A Middlewich assisted living appeal has secured permission for six specialist flats after an Inspector accepted revised surface water drainage evidence. The decision on 20 November 2026 overturned Cheshire East Council’s refusal, but a separate application for a full award of appeal costs was rejected.
The scheme at Powell House, Powell Drive, was promoted by Hollinshead Properties Ltd under application 25/3825/FUL. Inspector F P Tinsley concluded that a revised drainage strategy dealt with the original reason for refusal and imposed conditions to secure long-term management of the system and limit occupation to eligible residents.
The assisted living appeal illustrates a distinction important to applicants and councils alike. A scheme may become acceptable after new technical evidence is submitted during an appeal without making the authority’s earlier refusal unreasonable. The timing and completeness of information are central to both decisions.
Why the assisted living appeal was allowed
The Council originally refused the six flats because the submitted surface water strategy had not demonstrated that runoff from a design storm could be managed without affecting adjoining property. The Lead Local Flood Authority (LLFA) wanted further detail showing that the one-in-100-year rainfall event, with an allowance for climate change, would be contained within the site.
The appellant subsequently supplied revised drainage calculations and a block plan during the appeal. Inspector Tinsley accepted those documents because they responded directly to the LLFA’s identified deficiency and were relatively minor changes to the drainage arrangements, not a material redesign of the whole development. The Council and interested parties had an opportunity to comment, avoiding procedural prejudice.
The revised system included permeable tarmac to access and parking areas. This would spread infiltration across a larger proportion of the site and reduce reliance on impermeable hard surfacing. The updated drawing showed impermeable coverage falling from about 46 per cent of the existing site to around 19 per cent following redevelopment. Raised planting beds were proposed, but the drainage calculations did not depend on them.
The Inspector found that the assisted living appeal scheme would manage surface water adequately through sustainable drainage measures and would not increase flood risk to adjacent land. That removed the conflict with policies ENV16 and SE13 identified during the application. Planning Geek’s flood risk assessment guidance explains why the quality of evidence is essential even where the underlying development principle is acceptable.
Housing need and a protected historic setting
Cheshire East Council could not demonstrate a five-year supply of deliverable housing sites. This was not the technical reason for refusal, but it was relevant to the planning balance after the drainage objection was resolved. The Inspector gave significant weight to the scheme’s contribution to housing need, including accommodation for older people and those requiring care or support.
The site was previously developed land, and the Inspector was not given substantive evidence suggesting that local infrastructure could not accommodate six additional dwellings. The August 2026 National Planning Policy Framework’s housing policies supported the provision, particularly in the context of the local land supply shortfall. Planning Geek’s five-year housing land supply guide provides the wider policy background.
Part of Powell House falls within Middlewich Conservation Area. The Inspector considered that the proposal’s scale, siting, design and materials would preserve its character and appearance, meeting the statutory conservation duty under section 72(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990. This was a neutral consideration rather than an additional positive reason to approve the scheme.
Conditions secure specialist housing and drainage
The assisted living appeal was allowed subject to conditions addressing implementation, approved drawings, external materials, landscaping and the delivery and ongoing management of the drainage system. The Council did not submit suggested conditions, so the Inspector selected those considered necessary to make the development acceptable under the national tests.
The drainage strategy demonstrated that an appropriate solution was possible, but detailed arrangements for its operation, adoption, maintenance and management remained to be secured. A condition prevented development above ground level until those details were approved. That approach distinguished technical feasibility, already evidenced at appeal, from the arrangements necessary for long-term performance.
Another condition restricts occupation to people aged 55 or over or those with a demonstrated need for care or support, together with qualifying partners, spouses or carers. Without that safeguard, the Inspector considered that the scheme could become unrestricted market housing rather than the specialist accommodation that had been assessed. The wording and enforceability of planning conditions remain important after a successful appeal.
Why the full costs claim was refused
A separate costs application was made by the appellant. It alleged that Cheshire East Council had refused permission prematurely, without securing a further opportunity to revise the surface water design. This was considered independently from the planning merits, and Inspector Tinsley refused the requested award.
The application was submitted on 3 October 2025 without a surface water drainage strategy. The parties later agreed an extension of time to 9 February 2026 so additional information could be prepared and reviewed. The drainage submission was made on 2 February, leaving only seven days within that first extension for consultation with the LLFA. A second extension was agreed, taking the deadline to 25 February.
The LLFA’s 17 February response still identified an unresolved drainage issue. No acceptable revised strategy was received before the Council determined the application on 24 February. There was also no further agreed extension. The costs Inspector accepted that the question was whether the authority had behaved unreasonably in those circumstances, not whether a different procedural route might ultimately have avoided an appeal.
The Inspector remarked that “a different procedural course may have been available”, but that did not establish unreasonable behaviour. The Council had already agreed two extensions and lacked satisfactory technical evidence when it made its decision. The Council’s later decision not to make substantive representations on the appeal merits did not alter the circumstances that existed when it made the original decision.
The assisted living appeal therefore provides a particularly clear example of a successful planning appeal without a costs award. For an award, the applicant must demonstrate unreasonable conduct that caused unnecessary or wasted appeal expense. Winning on the revised merits is not enough. Planning Geek’s guide to recovering planning appeal costs covers the separate process.
Practical consequences of the decisions
Applicants relying on a technical report should establish early whether the decision-maker has the final information it needs. Here, the revised drainage design was sufficiently close to the application proposal to be accepted on appeal, but that did not erase the earlier evidence gap or guarantee recovery of the appellant’s costs.
For councils, the assisted living appeal shows that a refusal may have been justified on the record available at the decision date, even if a planning Inspector later grants permission following fresh evidence. For developers, it reinforces the importance of obtaining consultation responses and agreeing realistic submission timetables rather than assuming the appeal procedure will cure every evidential omission.
The planning appeal is 6013435 and the associated costs decision was issued on 20 November 2026. The official Planning Inspectorate page is appeal 6013435. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase. The short quotation is from Planning Inspectorate material released under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

0 Comments