Scotland has issued two new documents that could change how developers prepare a marine impact assessment for offshore energy and other major coastal projects. Published by the Scottish Government’s Marine Directorate on 28 October 2026, they deal with social and economic evidence for marine licence applications and the treatment of commercial fishing in environmental impact assessment.
The important distinction is between a separate Statement of Economic and Social Impacts, often shortened to SESI, and the fisheries chapter of an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA). The Scottish guidance directs applicants to examine direct effects on fishing operations within the EIA, while considering wider community and supply-chain effects in the separate statement.
This is guidance for Scottish marine licensing, not a new statutory instrument or a change to every planning application across Britain. However, offshore wind promoters, cable and port developers, consultants, fishing businesses and coastal councils now have a clearer account of the information Scottish Ministers expect to see before deciding relevant applications.
What the marine impact assessment guidance changes
The new social and economic statement guidance applies to applications for marine licences involving offshore renewables, including wind, wave and tidal schemes, as well as cables, ports and harbour works. It describes the evidence that can help ministers apply Scotland’s National Marine Plan, particularly its policies concerning economic benefit, social benefit and sound evidence. The National Marine Plan’s GEN 19 policy states: “Decision making in the marine environment will be based on sound scientific and socio-economic evidence.”
Rather than rely on headline job numbers or estimated investment alone, an applicant is asked to explain who benefits, who may lose out, where those effects occur and what would probably happen without the scheme. The assessment is meant to be proportionate to the size, duration and geographical spread of the project. A small marine intervention does not automatically need the same analysis as a major wind farm.
The social and economic statement is not a new legal duty
A central point is easily missed: the guidance says the SESI is not itself a statutory requirement. Scottish Ministers may nevertheless require relevant information to determine an application. The document explains that the statement is expected alongside a marine licence application, so leaving it to the end of a large project’s programme could create avoidable evidential gaps.
For a robust marine impact assessment, the department asks for a defined study area, identified stakeholders, a clear explanation of how proposed works cause their predicted effects, and a baseline followed by a counterfactual. That counterfactual is the likely outcome without the development, not simply a snapshot of current conditions. Both favourable and unfavourable consequences should be explained.
The guidance draws on HM Treasury’s Green Book, including additionality, displacement and leakage. For example, a new construction job filled by someone moving from an existing nearby employer is not necessarily the same as a net new job for Scotland. Likewise, spending recorded in one port does not establish how much of that spending will remain in the coastal community.
Offshore fisheries assessment gets more precise
The companion commercial fisheries EIA guidance is aimed particularly at offshore renewable projects. It addresses scoping reports, baseline evidence, effects on fishing grounds and the methodology for assessing commercial fisheries. This is supplementary advice, not a substitute for a project-specific assessment or consultation with fishing interests.
For most fleets the document recommends at least five years of baseline fishing data, with seven years more appropriate for nomadic fisheries showing longer cycles, such as scallop dredging. It cautions against relying on dated inshore data alone and points to more recent information, including vessel monitoring, landing statistics and engagement with local fishers. The advice does not turn those periods into universal statutory thresholds.
This detail matters because a marine impact assessment built from incomplete vessel records could understate the activity of smaller boats. The guidance notes gaps in monitoring data for vessels under 12 metres and cautions that some surveillance information is affected by uneven sampling. Applicants need to explain the limitations of their datasets rather than present a tidy map as conclusive evidence.
Where the EIA ends and wider community evidence begins
There is an unusually useful dividing line between the two documents. The Scottish Government says general socio-economic assessment chapters are no longer expected within the EIA. Instead, the separate SESI is intended to explain broader impacts on communities, employment, services and the wider economy. That does not mean all economic consequences have been removed from the EIA.
Direct social and economic effects on fishing operations should remain within the EIA’s commercial fisheries chapter. These might include longer journeys to alternative grounds, reduced catch value, changed operating costs, restricted access and the practical viability of returning after construction. The fisheries advice also asks applicants to consider potential displacement, cumulative effects and the consequences of different project stages.
Broader effects on seafood processors, supply chains, ports and fishing-dependent communities belong in the SESI. Keeping the distinction clear should help prevent important impacts falling between documents or being counted inconsistently. It also gives fishing organisations a more useful way to test whether the promoter has examined direct operational losses as well as wider local consequences.
Housing, tourism and local services must be considered
The marine impact assessment guidance goes beyond revenue and employment. Its social themes include housing, temporary accommodation, demographic change, access to healthcare and schools, tourism, recreation and the resilience of communities facing deprivation. A construction workforce arriving in a relatively small coastal settlement could create additional local spending while also placing pressure on rental accommodation and services.
The department expects evidence at an appropriate local level, as well as an overview for Scotland. It recommends identifying the ports likely to be used during construction and operation, or using transparent scenarios where commercial arrangements are uncertain. The approach is particularly relevant when several offshore projects may affect the same harbour or compete for the same workforce and facilities.
What applicants should do before submission
A practical starting point is to decide which effects need to be examined in the fisheries EIA and which belong in the broader social and economic statement. Applicants should record the justification for including or excluding impacts, the sources and age of each dataset, the groups likely to be affected and the level of uncertainty. Where desk-based evidence is thin, targeted engagement or primary research may be needed.
Another risk is overlooking the chronology. The fisheries guidance expects the scoping exercise to consider pre-construction, construction, operation, maintenance and decommissioning as applicable. A temporary restriction during cable-laying may produce a different economic outcome from permanent loss of access, while later mitigation measures must be considered against the initial unmitigated effects.
I would distinguish the marine impact assessment process from the ordinary land-use planning route. Marine licensing has its own decision-maker and policy framework, and the guidance concerns Scotland. Our overview of planning in Scotland provides a useful starting point for the wider system. An onshore substation, access road or associated development may present separate consent questions.
Why the October guidance matters
The two publications were issued on 28 October 2026, and neither announces consent for a particular wind farm or marine project. Their significance lies in a clearer evidence standard and a more explicit separation between direct fisheries effects and wider social consequences. That is useful to both applicants preparing an assessment and communities testing whether the submitted material reflects local experience.
For the operative detail, readers should use the Scottish Government’s analytical principles, its core themes, and the commercial fisheries guidance. Any marine impact assessment still needs to respond to the facts of the particular proposal, rather than treating government guidance as an automatic approval formula.

0 Comments