the emerging plan significant weight because of the stage reached in its preparation.

The Inspector also considered two separate housing appeals decided after the inquiry had closed. One allowed up to 240 homes off Ratcliffe Highway at Hoo. Another concerned land off Rochester Road. Both helped explain the wider planning context, but the Inspector warned that the sites, proposals and evidence were different, so neither controlled the outcome here.

The Inspector found that the development would conflict with countryside policies in the existing development plan and would not accord with the development plan as a whole. That distinction matters: an allowed appeal does not mean the decision-maker has found every local policy satisfied. It can mean that national policy and other material considerations carry sufficient weight to justify a different decision.

Housing supply of between 2.3 and 2.7 years

Medway’s housing land supply position was unusually stark. The principal parties agreed it stood between 2.3 and 2.7 years, well below the five-year requirement. Inspector Ware saw no need to settle upon an exact figure because every value in that narrow range represented a substantial shortfall. Planning Geek’s five-year housing land supply guide explains how that measure affects current planning decisions.

Under the August 2026 Framework, the absence of a five-year housing land supply can establish an evidenced unmet housing need for policy S5(1)(j), the route considered here for development outside settlements. The Inspector found that the scheme addressed that need, was physically well related to Hoo and could be accommodated by infrastructure. The Inspector consequently judged that the proposal met the relevant national-policy route.

The Hoo housing appeal therefore provides a concrete example of how the 2026 approach works. The Inspector did not simply apply the old paragraph 11(d) language, nor was a housing shortfall treated as automatically defeating landscape objections. Instead, the Inspector considered the scheme’s suitability under S5 and then weighed its particular benefits against the identified harms.

There is a financial and policy detail worth noting. The emerging Local Plan sought 25 or 30 per cent affordable housing, but the appeal scheme offered 10 per cent. The appellant’s viability evidence was not challenged. Inspector Ware still gave the affordable housing contribution substantial weight, despite the lower percentage, disagreeing with the council’s moderate weighting in the light of Framework policy and that unchallenged evidence.

That does not establish that 10 per cent will be accepted on other major developments. In the Hoo housing appeal, the viability position was uncontested and the Inspector evaluated it against this authority’s acknowledged housing deficit. Developers seeking a reduced obligation will still need their own evidence and appropriate agreement. See Planning Geek’s affordable housing planning guidance for the underlying principles.

Heritage, ecology and transport conditions

The site lies close to the Grade II listed Mill House, a late eighteenth-century building. The Inspector found limited harm to its setting, but attached considerable importance to that harm as required by section 66 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990. The Inspector concluded that the public benefits, especially the new homes, more than outweighed it.

Traffic and ecology had also featured in the inquiry process. Some initial objections were not pursued, and the evidence on highways and ecological mitigation was not challenged on technical grounds. The Inspector found no unacceptable highway impact and concluded that measures for protected sites could avoid adverse effects on their integrity, subject to the appropriate controls.

Permission is therefore not a licence to proceed immediately with every element shown in publicity material. The decision includes detailed conditions dealing with reserved matters, phasing, drainage, contamination, traffic management, walking and cycling links, biodiversity protection, energy measures and operating hours for commercial and community uses.

The section 106 obligations address affordable housing, highway works, open space and allotments, wild bird, skylark and bird disturbance mitigation, and the intended commercial and community facilities. Those measures formed part of the scheme the Inspector assessed. The precise reserved-matters designs and their implementation must still be approved and delivered.

What the Hoo housing appeal means for landowners

At the conclusion of the planning balance, Inspector Ware found the national-policy support and public benefits sufficiently weighty to justify a decision other than in accordance with the development plan. The appeal was allowed even though the Inspector had identified a moderate landscape impact and more limited agricultural and heritage harms.

The Hoo housing appeal demonstrates how much the factual and policy context can change the prospects for a significant housing site. The same broad location saw a refusal for a larger scheme in 2016. Ten years later, a revised layout, a severely constrained housing supply and a new national policy framework produced a different result.

For developers, the lesson is not that every edge-of-settlement greenfield site will now gain permission. The Inspector was explicit about the development being physically related to Hoo, the emerging allocation and the importance of credible landscape separation. Planning Geek’s guide to building outside settlement boundaries explains when the S5 route may apply and the matters that can still prevent permission.

For councils and local communities, the case shows why an objection needs to be supported by evidence on the degree of landscape harm, the significance of the settlement gap, deliverable alternatives and whether the scheme actually meets national policy. Concerns alone are not automatically decisive, but they were not dismissed without examination here.

The decision is appeal 6004418, dated 10 November 2026, by Inspector Phillip J G Ware following an inquiry in June and July 2026. The planning application is MC/24/2022. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase; Medway Council also maintains an official inquiry information page.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news

Campsfield inquiry set for 15 December

Campsfield inquiry set for 15 December

A rescheduled Crown development inquiry will examine plans for 240 additional detention spaces at Campsfield, including wastewater capacity and pumping station concerns.

Humber power line application accepted

Humber power line application accepted

National Grid’s 90km Humber power line proposal has entered pre-examination after acceptance, but its Development Consent Order has not been granted.