Scottish Ministers granted consent for the An Càrr Dubh wind farm in Argyll and Bute on 26 October 2026 despite an objection from the council. The decision authorises 13 turbines with blade tips up to 180 metres, an indicative 85.8MW wind generating capacity and an associated 20MW energy storage facility.
The An Càrr Dubh consent followed a public inquiry prompted by Argyll and Bute Council’s unresolved landscape and visual objections. Ministers granted both section 36 electricity consent and deemed planning permission, accepting some significant effects on scenery and the setting of a scheduled monument while giving substantial weight to renewable energy and climate benefits.
The signed 45-page decision notice contains a particularly important limitation: development cannot commence until details and environmental effects of the grid connection have been approved and the connection has its own necessary consent. Consent for the turbines is therefore not the same as permission to start building the whole project.
Why ministers granted An Càrr Dubh consent
The applicant behind An Càrr Dubh, Car Duibh Wind Farm Limited, submitted the scheme under section 36 of the Electricity Act 1989 on 12 April 2023. The site is approximately six kilometres north-west of Inveraray and 4.5 kilometres east of Dalavich, close to the operating An Suidhe wind farm and consented Blarghour development. The landscape is mainly moorland, heath, peat and rocky upland, with forest along part of the access route.
The proposal includes 13 turbines, foundations, electrical infrastructure, an energy storage facility, a meteorological mast, construction compounds and around 23.1 kilometres of site access tracks, including upgrades to existing tracks. It also includes numerous watercourse crossings and works associated with access from the road network. These are substantial engineering works, not merely thirteen turbine foundations.
Under section 57(2) of the Town and Country Planning (Scotland) Act 1997, ministers directed that planning permission be deemed granted alongside section 36 consent. The decision followed a public inquiry involving written submissions and hearings between March and June 2025. Reporter Philip McLean submitted his report and recommendation on 6 November 2025. He recommended consent subject to conditions, and ministers accepted that overall recommendation.
National Planning Framework 4 (NPF4) was central to the planning balance. Ministers acknowledged the significant weight given under the framework to renewable energy generation and greenhouse gas reduction. Their determination says the scheme is “acceptable and supported overall by NPF4 policies”. They considered that the adverse impacts, although important, did not outweigh the support for renewable generation across the development plan.
Council objection and landscape consequences
Argyll and Bute Council objected to An Càrr Dubh because of landscape and visual effects, particularly views around Loch Awe and the Dun na Cuaiche folly at Inveraray. Its concerns included turbines appearing to overlap from several viewpoints, turbine 13 looking detached from the main group, the prominence of turbines 1 and 2 and cumulative effects with neighbouring wind farms.
The Scottish Ministers did not pretend that the visual harm disappeared. Their decision acknowledges significant landscape and visual effects, generally localised within approximately ten kilometres, including effects in the Loch Awe and Loch Avich areas. They agreed with the reporter that the design was not fully aligned with wind farm design guidance, but that some mitigation had been achieved and the remaining effects were acceptable in the overall balance.
The heritage issue was also explicit. Historic Environment Scotland considered that the wind farm would significantly affect the setting of Ardchonnel Castle and the Island of Innis Chonnel scheduled monument, although it did not object on national-interest grounds. Ministers accepted the significant adverse effect on that setting. They nevertheless concluded that the scheme’s renewable energy, emissions and wider benefits justified granting consent subject to the specified controls.
Golden eagle concerns and ecological mitigation
Golden eagle habitat around An Càrr Dubh was one of the most sensitive issues at the inquiry. NatureScot did not object, but warned of a high risk of abandonment of a golden eagle territory because of habitat loss and cumulative disturbance. It also questioned whether the applicant’s original habitat proposals would mitigate that risk. RSPB Scotland objected unless an off-site golden eagle habitat management plan was secured.
The reporter accepted that the development would remove good golden eagle habitat, but considered significant effects on regional or national populations unlikely if habitat measures were secured through conditions. Ministers agreed that there remained potential for adverse effects on golden eagles. Crucially, they did not present all wildlife effects as non-existent merely because the scheme was approved.
The final conditions require a Habitat Management Plan, Restoration and Enhancement Plan and pre-commencement Bird Protection Plan informed by further surveys. There must also be golden eagle monitoring and bird and bat collision monitoring. The Restoration and Enhancement Plan must also cover peatland restoration and the management of woodland and riparian habitats. The decision judged that the risks could be managed through enforceable conditions, rather than by requiring the wind farm to be refused.
The grid connection condition is critical
The An Càrr Dubh consent notice openly recognises that the route, nature, scale and location of the off-site electricity grid connection are not yet known. Ministers considered the connection and the turbines to form a single project for environmental impact assessment purposes because the development could not function without both elements.
Rather than claiming the unknown connection had been comprehensively assessed, ministers imposed a multistage condition. No development may start until connection details, including likely significant environmental effects, have been approved by ministers in consultation with the planning authority. Any necessary planning permission or section 37 consent for the grid connection must also be obtained. This is a significant distinction for anyone considering the legal effect of the wind farm decision.
The decision therefore demonstrates the importance of reading the planning conditions, not simply the headline saying consent has been granted. A developer can receive a positive ministerial determination and still face substantial pre-commencement hurdles where associated infrastructure and environmental assessment have not yet been fully resolved.
Time limits, construction controls and next steps
Ministers granted the development a five-year period to commence, rather than the usual three years for deemed planning permission. The applicant had sought seven years, citing uncertainty over grid connection timescales, but the reporter and ministers were not persuaded that a longer period was justified. The electricity consent allows a 40-year operational period calculated by the commissioning provisions in the decision.
Further conditions control turbine appearance, micro-siting, construction traffic, forestry, peat, archaeology, bird protection, aviation lighting and operational noise. The final noise condition incorporates the 2026 Assessment and Rating of Wind Turbine Noise guidance. Aviation lighting must be reviewed periodically, including consideration of technology that could reduce the time lights remain visible.
Argyll and Bute Council will retain a significant role in approving details required by the deemed planning permission and monitoring compliance. The permission includes requirements for independent ecological, environmental, geotechnical and planning monitoring roles. These matters will influence how the scheme can proceed, even though ministers have resolved the principal consent decision.
Statkraft, which is developing the project, announced the consent on 27 October 2026 and said: “The focus will now be on securing a route to market and discharging planning conditions ahead of construction.” Readers following other projects north of the border can find more in Planning Geek’s guide to planning in Scotland.
The original primary source is the Scottish Government’s DPEA inquiry register, case WIN-130-10, together with the signed 26 October 2026 decision notice, reference ECU00004781. For wider reading on environmental controls, see Planning Geek’s conservation and protected sites guide; the particular statutory consent and policy framework here is Scottish. The new decision is consent, not confirmation that construction is under way.

0 Comments