Mayes, White and Oubridge v Secretary of State for Wales and Dinefwr Borough Council [1989] JPL 848
Mayes v Secretary of State for Wales is the High Court case that planning Inspectors still turn to when a council has failed to serve an enforcement notice on somebody who was entitled to receive a copy. It supplies the test for deciding whether that failure caused substantial prejudice, which is the question that usually decides an appeal on ground (e).
The short version is that a missed recipient does not automatically defeat the notice. The question is whether proper service could realistically have left that person in a different position.
Important legal note: Planning Geek is a planning consultancy, not a law firm. This page provides general planning information and is not legal advice. Case law must be read in its factual and legal context and may be affected by later judgments, legislation or policy. Where the original judgment is available, it remains the authoritative source. If the outcome matters to a live case or dispute, take advice from an appropriately qualified planning solicitor or barrister.
Copyright and licensing: Crown copyright and other rights in judgments and source material remain with the relevant rights holders. Where a judgment is reproduced from Find Case Law, it is used under the Open Justice Licence and the source should be acknowledged. Material obtained from other sources is reproduced only where the applicable terms permit it. Planning Geek does not claim copyright in the text of court judgments.
Need help with a planning application?
Planning Geek isn’t just a reference site - preparing and submitting planning applications is what we do. If you’d like a hand with an application, an appeal or any other planning matter, we’d be glad to help.
What Mayes decided
The case came from Dinefwr, a former borough in west Wales that is now part of Carmarthenshire. An enforcement notice had been appealed to the Secretary of State for Wales, and the dispute then reached the High Court, where it was heard by a deputy judge. It is reported in the Journal of Planning and Environment Law for 1989 at page 848, and Inspectors usually shorten the name to Mayes v Secretary of State for Wales or Mayes v SSW.
The problem was one of service. People who were entitled to be served with copies of the enforcement notice had not been properly served. The law allowed that kind of failure to be overlooked, but only if nobody had been substantially prejudiced by it. The court therefore had to say what substantial prejudice means in practice.
The deputy judge framed the test as a question: was there “any realistic prospect” that the people who should have been served would have found themselves in a different position had they been given their copies properly? He made clear that a difference in any respect would count. It did not have to be a material or significant difference.
On the facts, the answer went against the challenge. As Inspectors have since described the case, every point and objection open to the people who were missed had been heard, and their interests had been fully explored during the appeal. Proper service would have changed nothing for them, so the failure could be disregarded.
Mayes is also cited for a point aimed squarely at councils. All reasonable steps should be taken to identify everyone entitled to a copy of an enforcement notice, and those people should then be properly served.
The realistic prospect test
The test has two halves, and both matter.
The first half sets a low bar. The person who was missed does not have to show that they would have won an appeal, or even that they would definitely have appealed. It is enough that their position could realistically have been different in some respect.
The second half keeps the test honest. The prospect has to be realistic, not fanciful, and it has to flow from the failure to serve. If the person knew about the notice in time, took part in the appeal and said everything they wanted to say, proper service would have added nothing.
This is why the outcome turns so heavily on evidence. An Inspector needs to know who was missed, what interest they hold in the land, when they found out about the notice and what they could no longer do by that point.
Harm from the notice is not harm from the missed service
A common mistake is to argue that somebody is prejudiced because the notice affects their property. That is true of almost every owner, tenant and lender, and it is not the question.
The point was put neatly at a 2021 inquiry in Banwell, North Somerset, where the appellant complained that a mortgage lender had not been served. The council’s barrister described Mayes as setting a four stage test, with the last stage asking whether the failure to serve had itself caused actual prejudice. A lender’s interest will always be affected by the notice, he said, but that is a different matter from being harmed by not receiving a copy.
That was an advocate’s summary of the judgment, not the Inspector’s own finding, so it should not be quoted as the court’s wording. The distinction it draws is sound, though, and it matches how Inspectors approach the issue. In the event, the Inspector found that the notice had been served on everyone it needed to be, so the prejudice question did not arise.
How Inspectors apply Mayes today
Mayes comes up regularly in enforcement appeals. These decisions show the test working in both directions.
- Wallington, Sutton (October 2026): the council accepted that the man living in a caravan on the site had not been served. He was handed the notice months later and invited to the inquiry, but by then it was too late for him to lodge his own appeal, and nobody else had appealed on ground (a). He had lost any chance to ask for planning permission, even a temporary or personal one, and stood to lose his home. Applying Mayes, the Inspector found substantial prejudice and quashed the notice. The council was also ordered to pay part of the appellant’s costs for continuing to defend the point
- Hadley Highstone, Barnet (September 2021): neighbours with rights over a shared accessway were not served within the 28 day period, but the council later wrote to them explaining how to comment on the appeal. The Inspector found no substantial prejudice and cited Mayes in support
- Walton Close, Brent (November 2026): a landlord argued that tenants of a house in multiple occupation should each have been served, but did not name a single tenant who had been missed. With nobody identified, there was nothing to which the test could be applied. Ground (e) failed and the landlord was ordered to pay costs for running it
- Northern Ireland (appeal 2020/E0020): the Planning Appeals Commission applied Mayes to the equivalent Northern Ireland provision. It asked whether anyone had been denied the opportunity to take part in the appeal itself, and arranged for the owners who had been missed to be notified and invited to make representations
The pattern is consistent. Where a person learns of the notice in time to say or do everything they could have done anyway, a late copy cures the problem. Where a right has already gone, most obviously the right to bring their own appeal, it does not.
Where the test sits in the legislation
Mayes was decided under the Town and Country Planning Act 1971, which was then in force. Inspectors now apply its test to the Town and Country Planning Act 1990. In England, three provisions work together:
- Section 172(2) requires a copy of the notice to be served on the owner and the occupier of the land, and on anyone else with an interest that the council considers is materially affected
- Section 174(2)(e) makes it a ground of appeal that copies were not served as section 172 requires
- Section 176(5) allows the failure to be disregarded if neither the appellant nor the person who was missed has been substantially prejudiced
Mayes explains the last of these. It is also worth knowing that section 174(1) lets a person with an interest in the land appeal whether or not they were served. Somebody who hears about a notice by another route can still protect their position, provided they act before the notice takes effect.
Two more recent cases deal with neighbouring questions. Turner v Secretary of State looks at what counts as valid service on a site with many occupiers, including fixing the notice to the entrance gates. Stern v Horsham District Council concerns a notice that reached the right person but too late, which the High Court treated as a different defect from not being served at all.
Using Mayes in a ground (e) appeal
If you are relying on a failure of service, the appeal needs more than the bare fact that somebody was missed. Be ready to show:
- Who was not served, by name, and what their interest in the land is
- How and when they eventually found out about the notice, if they did
- What they could have done with proper service that they can no longer do, such as bringing their own appeal or asking for permission under ground (a)
- Evidence from that person wherever possible, because an Inspector will give little weight to prejudice claimed on behalf of someone who has said nothing
Ground (e) run without that evidence carries a real costs risk, as the Brent decision shows. Our guide to the award of costs explains when unreasonable behaviour leads to an order.
For councils, the lesson runs the other way. Check the Land Registry, use a planning contravention notice to find out who occupies the land, and keep a clear record of service. If somebody turns out to have been missed, tell them straight away and invite them to take part. That will often be enough, but it cannot restore a right of appeal that has already expired, and defending the notice regardless can be expensive.
An Inspector’s ruling on ground (e) is a decision on a point of law, so either side can ask the High Court to review it through a section 289 challenge.
About this summary
The complete original judgment is not currently held. This account of its reasoning and outcome is supported by later Planning Inspectorate decisions, particularly the Wallington enforcement appeal in October 2026, which quotes the court’s test, and the Banwell enforcement appeal in May 2021, which discusses how that test is applied. The reported citation is [1989] JPL 848.
Mayes v Secretary of State for Wales Case Law Page Updated: 18th November 2026





