Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Mid Sussex plan: 1,000 homes face landscape test

Inspector signals conditional support for 1,000 High Weald homes, but the Mid Sussex plan still needs more evidence before soundness is settled.

The Mid Sussex plan has moved closer to passing examination after Inspector Jonathan Bore indicated that three proposed housing allocations within the High Weald National Landscape could be justified by exceptional circumstances. Together, the sites at Handcross and Pease Pottage would provide around 1,000 homes, but a final conclusion depends on further evidence comparing them with alternatives outside the designated landscape.

The Inspector’s six-page letter is dated 10 November 2026 and was published by Mid Sussex District Council on 16 November, following hearings held from 3 to 6 November. It gives a preliminary favourable view of the modified district plan, not a final soundness report, an adopted plan or planning permission for any of the three developments.

For developers and planning authorities, the Mid Sussex plan raises a question extending well beyond West Sussex: when can unmet housing need help justify major housing allocations in a nationally protected landscape? The Inspector has accepted much of the revised housing strategy, including a requirement for 24,071 homes, but has reserved his final judgment on the National Landscape sites.

Why the Mid Sussex plan needs further evidence

Inspector Bore’s interim conclusions, document IDJB-19, are unusually direct about the competing pressures. Crawley has a substantial unmet housing requirement, and neighbouring districts are being asked to accommodate some of it. The Inspector identifies a need for 7,505 homes arising from Crawley’s adopted local plan, far above the spare capacity originally offered by Mid Sussex.

The modified Mid Sussex plan now provides for 24,071 homes over its extended period to 2040, an average of 1,267 homes a year on a stepped trajectory. The Inspector considers that higher requirement sound in principle. He also accepts the council’s revised selection process, which added 35 sites, and its work on affordable housing, employment and development management policies.

That is significant progress, but it does not remove the remaining landscape issue. Three proposed allocations, labelled MM88, MM89 and MM90, lie inside the High Weald National Landscape near Handcross and Pease Pottage. They are intended to contribute approximately 1,000 homes. The Inspector has asked the council for a short additional topic paper setting out more clearly how these locations compare with suitable and available land outside the protected area.

Responses to that paper are to be allowed for one week, strictly on its subject. The Inspector expects to submit his final report by 8 December, although that is a stated aim rather than a guaranteed date or confirmation of the ultimate findings.

Why 1,000 homes in a National Landscape are contentious

A National Landscape is the modern name for a designated Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty. Its landscape and scenic qualities enjoy high protection under national planning policy, and public bodies have statutory responsibilities towards conservation and enhancement. Planning Geek’s guide to National Landscapes and planning explains the designation, the strengthened duty and the separate tests for development proposals.

The Mid Sussex plan examination is being conducted under the September 2023 National Planning Policy Framework because of the applicable transitional arrangements. The Inspector nevertheless notes that the stringent approach to major development in protected landscapes has been carried forward into the 2026 Framework. It would therefore be unsafe to say that a newer, more pro-housing policy has swept away the landscape protection.

At a local-plan examination, the central issue is whether allocations can be justified and delivered within an overall sound strategy. That is not the same as granting permission for individual schemes. Detailed design, mitigation, access, landscape effects and the relevant statutory duty will still matter when applications are determined. The Inspector explicitly expects landscape-led design and consideration of that duty at the application stage.

The Inspector describes the three parcels as enclosed and influenced by nearby development, and says they are not particularly special in their contribution to the wider designated landscape. That is his site-specific assessment, not a conclusion that protection is weaker merely because a particular field is less visually dramatic. All land within the designation benefits from the same policy status.

Crawley’s housing need is central to the argument

The Mid Sussex plan letter emphasises the geographical difficulty. Crawley has Gatwick Airport to its north and the High Weald National Landscape to its south. Other authorities in the housing market area have their own housing requirements. The three proposed sites would sit close enough to Crawley to use existing employment, retail and public transport connections, rather than pushing homes much farther away.

There is also a potentially important affordable housing element. The Inspector refers to the opportunity for Crawley to secure nomination rights for a share of affordable homes. That is a possible future arrangement, not proof that an agreement or a particular affordable tenure mix has already been secured for these allocations.

The reasoning will interest other authorities facing unmet needs from neighbouring towns, especially where the geography is constrained by airports, protected landscapes or existing strategic development. It does not create a general entitlement to allocate housing in National Landscapes whenever an urban authority has a shortfall. The availability of reasonable alternatives, each site’s landscape contribution and public interest remain material.

What the Inspector said about roads and village separation

The letter also addresses a cluster of proposed sites around Burgess Hill, Sayers Common, Albourne, Hurstpierpoint and Hassocks. Residents have raised concerns about existing congestion, unsuitable lanes and the risk of neighbouring settlements merging in appearance. The council submitted additional evidence on Hurstpierpoint High Street in response to the examination.

Inspector Bore accepts the concerns are rooted in genuine highway conditions, but considers that the planned allocations would not individually or collectively add enough traffic to make the strategy unsound. He points to policy requirements for walking, cycling, bus improvements and highway interventions, with monitoring as development proceeds.

He also considers that landscape buffers can reduce intervisibility between settlements and avoid a perception of coalescence. This supports the strategic allocations at plan level. It does not exempt future applicants from demonstrating safe access, transport mitigation or acceptable detailed design.

What happens next to the Mid Sussex plan?

The next substantive stage is the council’s additional comparison of sites inside and outside the National Landscape, followed by the limited consultation response period. The Inspector’s eventual report will determine whether the remaining evidence supports his provisional conclusion. The council must then follow the applicable adoption procedure; no part of this letter amounts to adoption.

There is an important historical twist. An earlier examination ran into difficulty over cooperation with neighbouring councils. The current Inspector explains how the examination restarted and how the revised plan now addresses unmet need from Crawley and, to a degree, Brighton and Hove. That context makes his preliminary acceptance of the higher housing target consequential rather than a routine examination update.

Planning Geek’s guide to Local Plan examinations explains soundness, main modifications and what happens before adoption. The distinction matters here: a provisional indication that modifications are sound gives developers a clearer direction, but the plan’s final status and the weight of individual allocations are not settled until the remaining process is completed.

The Mid Sussex plan has therefore reached a meaningful turning point. It offers a potential route to provide around 1,000 homes within a National Landscape while responding to Crawley’s acute housing need. Whether that route survives the final examination depends on the further alternatives evidence, not simply the headline number of homes.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news

Priors Farm housing: 850 homes backed

Priors Farm housing: 850 homes backed

Wokingham councillors back 850 Priors Farm homes, but major affordable housing and highways obligations remain subject to linked decisions and a legal agreement.