Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Tewin extension wins on larger permitted fallback

The Inspector finds disproportionate enlargement and Green Belt harm, but accepts that a larger lawful alternative provides very special circumstances.

A Tewin extension has won planning permission after an Inspector accepted that a larger permitted-development alternative would cause greater harm. K E Down allowed the Bishops Road proposal in Tewin Wood, Hertfordshire, on 14th October 2026, overturning East Hertfordshire District Council’s refusal.

The decision grants a part two-storey, part single-storey rear extension to an existing house in the Green Belt. The Inspector found the cumulative enlargement disproportionate to the original house and therefore inappropriate development, but concluded that very special circumstances justified permission.

I would focus on the comparison with what could realistically be built instead. This was not a finding that screening makes a large extension acceptable on its own. A genuine prospect of a bigger, less sympathetic permitted scheme was the consideration that changed the balance.

Why the Tewin extension was inappropriate

The house is a post-war property in a traditional mock-Tudor style, on a wooded estate of individually designed homes, many on generous plots. The proposed works would be at the rear and not visible from the highway. A high fence and vegetation also screened views from the public footpath behind.

However, visibility and the size test were separate questions. National Green Belt policy allows extensions within an exception only where they do not produce a disproportionate increase compared with the original building. The relevant baseline was the house as originally built, rather than its already enlarged form.

The Tewin extension followed earlier two-storey side works, single-storey front and rear extensions and a conservatory. The council estimated that these had already increased original floorspace by almost 80%, a figure the appellant did not dispute.

The new scheme would demolish the conservatory and partly reuse its footprint, adding a modest two-storey projection to an existing rear gable and enlarging the ground-floor accommodation. Compared with the existing house, the works did not appear disproportionate in themselves.

Compared with the original house, the position was different. The approximate doubling in size would be noticeably disproportionate. The Inspector therefore found the proposal inappropriate development in the Green Belt, rather than fitting within the ordinary extension exception.

Screening limited harm but did not remove it

Green Belt openness has spatial and visual aspects. The extensions would closely relate to the house, with limited projections, so their spatial effect would be modest. Public views were restricted, while neighbours would see parts of the two-storey element through vegetation.

The Inspector found modest harm to openness. That was still harm requiring substantial weight in the balance. A proposal can be largely hidden from a road and remain inappropriate development with an adverse spatial effect.

In the Tewin extension assessment, screening helped explain the degree of harm. It did not establish the very special circumstances needed to approve inappropriate development. The Inspector turned separately to the fallback already available to the owner.

The larger alternative was a genuine prospect

In January 2026, the council had confirmed that prior approval was not needed for two eight-metre-deep single-storey rear extensions, under reference 3/25/1840/PNHH. The Inspector accepted those works as the permitted fallback put forward if this appeal failed.

The alternative would have a noticeably greater floor area and volume, adding significant bulk. The council accepted that it would be larger and form a less consolidated arrangement. It nevertheless questioned whether it was realistic because it would provide no first-floor accommodation.

The Inspector examined what the appellant was seeking to achieve. The first-floor part of the appeal scheme would enlarge an existing bedroom rather than create additional rooms. The ground-floor works would significantly open up and enlarge the kitchen, breakfast and family-room area.

For the Tewin extension, that made the alternative credible. The owner could still obtain the desired ground-floor enlargement by building the permitted scheme. The Inspector found a genuine prospect that this would happen if the appeal were dismissed, rather than a theoretical alternative with little likelihood of implementation.

He concluded that the fallback would project further into the garden and beyond the fairly regular building line. It would be materially less sympathetic to the house and surrounding area and more harmful to the Green Belt. That consideration carried considerable weight in favour of the appeal proposal.

How the final balance was reached

The decision gave substantial weight to the identified Green Belt harm. It then found that the other considerations clearly outweighed that harm, providing the very special circumstances necessary in this case. The appeal was allowed under application reference 3/26/0105/HH.

The Tewin extension result is useful because the Inspector did not blur the stages. He found the proposal disproportionate, identified the openness harm, tested whether the alternative was realistic and compared the two outcomes before making the final judgement.

I would use the same discipline when considering another fallback argument. You need to know exactly what is lawful, what the relevant decision or permitted development right allows and whether there is a real prospect of that option being built. The mere existence of a larger drawing is not the evidence demonstrated here.

Permission remains tied to the approved scheme

The Tewin extension permission’s three conditions require commencement within three years, compliance with the approved drawings and external materials matching the existing building. They grant this scheme, rather than an unrestricted ability to extend elsewhere on the plot or change the approved design.

The Inspector did not impose a bat-related condition in the absence of evidence requiring one. He nevertheless noted the owner’s and contractors’ responsibility to understand protected-species legislation. Planning permission should not be read as a finding that other legal responsibilities disappear.

The full official decision, reference 6012750, contains the complete reasoning. Planning Geek’s guide to Green Belt and related land descriptions provides background to the designation.

0 Comments

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news