Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

St Helens Article 4 confirmed for 1st December

The borough-wide HMO Direction starts on 1st December, with the council acknowledging potential compensation risks from its short timetable.

The St Helens Article 4 Direction has been confirmed as an immediate Direction across the borough, with a stated commencement date of 1st December 2026. It removes the permitted development right to convert a family home into a small house in multiple occupation (HMO).

From 1st December, a change from a dwellinghouse in Use Class C3 to a small HMO in Use Class C4 within the area will normally need planning permission. The council’s decision record, dated 20th November, follows a public consultation.

I would urge anyone with a project in progress to check the legal documents and the position of their property now. The report also acknowledges a risk of compensation claims because the council chose a shorter timetable rather than waiting 12 months.

What the St Helens Article 4 decision says

The council’s published delegated decision record is headed “Confirmation of Article 4 direction for HMO’s” and describes the measure as borough-wide. Its report gives 1st December as the date the Direction would come into force.

The council has confirmed the Direction as immediate, with a stated commencement date of 1st December 2026. Its 20th November delegated decision record contrasts the short timetable with a 12-month, non-immediate option that would have reduced potential compensation exposure. That longer option was not selected. The report records the confirmation decision, but the signed Direction, confirmation notice and map have not yet been independently checked for their exact legal wording and boundary.

The St Helens Article 4 Direction is due to take effect on 1st December, so the restriction has not yet started. Anyone affected should check the formal documents and the position of their particular property.

We previously reported on the St Helens consultation and proposed December timetable. The new decision record addresses the responses received after that consultation.

Which HMO changes are affected?

The St Helens Article 4 restriction concerns the permitted development right that can allow a change from a C3 dwellinghouse to a C4 small HMO without a separate planning application. A C4 HMO generally accommodates three to six people who form more than one household and share facilities.

When a valid Direction removes that right for a property, an applicant must seek express planning permission for the affected change of use. The council can then consider the proposal against the development plan and other material planning considerations. Neighbours may have an opportunity to comment through the application process.

This is not a blanket prohibition on shared housing. The report states that the Direction “does not prevent all HMO’s” but would give the council control over their location and impacts. A planning application can be approved or refused on its merits.

It is also important to distinguish planning permission from HMO licensing. A property may need a licence under housing legislation as well as the correct planning position. One does not automatically establish the other.

Existing use and unfinished projects

An existing lawful C4 use does not automatically become unlawful because the St Helens Article 4 restriction takes effect. What matters is whether the relevant use had actually begun lawfully, and whether evidence supports that position. An intention to let a house, a purchase or building work alone does not necessarily establish that the change of use has occurred.

If you already operate a small HMO, consider keeping dated evidence of occupation and the nature of the use. A certificate of lawfulness can provide a formal determination on an appropriate application, but it is not automatic and depends on the facts and evidence.

For an unfinished project, I would establish the current lawful use, the actual stage of occupation, any existing planning conditions and the relevant commencement date. Do not assume that having spent money or obtained a licence preserves a permitted development right.

St Helens Article 4 compensation: what is the risk?

The short timetable is a significant part of this story. The council report acknowledges that proceeding without a 12-month lead-in carries a risk of claims by owners or developers who suffer qualifying loss. It states that “the level and nature of compensation is broadly unknown”. It says the potential financial impacts and claims were considered when members chose to proceed without a 12-month consultation period.

That does not mean everybody who intended to create an HMO is automatically entitled to compensation. The legal route generally depends on a subsequent qualifying planning application being refused, or permission being granted subject to relevant conditions, and on establishing qualifying abortive expenditure or other directly attributable loss. The statutory requirements and exceptions must be considered against the particular facts.

Class L is among the rights covered by the relevant compensation regulations. The prescribed timing for the planning application and the separate timing for making a compensation claim must not be confused. A short notice period can create potential exposure, but it does not establish that an individual claim succeeds or that the Direction is invalid.

Our guide to Article 4 compensation claims explains the distinction between the withdrawal of permitted development rights, a qualifying planning decision and the loss that may be recoverable. I would keep records of expenditure, decisions, professional advice and the project timetable if you think you may be affected.

What the consultation revealed

The council reports 33 written responses: 12 in support, 19 objections and two concerning a particular planning application. Objectors raised the start date, the consultation period, existing projects and transitional arrangements. Supporters raised residential amenity, community involvement and the effect of concentrations of HMOs.

According to the report, members weighed the possible compensation risk against the community impacts of delaying the St Helens Article 4 controls for 12 months. The report also discusses the possibility that restrictions targeted at particular neighbourhoods could displace HMO proposals into other areas.

The council’s own report recognises that some HMOs meet an accommodation need. Requiring an application gives the authority an opportunity to consider an individual proposal; it does not guarantee that any particular application will be refused or approved.

What should owners do next?

First, check the formal Direction and map when available, and confirm whether your property is covered and when the relevant right is withdrawn. Our HMO Article 4 index lists local authorities and their Directions where available.

Next, establish what use is taking place and retain evidence. If the St Helens Article 4 change affects a planned conversion, consider whether a planning application or a certificate of lawfulness is appropriate. Compensation requires a separate assessment; do not assume that submitting an application will secure payment.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news

Retrospective flats bid after appeal

Retrospective flats bid after appeal

A Forest Gate developer seeks permission for three flats after an enforcement appeal upheld, but varied, Newham’s earlier demolition notice.

Mayors offered transport order powers

Mayors offered transport order powers

A Department for Transport consultation proposes devolving local transport order decisions to England’s mayoral strategic authorities.