Scottish substation appeals have resulted in approval for two major electricity grid projects at Carnaig in the Highlands and Hurlie in Aberdeenshire. On 18 November 2026, Scottish Ministers granted permission for the Carnaig 400-kilovolt substation, according to the official Planning and Environmental Appeals Division record. SSEN Transmission announced the approvals of both schemes on the same day.
The Carnaig development is proposed on land south-west of Loch Buidhe near Bonar Bridge. It would provide a new 400kV substation and associated infrastructure, with access and landscaping. Its planning appeal, PPA-270-2322, followed Highland Council’s refusal of application 24/05062/FUL, despite officers having recommended approval.
The second of the Scottish substation appeals concerns Hurlie at Fetteresso Forest near Stonehaven. The official DPEA record and decision letter confirm that Scottish Ministers also granted planning permission for that project on 18 November 2026, following Aberdeenshire Council’s refusal. Both cases had been recalled for determination by Scottish Ministers on 25 March 2026, and in each case Ministers adopted the reporter’s recommendation that planning permission be granted.
Two refusals reversed through the Scottish appeals system
The Scottish substation appeals follow a sequence in which both councils declined permission despite favourable officer recommendations. At Carnaig, the Scottish Government’s case record gives the originating application number as 24/05062/FUL and the appeal reference as PPA-270-2322. The appeal was received on 18 February 2026, and its official record states that the application was granted on 18 November. The case was handled through written and further written submissions, with a report prepared for Ministers.
At Hurlie, SSEN had applied to Aberdeenshire Council under reference APP/2024/1951. Its application covered a 400kV air-insulated substation, site access, earthworks, drainage, landscaping and temporary construction compounds at Fetteresso Forest. The council refused the proposals in early 2026, and the developer lodged appeal PPA-110-2474 on 27 February. The DPEA record shows the appeal was decided on 18 November 2026, the same day the company announced the outcome.
Both cases were recalled by Ministers because they raised matters of national importance under National Planning Framework 4. At Carnaig, Ministers accepted that significant landscape and visual effects would arise during construction and early operation but agreed they would be temporary and localised, and granted permission subject to 34 conditions; the applicant’s claim for expenses was refused. In the Hurlie decision letter, Scottish Ministers agreed with the reporter that while there would be significant landscape and visual effects, these would be experienced from very few locations and localised with design mitigation applied
. Ministers removed the reporter’s recommended socio-economic and military aircraft remains conditions, narrowed the biodiversity condition to onsite measures, and awarded expenses against Aberdeenshire Council. Both reporters also considered whether each substation formed part of a larger EIA project with its grid connections, applying the Court of Session’s ruling in Raeshaw Farms v Scottish Ministers.
Why Carnaig and Hurlie matter for electricity capacity
Both schemes form part of SSEN Transmission’s programme to reinforce the northern electricity transmission network. The company says the 400kV substations are intended to help connect new generation, relieve constraints and move electricity between regions. A substation is not a generating station: it provides equipment to switch, transform and manage electricity moving through the high-voltage network.
The wider SSEN investment programme is significant in scale. The company has described a proposed £29 billion programme across the north of Scotland and associated opportunities for employment and suppliers. That programme-level figure must not be mistaken for the construction cost of either Carnaig or Hurlie, and forecasts of regional economic benefit are not guarantees that individual contracts or jobs have been secured.
The Scottish substation appeals are therefore more than ordinary small-site disputes. Electricity network capacity affects the timing and viability of generation projects, large industrial users and other energy-intensive development. Equally, the national importance of the network does not remove the requirement for individual projects to be assessed against environmental, landscape and community impacts.
Local objections and the importance of the decision documents
Hurlie has been contentious locally. The reporter’s report records 2,318 representations to the council, of which 2,308 objected, together with a petition of 1,140 signatures. Earlier reports describe objections about the location and the potential industrialisation of the rural landscape. Those concerns should not be dismissed simply because the final outcome differs from the council’s refusal.
The fact that a planning officer supports a proposal does not oblige elected councillors to do the same. Nor does a council’s refusal mean that Ministers must uphold it. The appeal stage requires a decision on the submitted evidence, the relevant statutory and policy framework and the planning merits of the individual application. The full reasons matter much more to future applicants than a headline saying that an appeal was won.
For the Carnaig decision, the official Scottish appeal case record publishes the decision letter and reporter’s report dated 18 November, as does the Hurlie case record (PPA-110-2474). SSEN’s announcement sets out the company’s response to both approvals.
What the Scottish substation appeals mean for planning practice
The practical distinction is between the original local authority decision, the subsequent appeal decision and physical implementation. A ministerial approval can change the planning status of a project, but construction still needs to comply with the decision’s conditions and any other applicable requirements. Land arrangements, construction planning, environmental controls and the wider transmission programme may all affect delivery.
The Scottish substation appeals also illustrate why Scotland must be treated as a separate planning jurisdiction. Its framework, decision-making institutions and appeal arrangements are not interchangeable with the procedures applying to most development in England. Planning Geek’s planning in Scotland overview explains the jurisdictional distinction and provides a route into Scottish planning coverage.
SSEN Transmission’s director of development, Alison Hall, described the two approvals as an important milestone for these nationally significant projects
. That is the developer’s assessment of their significance, rather than a substitute for the Ministers’ formal planning reasons. The company says it will continue engaging with councils, landowners and communities as the projects develop.
What happens next for the two schemes
Anyone relying on these decisions should check the conditions, approved drawings and any other permissions required, many of which must be discharged before development starts. Both decisions are final subject to the right of any person aggrieved to apply to the Court of Session within six weeks of the 18 November 2026 decision letters, and each permission must be commenced within five years.
The Scottish Government has separately announced that the DPEA case-management portal will be unavailable from 20 to 27 November 2026, with normal service expected from 30 November. Anyone reviewing these Scottish substation appeals should retain copies of key documents and check the alternative submission guidance rather than assume the portal will be continuously accessible during that period.
For now, the material new stage is the confirmed approval of two large 400kV projects after council refusals. The next commercially meaningful developments will be the detailed conditions, confirmation of construction programmes and any further legal or technical steps, rather than another repetition of the same approval announcement.

0 Comments