Birmingham City Council v Bravington [2023] EWCA Civ 308
Why this case matters to planning: The Court of Appeal examined how a local authority may serve a statutory notice and cast doubt on part of the older planning decision in R v Bromley London Borough Council, ex parte Sievers (1981) 41 P&CR 294. Its direct subject was housing possession, not planning permission. Planning practitioners should read the discussion of Sievers in that limited context.
Court: Court of Appeal (Civil Division). Judges: Moylan, Newey and Arnold LJJ. Judgment: 22 March 2023. Neutral citation: [2023] EWCA Civ 308. Case number: CA-2022-000285.
Background and the question of service
Birmingham City Council sought possession of a secure tenancy using the statutory provisions applicable to serious anti-social behaviour. It had to serve a notice on the tenant under section 83ZA of the Housing Act 1985. An officer delivered the notice to a woman who answered the door at the tenant’s home and identified herself as his partner. The tenant argued that he had not seen the notice and that it had not been lawfully served.
At first instance and on the first appeal, the tenant succeeded. The Court of Appeal was asked whether service was nevertheless effective under section 233 of the Local Government Act 1972, which permits specified statutory documents to be delivered, left at the proper address or posted. The appeal was not about whether an application for planning permission was made on time.
Important legal note: Planning Geek is a planning consultancy, not a law firm. This page provides general planning information and is not legal advice. Case law must be read in its factual and legal context and may be affected by later judgments, legislation or policy. Where the original judgment is available, it remains the authoritative source. If the outcome matters to a live case or dispute, take advice from an appropriately qualified planning solicitor or barrister.
Copyright and licensing: Crown copyright and other rights in judgments and source material remain with the relevant rights holders. Where a judgment is reproduced from Find Case Law, it is used under the Open Justice Licence and the source should be acknowledged. Material obtained from other sources is reproduced only where the applicable terms permit it. Planning Geek does not claim copyright in the text of court judgments.
What the Court of Appeal decided
Newey LJ held that the statutory requirements for service were met. A document could be left at an address by a method a reasonable person, intending to bring it to the recipient’s attention, would adopt. In the circumstances, delivery to the tenant’s partner who answered the door was sufficient. The tenant’s subsequent awareness of the notice was not the governing test. Moylan and Arnold LJJ agreed that the council’s appeal should be allowed.
The court treated section 233 of the 1972 Act as a provision which allocated the risk of non-receipt once a permitted method of service had been used. That was important to the possession proceedings, but the precise statutory requirements for each different type of notice must still be examined. Section 233 governs documents served by or on behalf of a local authority. Section 231 separately governs certain documents served on a local authority.
Why the court discussed the planning case Sievers
At paragraphs 30 and 31, Newey LJ considered R v Bromley London Borough Council, ex parte Sievers, a Divisional Court decision involving an application to approve reserved matters under outline planning permission. The deadline fell on a Sunday when the town hall was closed. The application was handed to an official on Monday. In Sievers, the Divisional Court had rejected the suggestion that the documents could have been left at the council’s offices by putting them through its letter box on the Sunday.
The Court of Appeal questioned that approach. Newey LJ said that placing a document in an appropriate letter box could amount to leaving it at the relevant address for the purposes of sections 231 and 233. He relied in part on Lord Newborough v Jones [1975] 1 Ch 90, which concerned an agricultural tenancy notice and had not apparently been cited in Sievers. Because Sievers was a Divisional Court decision, it did not bind the Court of Appeal.
Arnold LJ added an important qualification at paragraphs 43 and 44. In his reading, Shaw LJ’s remarks in Sievers also dealt with the timing of service: a document deposited in the town hall letter box on the Sunday would not actually come to the council’s attention before an employee received it on the Monday. The timing question should therefore not be confused with the more general issue of whether a letter box can constitute a valid method of leaving documents.
Subsequent planning significance
The Planning Court revisited these authorities in R (TNC Group Holdings Limited) v Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government [2026] EWHC 2912 (Admin). That later judgment concerned a reserved matters application uploaded to the Planning Portal before the deadline but not released to the local planning authority until the following day. The Planning Court distinguished Sievers and referred to the doubts expressed about its reasoning in Bravington. Importantly, the outcome in TNC also rested on the express rules for electronic communications in the development management procedure legislation.
Bravington should therefore not be quoted as deciding when a digital planning application is made, nor as creating a general grace period for deadlines. Its direct holding concerns statutory notice service under section 233 of the 1972 Act; its discussion of Sievers is relevant to the history and interpretation of planning application receipt and service requirements.
Practical implications
Planning professionals dealing with statutory time limits should distinguish the form of the document, the identity of its intended recipient, the prescribed methods of service and the moment at which a particular provision treats the document as received. A case about service on a tenant does not automatically resolve a question about electronic submission to a planning authority. The later TNC judgment gives more directly applicable guidance for applications made through the Planning Portal.
The complete approved Court of Appeal judgment, dated 22 March 2023, is available to Planning Geek Gold Members below.





