R (TNC Group Holdings Limited) v Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government [2026] EWHC 2912 (Admin)
R (TNC Group Holdings Limited) v Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government [2026] EWHC 2912 (Admin) concerns a reserved matters application submitted through the Planning Portal on the last day of the permission’s deadline. It was not made in time because the Portal did not release it to Wealden District Council until the following day.
The Planning Court dismissed the developer’s challenge to the Planning Inspectorate’s rejection of a non-determination appeal. The case clarifies the distinction between uploading documents to the Planning Portal and the local planning authority being able to access them. It also confirms that an Inspectorate case officer may reject an invalid appeal on the Secretary of State’s behalf.
Court: High Court, King’s Bench Division, Planning Court. Judge: C M G Ockelton sitting as a Judge of the High Court. Judgment handed down: 11 November 2026. Hearing: 16 July 2026. Case: AC-2026-LON-000239. Outcome: claim dismissed on grounds 2 and 3; permission on ground 1 had been refused earlier.
Important legal note: Planning Geek is a planning consultancy, not a law firm. This page provides general planning information and is not legal advice. Case law must be read in its factual and legal context and may be affected by later judgments, legislation or policy. Where the original judgment is available, it remains the authoritative source. If the outcome matters to a live case or dispute, take advice from an appropriately qualified planning solicitor or barrister.
Copyright and licensing: Crown copyright and other rights in judgments and source material remain with the relevant rights holders. Where a judgment is reproduced from Find Case Law, it is used under the Open Justice Licence and the source should be acknowledged. Material obtained from other sources is reproduced only where the applicable terms permit it. Planning Geek does not claim copyright in the text of court judgments.
A last-day reserved matters application in Crowborough
Wealden District Council granted TNC Group Holdings outline planning permission on 5 September 2023 for demolishing an existing care home and replacing it with a new care home at Old Lane, Crowborough, East Sussex. A condition required reserved matters to be submitted within 18 months, giving a deadline of 4 March 2025. If the application was not made in time, the outline permission could no longer be implemented in accordance with that condition.
At 4.36 pm on 4 March 2025, the developer uploaded the reserved matters documents to the Planning Portal. At 5.05 pm the Portal accepted the chosen payment mechanism and at 5.09 pm the money left the developer’s bank account. Crucially, the Portal did not process the payment until 9.06 am on 5 March, transmitted the application to the council at 3.16 pm and made it accessible to the council at about 3.35 pm. The council’s system downloaded it automatically at 3.46 pm.
The council initially proceeded with the application before concluding that it had arrived too late. The developer appealed for non-determination under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990. In December 2025 an Inspectorate case officer rejected the appeal as invalid because the reserved matters application had not been made within the original permission’s time limit. The company challenged that decision in the High Court.
When is an electronic application legally made?
The judge distinguished the application being uploaded to an intermediary from the application being received by the intended planning authority. The general principle, accepted by the claimant and discussed in Camden LBC v ADC Estates Ltd (1991) 61 P&CR 48, is that an application is made when it reaches the intended recipient. The question was whether the Planning Portal could be treated as the council’s agent for receipt. The judge referred to R (Morris Homes (North) Limited) v Bolton Council [2025] EWHC 657 (Admin), which emphasised that the meaning of an application being made depends on the statutory context. The court also cited R (Rahimian) v Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government [2016] EWHC 1634 (Admin), an enforcement appeal deadline case, for the description of the Portal as the Inspectorate’s online facility.
Ockelton rejected that argument. The Portal was not under the council’s control, was used for submissions to numerous authorities and operated as a transmission service. The judgment described it as “much more like a postbox” than a box on the council’s own premises. Neither the council encouraging electronic submission nor the applicant relinquishing control over uploaded documents changed the recipient for the legal test.
The Portal’s payment terms also mattered. They explained that an application would not be sent to the authority until payment had been received and processed, and that payment processing could be delayed. The court accepted that the developer bore the risk of the Portal’s timing under those terms. There was no need to establish why particular delays occurred during the night or following payment clearance.
The electronic communication rules and business hours
Article 2 of the Town and Country Planning (Development Management Procedure) (England) Order 2015 provided a second and independent route to the result. Under article 2(4), electronic transmission satisfies the relevant requirement only when the document is capable of being accessed by the recipient, legible and sufficiently permanent. The council could not access the documents until the Portal released them the next day.
Article 2(6) also treats electronic communications received outside the recipient’s business hours as received on the next working day. Here the council’s business hours ended at 5 pm. The court noted that the developer chose a payment arrangement that could not realistically be completed before that time. The rule is particularly important for submissions near a deadline, but it is not a universal pronouncement about every statutory digital system: the relevant legislation and the route used must be identified.
Section 93(4)(b) of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 expressly treats a reserved matters application made after the condition’s deadline as not made in accordance with the permission. A council’s earlier administrative processing of an application cannot retrospectively extend that statutory limit. The court held the application was made on 5 March 2025 and the original outline permission had therefore lapsed.
No one-day grace period
TNC relied on R v Bromley LBC ex parte Sievers (1981) 41 P&CR 294, an older judgment concerning a physical application delivered on the Monday after the deadline fell on a Sunday, when council offices were closed. The present judge distinguished that case on its facts and on the introduction of specific electronic communication provisions. The earlier suggestion that slight lateness could be ignored was not part of the decision necessary to resolve that case.
The court also referred to the Court of Appeal’s doubts about aspects of Sievers in Birmingham City Council v Bravington [2023] EWCA Civ 308. There was no basis to disregard a late electronic application as immaterial merely because the delay was one day. The point of the statutory deadline was to determine whether the reserved matters had been applied for within the original permission’s operative period.
Could an Inspectorate case officer reject the appeal?
The other surviving ground challenged the authority of the Planning Inspectorate case officer. TNC argued that the validity of a planning appeal could be decided only by the Secretary of State acting through an appointed inspector. The court rejected that position. Under the Carltona principle, civil servants can generally exercise functions in a minister’s name unless the law reserves a specific decision to another person.
Determining whether there was a valid appeal to determine was an administrative gateway question, not a substantive planning appeal requiring an inspector’s planning judgment. The Inspectorate case officer was therefore entitled to reject the purported appeal without an inspector first deciding the merits. The judge also considered the R v Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions, ex parte Bath and North East Somerset District Council [1999] 1 WLR 1759 appeal-validity authority and Newcastle-upon-Tyne City Council v Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government [2009] EWHC 3469 (Admin). Those authorities did not reserve the administrative rejection of an invalid appeal exclusively to an appointed inspector. The judge observed that a wrongly reached validity conclusion might itself be open to a challenge, but the mere identity of the case officer did not make the procedure unlawful.
The court also saw no basis for suggesting that an inspector could extend the statutory deadline for a reserved matters application after the outline permission had lapsed. That would conflict with the wording of section 93(4)(b). The challenge failed on both grounds before the court, and the claim was dismissed.
Practical consequences for applicants and authorities
For applicants, the safe date is not simply the day a form is uploaded or payment instructions are entered. The applicant needs evidence that the authority received an accessible submission within the applicable deadline and business-hours rules. Particular care is needed with bank transfers, larger fees, public holidays and last-day submissions. The Portal’s own confirmation of upload should not automatically be treated as proof that the authority has received the application.
For authorities and appeal practitioners, the judgment draws a clear distinction between the formal validity of an application and whether an appeal exists at all. It also demonstrates why deadlines in outline permissions should be checked against the statutory provisions, rather than assumed to be flexible after administrative correspondence begins.
This judgment concerns a reserved matters application under English planning legislation and the particular terms of the Planning Portal. It does not establish identical rules for all online planning systems or other jurisdictions. For related background, see Planning Geek’s guides to planning applications and planning appeals.
Planning Geek holds the complete nine-page approved judgment. Gold Members can access the locally protected document below.





