A storage units appeal has allowed 35 small Class B8 premises on farmland beside Castle Donington, despite a finding that the project would disturb neighbouring households. The Planning Inspector decided on 20 November 2026 that evidenced demand for business space and the economic benefits outweighed that harm under the revised national policy.
Inspector David Smith allowed appeal 6012622 at land north of Hilltop Farm, Hill Top, after North West Leicestershire District Council refused planning permission. The scheme comprises 35 storage or distribution units providing 3,511 square metres of internal floorspace, together with access, parking and servicing space.
The storage units appeal matters well beyond this one site because the Inspector accepted conflict with the adopted local plan and still granted permission. The decision shows how carefully evidenced demand can carry substantial weight, but also why developers need workable controls for noise, vehicle movements and nearby homes.
Why the storage units appeal succeeded
The site is an irregularly shaped piece of agricultural land outside Castle Donington’s Limits to Development. Local Plan Policy S3 generally restricts development in the countryside, but Policy Ec2 allows certain employment proposals if immediate need or demand cannot be met on allocated sites, and the location is otherwise suitable.
The 35 units would be arranged in small blocks of two to four, with six different unit sizes and an average of about 100 square metres. A new entrance would serve the site from Hill Top. These were smaller premises than some warehouse developments already available around the village and airport.
The appellant presented details of 58 parties who had registered interest in storage accommodation, covering businesses wanting to start up or expand. Some wanted more than one unit. A 2020 employment-land assessment and a 2024 update also pointed to an undersupply of non-strategic industrial premises across the district.
The Inspector recognised that those expressions of interest were not guaranteed tenancies. Even so, their scale made the local need credible. He found that the applicants had shown a convincing picture of immediate demand for small Class B8 units
in the area, and that allocated employment sites did not offer a suitable alternative.
The storage units appeal therefore illustrates the value of matching market evidence to the actual type and size of buildings proposed. General assertions that a district needs employment land may not be enough. Here there was a defined product, a list of potential occupiers and supporting district-wide evidence.
Harm to neighbouring gardens was accepted
The council’s amenity concerns were not dismissed as speculation. Homes on Hill Top and High Street border the appeal land, with some houses about 22 metres from the proposed units and operational roads or parking areas closer still. The existing use as agricultural land meant the nature and frequency of activity would change.
An acoustic assessment indicated that background sound was dominated by traffic and that operational noise would be low. The council did not dispute its technical calculations. But the Inspector considered that regular delivery, unloading and vehicle movements would remain noticeable to neighbours, especially when using their gardens.
Perimeter landscaping could screen activity visually, but it would not remove all noise. Limiting the working day could avoid night-time disturbance, although the important effects were likely to occur during daytime hours. The Inspector found harm to residents’ living conditions and a resulting conflict with Local Plan Policy D2.
That finding is what makes the storage units appeal useful. The Inspector did not pretend that the proposal met every development-plan test, nor that a favourable acoustic report eliminated ordinary disturbance. He weighed the acknowledged harm against the specific benefits in the national planning policy framework.
How national policy changed the balance
The revised 2026 National Planning Policy Framework provided the decisive material consideration. Policy E2 directs substantial weight towards economic benefits from commercial development that enables businesses to invest and grow, while Policy S5 sets the approach to certain development outside settlements.
The Inspector found the proposal physically related to Castle Donington and of a scale that surrounding infrastructure could accommodate. There were bus services, cycling opportunities and links to the strategic road network. The local demand evidence was persuasive in showing why these particular premises were needed.
The storage units appeal was still contrary to the development plan as a whole. However, the Inspector concluded that its adverse effects did not substantially outweigh the development’s economic benefits. National policy was therefore a material consideration of sufficient importance to justify granting permission despite that conflict.
This is not a general invitation to place warehouses anywhere outside a settlement boundary. Our guide to building outside settlement boundaries explains why both the relevant local plan and national policy need to be considered on the actual facts of a proposal.
HGV controls and operating restrictions
Traffic generated local concern, especially about heavy goods vehicles entering Castle Donington’s historic centre. The highway authority did not object on capacity or safety grounds. However, a planning obligation would fund changes to the Traffic Regulation Order to prevent HGVs serving the site from travelling through the village.
The Inspector considered that HGV routing measure necessary to make the development acceptable. The conditions also control working hours, loading and unloading, construction traffic, lighting, landscaping, external materials and drainage. Further controls address access, outside storage, ecology, air quality and proximity to East Midlands Airport.
Importantly, the permission restricts some future permitted development rights, including Class P, and controls combining units and creating retail sales space. Our Use Class B8 guidance explains what falls within storage and distribution use. A permission for small B8 units should not be mistaken for unrestricted commercial floorspace.
The storage units appeal also required an updated badger survey before works begin, alongside site management arrangements. Those details demonstrate how a favourable appeal decision can still leave the developer with significant pre-commencement and operational obligations.
What applicants should take from the decision
For similar employment schemes, the most persuasive evidence may be real demand for premises of a specific scale, not a generic estimate of jobs created. The marketing exercise here helped distinguish the proposed units from existing larger sheds and trade-counter premises that did not meet the same need.
Equally, neighbours’ amenity remains material even when technical noise calculations suggest low impacts. The decision is a reminder to examine the actual relationship between manoeuvring space, gardens, delivery frequency and operational hours. Where those effects cannot be removed completely, the planning balance needs to acknowledge them accurately.
The storage units appeal was allowed on 20 November 2026, reference 6012622, following a site visit on 11 November. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase.


0 Comments