The Musselburgh flood inquiry has opened as a Reporter appointed by Scottish Ministers begins examining East Lothian Council’s proposed flood protection scheme and the objections lodged against it.
The Musselburgh flood public local inquiry began on 6th October 2026 at Eskmills in Musselburgh. The scheme has been called in for determination by Scottish Ministers under the Flood Risk Management (Scotland) Act 2009, so the final decision no longer rests with the council alone.
The Musselburgh flood project is intended to reduce flood risk from the River Esk, the coast and climate change for up to 3,200 properties. The inquiry will test whether the scheme should be confirmed, modified or rejected before Ministers make the final decision.
Working on a major planning or infrastructure proposal?
Planning Geek can help with planning strategy, policy evidence and the route through applications, objections and appeal or inquiry procedures.
Why the Musselburgh flood inquiry is happening
East Lothian Council published the proposed Musselburgh Flood Protection Scheme in March 2024. The scheme is being promoted under separate flood-risk legislation rather than through an ordinary planning application, but the process has many features familiar to planning practitioners: environmental assessment, objections, evidence, a Reporter and a final ministerial decision.
For the Musselburgh flood scheme, in September 2025 the council made a preliminary decision to confirm the scheme without modifications. It then asked Scottish Ministers to consider the proposals and hold a public local inquiry.
Scottish Ministers called in the Musselburgh flood scheme during December 2025. Paul Cackette was subsequently appointed as Reporter and the case is being handled through the Scottish Government’s Planning and Environmental Appeals Division.
The DPEA case page identifies the matter as reference FPS-210-1. It records the scheme as a Flood Prevention Scheme, with the case to be decided through further written submissions and inquiry proceedings.
That procedural route matters because the Reporter does not make the final ministerial decision personally. The inquiry will produce a report and recommendation for Scottish Ministers, who can confirm the scheme, confirm it with modifications, or reject it.
Scheme aims to protect up to 3,200 properties
East Lothian Council says the scheme is intended to bring about a major reduction in flood risk across Musselburgh. The town has long been exposed to flooding from the River Esk and coastal influences, with future climate change adding to the risk profile.
The council’s project website says the proposals have been developed to protect up to 3,200 properties. The notified scheme includes a package of interventions rather than a single defence structure, and has been subject to environmental assessment and extensive community engagement.
That scale helps explain the intensity of the inquiry. Flood protection schemes can create benefits for thousands of homes and businesses, but the physical works can also affect landscape, public space, river corridors, access, heritage and ecology.
The task for the inquiry is therefore not simply to decide whether flood protection is desirable in principle. It is to examine whether this particular statutory scheme is justified, whether the proposed works are proportionate and whether the objections reveal issues that require modification or rejection.
Detailed design is already moving in parallel
The inquiry is taking place while East Lothian Council advances detailed design work. In April 2026 councillors agreed to move into Stage 6 of the project rather than wait for the ministerial decision.
The council said that decision reflected funding and programme pressures. Detailed design was expected to take around 24 months at an estimated cost of £6 million, allowing the authority to prepare for procurement if the scheme ultimately receives consent.
The same council update referred to a £35.6 million national funding cap applying to the project and the need to have a construction contract in place within the relevant funding timetable.
That creates an unusual but understandable overlap. The council is spending money developing a scheme that remains subject to an independent ministerial determination, while trying to avoid losing time if Ministers later approve it.
For practitioners, that is a useful reminder that major infrastructure processes rarely proceed in a neat single-file sequence. Design, funding, statutory approvals, environmental evidence and procurement can all move at different speeds.
What the Reporter will examine
The inquiry is concerned with the justification for the scheme and the outstanding objections. The statutory notice confirms that the proceedings are open to the public and that the Reporter will hear evidence over a series of sessions.
The DPEA case record shows the opening session at The Venue, Eskmills, on 6th October, with further oral process also scheduled later. The precise programme can change as the Reporter manages the evidence and the parties.
In practical terms, objectors and the council will have an opportunity to test evidence and explain why the scheme should, or should not, proceed in its present form. The Reporter can consider whether changes are needed before making recommendations to Ministers.
The inquiry is therefore more than a consultation meeting. It is a formal evidential process with direct consequences for the legal future of the scheme.
Flood risk, public realm and local impact all meet here
The controversy around the project reflects a familiar tension in large flood schemes. Stronger protection can reduce risk to existing development, but hard engineering can also alter the appearance and use of riverfront spaces.
That does not mean natural flood management and engineered defences are simple alternatives. A credible scheme has to respond to the actual flood mechanisms, land availability, hydraulic modelling, climate allowances and the level of protection being sought.
Equally, engineering need does not remove the need to consider place. Walls, embankments, gates, river-edge works and changes to access can all affect how a town centre or waterfront functions and feels.
The public inquiry is the mechanism through which those competing considerations can be examined in a structured way before Scottish Ministers decide whether the statutory scheme should proceed.
What happens after the inquiry
Once the oral and written evidence is complete, the Reporter will prepare a report for Scottish Ministers. The recommendation can support confirmation, modification or rejection of the scheme.
East Lothian Council has previously indicated that the final decision is expected after the inquiry process rather than during the hearing sessions themselves. The timetable remains dependent on the scope of evidence and the time required for the Reporter and Ministers to complete their work.
If the scheme is confirmed, detailed design and procurement work will still need to progress before construction. If it is modified, further design work may be needed. If it is rejected, the council would have to reconsider how it responds to Musselburgh’s flood risk.
Planning Geek’s Scotland planning section follows significant Scottish planning and infrastructure decisions, while our planning policy guidance explains how policy and decision-making frameworks influence major proposals.
Planning Geek view
The significance of the Musselburgh inquiry lies in the collision between urgency and scrutiny. The flood risk is real, the council wants to keep the delivery programme moving, and significant design work is already under way. But the statutory objections still have to be tested independently.
That is exactly what a public inquiry is for. It provides a formal route to examine whether the scheme is justified in its present form, rather than treating either the council’s preliminary decision or the objections as the final word.
For anyone following major infrastructure in Scotland, the case is also a useful example of how a project can sit outside the conventional planning-application route while still involving many of the same professional disciplines: environmental assessment, public participation, design evidence, legal procedure and ministerial decision-making.

0 Comments