Skip to content

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

Need planning help?

Applications, appeals, permitted development, enforcement and planning strategy across England

Get planning advice →

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Planning Geek on YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Planning explanations, updates and practical guidance in video form

Watch on YouTube →

R (Hilary Jones) v Isle of Anglesey County Council [2024] EWHC 2582 (Admin)

In R (Hilary Jones) v Isle of Anglesey County Council, Mr Justice Mould considered when the change of use of a building can be treated as having commenced even though members of the public have not entered it for its intended new purpose. The case concerned a visitor information centre at the former Penrhos Estate near Holyhead. The High Court dismissed a judicial review challenging Anglesey Council’s conclusion that the permitted change of use had begun in time.

Court: High Court of Justice, King’s Bench Division, Administrative Court, Wales District Registry. Judge: Mould J. Judgment: 11 October 2024. Neutral citation: [2024] EWHC 2582 (Admin). Case number: AC-2023-CDF-000127. Interested party: Land and Lakes (Anglesey) Limited.

Important legal note: Planning Geek is a planning consultancy, not a law firm. This page provides general planning information and is not legal advice. Case law must be read in its factual and legal context and may be affected by later judgments, legislation or policy. Where the original judgment is available, it remains the authoritative source. If the outcome matters to a live case or dispute, take advice from an appropriately qualified planning solicitor or barrister.

Copyright and licensing: Crown copyright and other rights in judgments and source material remain with the relevant rights holders. Where a judgment is reproduced from Find Case Law, it is used under the Open Justice Licence and the source should be acknowledged. Material obtained from other sources is reproduced only where the applicable terms permit it. Planning Geek does not claim copyright in the text of court judgments.

The Penrhos hybrid planning permission

In April 2016, Isle of Anglesey County Council granted a single hybrid planning permission covering outline proposals for leisure and residential development and full permission for the change of use of several existing buildings at Penrhos Coastal Park. One was the Bailiff’s Tower, formerly used as a cricket clubhouse, which was to become a visitor information centre. Condition 70 required the relevant change of use to begin within five years, by 19 April 2021. A separate condition 4 regulated commencement of the outline elements.

In April 2021 the developer prepared an upper-floor room in the listed tower as a visitor centre. The work included redecoration, carpets, furniture, displays and signs. The room was ready for visitors, but Welsh coronavirus restrictions then prevented indoor visitor attractions from opening to the public. The developer supplied evidence of the works to the council before the five-year deadline.

Hilary Jones, a local resident and objector to the wider development, challenged the council’s subsequent decisions approving matters under a section 106 agreement. Her claim depended in part on the assertion that the full change-of-use permission had expired because no visitor centre had actually operated before the deadline.

Physical adaptation and actual use must be considered together

Mould J rejected the argument that day-to-day operation was a legal prerequisite for a material change of use. Applying Impey and Welwyn Hatfield v Beesley, the court explained that the decision-maker should consider the physical state of the building alongside its actual, attempted and intended use. Their relative weight depends on the circumstances. The absence of actual use is relevant, but it is not automatically decisive.

The restrictions were important because they provided a clear reason why a visitor centre that had been fitted out and made ready could not admit visitors. The council was entitled to find that the developer had done enough to bring about the new use even before public access became possible. The court rejected the contention that officers had misdirected councillors on this point.

Internal works and commencement under section 56

The claimant also argued that converting only one upper-floor room, without substantial operational development, could not implement the permission. The High Court disagreed. The change of use capable of constituting material development under section 56 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 could, on the facts, begin through the creation of a visitor centre ready for its intended function in part of the building. It was unnecessary to convert every room, and the fact that the work was mainly internal did not make the council’s conclusion irrational.

Later closure of the facility did not undo commencement. The relevant issue was whether the steps taken before 19 April 2021 were sufficient at the time. The judgment also considered the principle discussed in Riordan Communications that section 56 does not require proof of an intention to carry out the development continuously after the material operation.

The outline permission had its own commencement condition

Mould J separately considered whether any failure to commence the full change-of-use element would have caused the whole hybrid permission to lapse. He held that conditions 4 and 70 had distinct fields of operation. Condition 4 governed the outline elements, while condition 70 governed the full change-of-use element. Even if condition 70 had not been complied with, that would not by itself have prevented the outline development proceeding, provided its separate commencement condition had been satisfied.

The claimant’s challenge to the council’s refusal to open an enforcement investigation also failed. The High Court dismissed the judicial review on all grounds and refused permission to appeal. That is the court’s outcome, not a finding that all subsequent works at the wider Penrhos scheme necessarily comply with their permissions.

What Jones means for planning practice

The case is relevant to commencement disputes, certificates of lawfulness and enforcement questions involving the timing of a material change of use. A building may acquire the new planning use through adaptations and demonstrated readiness before it is actively used, but the conclusion must be reached on the individual evidence. Mere intention or paperwork will not necessarily be enough. The physical state of the premises and the practical reasons for any absence of activity remain central.

The decision arose from Welsh development, a particular hybrid permission and the statutory restrictions in force during April 2021. It should not be read as a general exemption from use commencement conditions or as authority that every empty, fitted-out building has already changed use.

Complete judgment

The complete judgment is available to Gold members below.

Affected by this case, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this page