A retrospective flats application has been submitted to Newham Council to retain an already-built residential block in Forest Gate, east London. The latest proposal, validated on 26 October 2026, seeks permission for three self-contained homes following years of enforcement action over an unauthorised three-storey building.
The council approved a two-storey building containing two maisonettes in January 2018. Instead, a three-storey development containing four homes was erected. Newham issued a demolition enforcement notice in 2022, but an Inspector later varied the notice to allow alterations that would bring the building into line with the original permission.
The retrospective flats application has attracted renewed attention after BBC reporting on 19 November. The important distinction is that the earlier enforcement appeal did not grant planning permission for the building as constructed. The new design must still be assessed on its own merits, including the quality of accommodation, appearance and neighbouring heritage assets.
What the retrospective flats application proposes
The current application, 26/02044/FUL, relates to land behind Romford Road. Newham’s application record names Equator Properties (UK) Limited and Surbjit Aulak. The plans seek to retain a building containing three residential units while removing its existing roof, constructing a mansard roof, adding a first-floor balcony and providing landscaping, private amenity space, cycle parking and refuse storage.
The scheme would retain the two lower-floor flats and replace two existing top-floor studio units with one single-bedroom flat. The applicant’s housing-quality submission says the revised accommodation would meet the Nationally Described Space Standard. That is a case being advanced in support of the application, not a finding that the council has accepted the space standards or approved the scheme.
There is also a heritage dimension. The backland plot adjoins the Forest Gate Town Centre and Woodgrange Estate Conservation Areas and affects the setting of Grade II listed Emmanuel Church. The applicant’s supporting statement argues that a zinc-clad mansard and more orderly external details would improve the building. Newham must reach its own conclusion on design, setting and residential amenity.
How the original permission differs from what was built
The starting point was permission 17/03965/FUL, issued on 31 January 2018. It authorised a new two-storey building with two two-bedroom maisonettes on the former vacant rear plot. Details relating to construction logistics and contaminated land were subsequently approved in June 2019.
The development that was actually built contained two flats and two studio units across three storeys. Newham’s enforcement notice, identified in its later officer report as 2000482ENFC, was issued on 8 August 2022. It alleged the unauthorised erection of a building containing four self-contained residential units and required demolition and removal of the resulting materials within six months.
This is not simply a dispute about a roof shape. The approved building, the completed four-unit development and the newly proposed three-unit arrangement are different schemes. A retrospective flats proposal needs to be considered in that context: retaining some of a building does not mean every departure from an earlier permission has become lawful.
The enforcement appeal was varied, not quashed
The decisive earlier proceeding was enforcement appeal APP/G5750/C/22/3305768, decided by Inspector R Satheesan on 27 November 2023. The appellant was Equator Properties UK Limited. The appeal proceeded on grounds (f) and (g) under section 174 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990. A ground (a) appeal, which could have resulted in planning permission being considered, lapsed because the prescribed fees were not paid.
On ground (f), the Inspector considered whether demolition was excessive when the earlier permission might still be capable of implementation. The Inspector examined section 56 of the 1990 Act, foundation works and the wording of outstanding planning conditions, concluding on the balance of probabilities that the 2018 permission had commenced before expiry. Not all undischarged conditions prevented lawful commencement, because their terms and significance differed.
The Inspector noted that enforcement should be “remedial rather than punitive”. The decision replaced the demolition-only requirement with a choice: alter the building so that it wholly complied with the 2018 plans, conditions and limitations, or demolish it. Following either route, resulting materials would have to be removed. The appeal also succeeded on ground (g), extending the compliance period from six to twelve months, having considered the position of tenants living there.
Crucially, the enforcement notice was upheld subject to those variations. The Inspector neither approved the existing four homes nor authorised a third storey as built. The distinction between grounds (a), (f) and (g) is explained in Planning Geek’s guide to enforcement appeal grounds.
A further retrospective application was refused in 2024
After the appeal, another proposal sought to reshape the development into a two-bedroom flat and a four-bedroom maisonette. Newham refused application 23/02640/FUL on 30 July 2024. The application reference begins with 23, but the published decision was issued in 2024.
The council’s delegated report and refusal notice raised more than the existence of unauthorised development. They identified concerns about the building’s roof proportions, architectural treatment, standards of accommodation and outlook. The report described bedrooms relying on rooflights for their outlook and questioned the usefulness of external amenity space. Sustainable transport and the scheme’s arrangements for vehicles also featured in the refusal.
A separate 2024 proposal for prior approval to add a storey, reference 24/00680/PREHHA, had also been rejected. These decisions show why a revised layout alone is not an automatic answer to an enforcement problem: the council can assess the proposed development against applicable design, housing and amenity policies.
What the developer says has changed
The new retrospective flats application proposes replacing the existing roof with a mansard and consolidating the two small upper-floor studios into one flat. Supporting documents dated September 2026 present the scheme as a response to the earlier findings. They include housing-quality, daylight and sunlight, heritage, transport, waste, fire-safety and demolition-method submissions.
The application form identifies pre-application discussions in March 2026. It says the proposal was supported in principle, subject to waste and cycle-storage arrangements. The planning statement also refers to advice from council officers. This is the applicant’s account of pre-application advice; it is not an issued planning permission, an approval of every drawing or a guarantee of how a final application will be determined.
It will be particularly important to see whether the new accommodation is genuinely satisfactory in practice and whether the revised roof and access arrangements overcome the earlier concerns. The heritage setting adds another assessment separate from the internal floor plans. A reduction from four homes to three does not dispense with the need to justify the scheme.
What happens to the enforcement position?
The current retrospective flats application was validated on 26 October 2026 and, in the records checked for this report, no determination has been identified. Newham must decide whether the three-unit development, including proposed alterations, is acceptable. The existing enforcement appeal decision remains a separate legal event with its own varied requirements.
Submitting a retrospective application does not itself grant planning permission or establish that an enforcement notice has been complied with. Nor does pre-application feedback displace a formal decision. Whether an enforcement notice has been complied with, or what further enforcement steps are available, depends on the operative notice, the facts on the ground and any later lawful decisions; none should be assumed merely from this new submission.
For applicants and advisers, this case underlines why it pays to understand the scope of an existing permission before proposing yet another redesign. Planning Geek’s guide to the order of planning enforcement explains how notices, appeals and subsequent steps fit together. The retrospective flats proposal will need a substantive decision on its planning merits, whatever the result of the earlier appeal.
Original records and reporting
The primary records are Newham Council’s 2026 application, its 2024 refusal and the Inspector’s 2023 enforcement appeal decision. The dispute has also been reported by BBC News.

0 Comments