Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Scottish EPC C plans face landlord backlash

Scottish rental energy standards face opposition in consultation responses, with cost, heritage buildings and the proposed 2028 deadline prominent concerns.

Scottish EPC C proposals for privately rented homes have met substantial opposition from respondents to a government consultation, with landlords questioning the timetable and costs of upgrading Scotland’s ageing housing stock. The Scottish Government published its analysis of the responses on 6th October 2026, providing fresh evidence of the obstacles facing proposed minimum energy efficiency rules.

The Scottish EPC C consultation considered a reformed Energy Performance Certificate Heat Retention Rating of band C for new private tenancies from 2028, with a backstop of 2033 for the wider private rented sector.

Only 35 per cent of respondents supported band C as the minimum standard; a proposed £10,000 cost cap drew support from 24 per cent. Neither the milestones nor the proposed cap should be described as regulations already in force.

The results expose a practical challenge for planning and heritage professionals as well as landlords: energy upgrades must be technically appropriate for listed buildings, traditional stone homes and tenements, while respecting separate requirements for planning permission, listed building consent and building standards where relevant. The government has yet to publish final rules arising from this exercise.

Scottish EPC C proposals: what the consultation tested

The Scottish Government consulted between 6th June and 29th August 2025 on draft regulations for a Minimum Energy Efficiency Standard in the domestic private rented sector. It used powers under the Energy Act 2011 as a proposed legal route. The new analysis contains 316 responses, comprising 107 from organisations and 209 from individuals.

The proposed standard is not simply the familiar cost-based rating seen on older Energy Performance Certificates. Under the reformed Scottish certificate framework, a Heat Retention Rating would measure how effectively the fabric of a dwelling retains warmth. A separate energy cost rating would help describe likely running costs. The proposed legal requirement would use the Heat Retention Rating.

The government proposed that properties newly let from 2028 should, where feasible, meet band C, with 2033 as the date for bringing the rest of the private rented stock within the standard.

There would be exemptions for properties where improvements are unsuitable or not reasonably practicable. This is the model on which views were sought, not an announcement that every privately rented dwelling must already meet EPC C.

The consultation analysis cautions that it is based on self-selecting responses. Its percentages tell us about the people and organisations who responded, not the views of all Scottish landlords, tenants or householders. That distinction matters when using the findings to assess policy risk.

Most respondents rejected the proposed implementation dates

For the Scottish EPC C requirement proposed for new tenancies from 2028, 29 per cent of respondents agreed and 59 per cent disagreed. Organisations were considerably more supportive than individuals, with 53 per cent of organisations favouring the timetable compared with 17 per cent of individual respondents.

An equivalent 29 per cent supported the proposed 2033 deadline covering all privately rented homes, compared with 56 per cent opposed. Some respondents wanted earlier progress to support climate targets, while others warned that the time remaining would be inadequate for surveys, design, consent, financing and construction.

Concerns about contractor availability were especially prominent for remote, island and rural locations, where specialist skills and materials may be harder to secure.

A statutory deadline is of limited practical value unless a viable assessment and delivery chain can meet it. Landlords also need clarity soon enough to avoid spending on improvements that later prove irrelevant to the adopted rating methodology.

The consultation analysis does not settle which timetable ministers will adopt. Any eventual deadlines, transitional arrangements and exemptions must be checked against the final legislation, rather than assumed from the draft consulted upon.

A £10,000 spending cap divided respondents

For Scottish EPC C upgrades, the government proposed a cost cap of £10,000 for energy efficiency improvement works. Just 24 per cent of respondents supported that cap, while 59 per cent opposed it.

Some considered the maximum unaffordable for landlords, particularly where local rents are modest. Others warned that £10,000 could be insufficient to achieve band C in buildings needing major fabric works.

Among alternative proposals, a £5,000 cap was frequently suggested. A different question asked whether all actual improvement costs and the cost of an EPC should count towards the cap. On that point, 81 per cent agreed, suggesting broad support for transparent accounting even where respondents disagreed about the cap itself.

Respondents also asked for grants, subsidies, tax incentives and other support. Support for public assistance was strong, but interest in loans was more limited. For owners with multiple older properties, the aggregate capital requirement can be far greater than the headline amount for one dwelling.

The final scheme will need rules defining eligible costs, previous expenditure, how technical exemptions are established and who checks compliance. An assessment of a landlord’s costs under draft proposals should not be represented as an entitlement to an exemption before those rules are made.

Listed buildings and traditional tenements raise hard questions

Scotland has a large stock of stone-built homes, historic tenements and listed buildings that are not always suited to standard fabric measures. Consultation respondents identified problems with insulation systems that might change how an older wall handles moisture, with potential consequences for ventilation, condensation, damp and mould.

Those risks do not mean older buildings should be left inefficient. They reinforce the need for a property-specific approach, with appropriate diagnosis before works are specified. In protected buildings, a technically viable measure may also require listed building consent or planning permission depending on the location and character of the works.

Older stone buildings in rural areas can face particularly difficult economics, combining relatively low rental returns with high specialist installation costs. Respondents warned that some landlords might sell properties or pass costs through to tenants. Those are concerns raised in consultation, not a confirmed forecast of how many homes will leave the sector.

The proposed Heat and Energy Efficiency Technical Suitability Assessment, or HEETSA, could help determine when particular interventions are unsuitable. Respondents saw value in a more rigorous route that accounts for ventilation, physical condition, climate and building fabric rather than reliance on a simplified rating alone.

Which tenancies would come within the new standards?

The consultation considered whether crofters, small landholders and agricultural holdings should be excluded from the private rented sector rules. Some respondents argued that these arrangements have different legal frameworks and that rural housing stock is often technically difficult to upgrade. Others emphasised that people living in poorly insulated rural homes can have particularly acute fuel poverty concerns.

Short-term holiday lets were also contentious. Fifty-two per cent of respondents disagreed with excluding them, while 35 per cent supported exclusion. Some feared that an exemption would create an incentive to move homes away from ordinary residential tenancies and into holiday letting. Others felt that permanent tenants and holiday guests should not be treated identically.

How the eventual legislation defines its coverage will matter to owners of mixed portfolios and to advisers dealing with farm dwellings, holiday cottages, rural conversions and houses in multiple occupation. The rules on planning use and the rules on minimum energy efficiency are separate legal questions.

Local authorities face an enforcement challenge

The consultation canvassed whether local authorities should monitor and enforce the standard. Respondents generally favoured that route, but many raised questions about councils’ staffing, budgets and technical capacity. Local authorities may already be responsible for planning, building standards, private landlord registration and housing enforcement, with different powers and teams.

Compliance may require checking certificate ratings, recording exempt buildings, reviewing technical evidence and responding to disputes about improvement costs. The more complex exemptions are, the greater the need for clear national guidance and consistent administration. Respondents also questioned proposed higher financial penalties for breaches, expressing concern that sanctions could worsen affordability or encourage disposal of rental properties.

For planning teams, the interaction is indirect but important. Property owners may seek consent for exterior insulation, window alterations, heat pumps and other measures. A national energy rule cannot itself supply listed building consent or guarantee that a particular intervention meets local design and heritage policy.

What happens next for landlords and planning advisers

Ministers must decide whether and how to revise the Scottish EPC C proposals. The consultation analysis is evidence for policy development, not a commencement order. Landlords should distinguish future policy ambitions from existing obligations and avoid advertising any proposed deadline as already legally binding.

A prudent first step is to establish the property’s present certificate information, review likely fabric options, identify listed or conservation status, and understand whether works may need planning permission, listed building consent or building warrant approval. Doing this early can reduce the risk of emergency applications or unsuitable retrofit measures if new rules are adopted.

The analysis places two public objectives in tension: improving the warmth and cost of living of rented homes, while maintaining an adequate supply of affordable rental accommodation. The eventual regulatory design will have to address both. The next watch point is a Scottish Government decision on the final regulations, exemptions and delivery timetable.

Official sources and further reading

Official sources: Scottish Government consultation analysis, 6th October 2026; original draft regulations consultation; tenant engagement research. Related Planning Geek topics include Scottish planning news and listed buildings.

0 Comments

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news

Campsfield inquiry set for 15 December

Campsfield inquiry set for 15 December

A rescheduled Crown development inquiry will examine plans for 240 additional detention spaces at Campsfield, including wastewater capacity and pumping station concerns.