Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Pub chimney appeal varies Grade II* enforcement notice

An Inspector upholds enforcement against modern flues at the Grade II* Crown and Treaty Inn, but allows nine months for removal.

by | 21st November 2026 19:28 | AppealsEnforcement

A pub chimney appeal has upheld a listed building enforcement notice requiring restoration of three historic chimney stacks at the Grade II* Crown and Treaty Inn in Uxbridge. The Inspector nevertheless amended the timing of the notice, allowing nine months for both removing modern extraction flues and carrying out the rebuilding.

Inspector Paul Freer issued his decision on 20 November 2026, following an appeal by Stonegate Pub Group against a notice from the London Borough of Hillingdon. The notice concerned extraction flues, supporting wires and liners installed where prominent historic chimney stacks had stood.

The pub chimney appeal makes an important distinction between the lawfulness of unauthorised work and how quickly an owner must put it right. The heritage harm was serious, but the Inspector accepted that immediate removal before restoration materials were ready would be impractical.

Why the pub chimney appeal concerned important historic fabric

The Crown and Treaty Inn dates from 1576 according to its listing description, although it has undergone substantial restoration. Three distinctive chimney stacks, each formed from three hexagonal shafts above moulded brick cornices, are specifically recorded as part of the building’s special interest. Its designation is Grade II*, rather than the Grade II wording originally used in the notice.

The works involved three modern extraction flues on the west elevation, associated wires and flue liners, and the capping of chimney stacks. The original notice required removal of the modern apparatus within one month and rebuilding the chimneys within nine months, with particular materials and workmanship to match the historic form.

The pub chimney appeal involved a notice issued on 19 August 2024. The Inspector considered three grounds under section 39 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990, dealing with whether consent ought to be granted, whether restoration steps were appropriate, and whether the compliance period was reasonable.

Planning Geek’s guide to listed building consent explains the separate consent requirement for works affecting a listed building’s character. A planning permission for a commercial operation does not itself dispense with that statutory control.

Modern flues could not replace historic chimneys

Inspector Freer found that the modern metal flues were visually incongruous on a building of this age and form. More significantly, the removal of the earlier chimney stacks had affected a feature that made an important contribution to the building’s historic and architectural significance.

The Inspector assessed the heritage harm as substantial because an important part of the asset’s significance had been entirely removed. The pub chimney appeal was therefore not simply about whether new metalwork could be made less prominent. The loss of the historic stacks themselves was central to the assessment.

The revised August 2026 National Planning Policy Framework requires substantial weight to be given to the conservation of designated heritage assets. Its policy HE6 sets out how heritage harm is to be considered alongside any public benefits. The Inspector applied the substantial-harm test to the Grade II* building.

Stonegate argued that the gastropub’s continued operation benefited the community and allowed customers to appreciate the historic interior. It sought temporary listed building consent for the extraction equipment while chimney restoration could be arranged. Those were considerations, but they did not outweigh the heritage loss identified.

The Inspector accepted that public access had some public value, but considered the main advantage of the pub remaining operational to be a private benefit for the business. He was not persuaded that the Framework’s alternative substantial-harm criteria were met, and ground (e) therefore failed.

Why the proposed restoration requirements survived

The pub chimney appeal also challenged the steps required by the enforcement notice. Stonegate suggested that flue liners below roof level had existed historically and that replacement liners might not harm the building. The Inspector noted, however, the Council’s point that the existing arrangements would probably need to be altered if the chimney stacks were reconstructed accurately.

No detail had been provided showing that replacement flue liners would be harmless or unnecessary. The Inspector was accordingly satisfied that the notice’s restoration requirements would serve the statutory purpose of restoring the listed building’s former character. That challenge, considered under ground (i), failed.

In dealing with the grounds, the Inspector treated a reference to ground (j) as one to ground (i), because that was the substance of the argument and the Council had addressed it. This is a useful example of the importance of framing enforcement appeal grounds accurately without overlooking the case actually being advanced.

The listed building description itself also mattered. The notice incorrectly identified the building as Grade II, and the Inspector formally corrected it to Grade II*. That correction did not invalidate the notice or displace the need to remedy the unauthorised works.

Nine months allowed for a joined-up restoration

The decisive success in the pub chimney appeal concerned ground (h), which tests the period allowed to comply. The original timetable demanded removal of flues within one month but gave nine months for reconstruction. Stonegate argued that those deadlines should be aligned to minimise disruption to operating facilities.

The Inspector explained that “there would be no point in removing the three extraction flues” before the restoration was ready. He varied the notice by replacing the one-month period in the removal requirement with nine months, bringing the principal deadlines together while preserving the Council’s restoration objectives.

That was a limited procedural success, not permission to retain the modern flues indefinitely. The listed building enforcement notice was upheld as corrected and varied, and the Inspector rejected arguments that the unauthorised installation should receive temporary consent.

The outcome illustrates why owners should distinguish between defending work on its merits and demonstrating a practical timetable for compliance. Planning Geek’s explanation of enforcement notices provides background on the different remedies and procedures, although listed building enforcement has its own statutory provisions.

Practical lesson for heritage owners and pub operators

Where original features are integral to a listed building’s significance, replacement equipment can be unacceptable even if it supports an active commercial use. Owners should establish the approved historic details and possible restoration methods before introducing alternative plant or exhaust routes.

The pub chimney appeal also shows how evidence on construction sequencing can influence the period for remedying a breach. A request for additional time is more persuasive when tied to an identified restoration programme than when it merely postpones a required outcome.

Appeal APP/R5510/F/24/3352760 was determined by Inspector Paul Freer on 20 November 2026. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase. The Inspector’s decision text is Planning Inspectorate material made available under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news