A Class MA appeal for 30 flats in Hammersmith has been dismissed because the applicant failed to show that larger delivery vehicles could safely serve a converted office building close to the A4. Inspector Lewis Condé issued the decision on 5 November 2026, upholding Hammersmith and Fulham Council’s refusal of prior approval.
The proposal concerned TWI House at 23 Eyot Gardens, an office building close to the street’s junction with the A4 Great West Road. Developer Honeycastle Sarl sought to convert parts of its basement, ground, first and second floors and roof space from Class E offices to 30 Class C3 homes under Part 3, Class MA of the General Permitted Development Order.
The result matters because the Inspector accepted the two other disputed technical matters: adequate natural light in all habitable rooms and a proportionate approach to contamination. Evidence about refuse collection and larger servicing vehicles, rather than a blanket objection to office conversions, defeated the scheme.
Why the Class MA appeal failed
The Class MA appeal involved prior approval application 2025/02818/PMA56. Under paragraph MA.2(2), the Inspector examined transport and safe access, contamination and adequate natural light. A prior approval appeal is assessed against the matters specified by the right, rather than the wider planning merits of a conventional application for permission.
TWI House occupies a corner close to Eyot Gardens and the A4, a 40mph dual carriageway. Parking along both sides of Eyot Gardens leaves limited available road width. The Inspector was concerned that a larger delivery vehicle stopping to service new flats might obstruct traffic entering from the A4, potentially causing traffic to queue back onto the main carriageway.
Vehicle tracking did not establish safe access
The applicant supplied tracking showing a 7.5-tonne box van manoeuvring into the site and a car passing a stationary van and an 8.15-metre refuse vehicle. The available clearance was extremely tight, particularly with cars parked along the street. Demonstrating a theoretical swept path was not enough to show that ordinary traffic could pass reliably in practice.
A servicing management plan forecast approximately 13 two-way delivery and servicing trips each weekday. The Inspector accepted that many would involve cars, motorcycles, bicycles and smaller couriers. But refuse collection and larger deliveries would remain reasonably foreseeable, even if they were relatively infrequent. Their consequences near a major road junction still mattered.
Other vehicles over 7.5 tonnes were anticipated but not adequately modelled. The evidence also lacked observed traffic-flow data for Eyot Gardens, leaving the number and timing of vehicles entering from the A4 uncertain. Without that baseline, the Inspector could not exclude the risk that a servicing vehicle would block approaching traffic.
In this Class MA appeal, a ring-ahead system, delivery scheduling and management measures could not ensure that every vehicle capable of entering the site would do so, or that larger or unanticipated vehicles would avoid stopping on Eyot Gardens. Even with a condition, unanticipated larger vehicles would remain possible. The Inspector found the scheme fails to satisfy paragraph MA.2(2)(a) of the GPDO
.
The applicant had also submitted an obligation designed to stop future occupiers getting local on-street parking permits, apart from Blue Badge holders. The Inspector did not need to decide whether it was effective because the servicing issue was already fatal. Long-stay cycle parking and two visitor spaces by the entrance were considered acceptable, but did not remove the access problem.
Contamination did not require intrusive investigation
The building had formerly been associated with a foundry and metal works, raising obvious questions about contamination for future residents. GeoCon Site Investigations prepared a revised Phase I Preliminary Risk Assessment, which concluded that risks were very low and considered possible ground gas, volatile contaminants and made ground.
Although the assessment did not include intrusive sampling, the Inspector accepted its methodology and supporting explanations. The existing building and substantial hardstanding would remain, reducing the opportunities for residents to contact the ground. No relevant nearby landfill or other sources had been identified to undermine the desk-based assessment.
Excavation was proposed mainly to extend a lift into the basement. A condition requiring a watching brief, with investigation and remediation should unexpected material be encountered, would be proportionate. The Class MA appeal therefore succeeded on its contamination argument. The Inspector considered that further Phase II intrusive investigation was not required on this evidence.
Why inadequate sunshine did not mean inadequate natural light
The applicant’s daylight and sunlight report used recognised guidance to test the proposed flats. Every habitable room would meet the recommended level of daylight illuminance, often comfortably. Direct sunlight results were worse: six units had no habitable room achieving the 1.5 hours of sunshine recommended by BS EN 17037.
The Inspector regarded that sunlight shortfall as notable but distinguished direct sunshine from the legal requirement for adequate natural light. Class MA does not prescribe a minimum number of hours of direct sunlight, and flats with north-facing rooms can struggle against that part of industry guidance even when their daylight is satisfactory.
As the decision puts it, the direct sunlight results are therefore relevant to that assessment but are not determinative
. In this Class MA appeal, the daylight illuminance evidence was sufficient. That is not a general exemption from assessing sunlight, but it is a useful reminder that the statutory test and the technical guidance are not identical.
An older permission for 27 flats was not enough
Prior approval had been granted in 2016 under the former Class O for 27 dwellings at the same building, but it had never been implemented. The Inspector treated that as a different proposal determined under the provisions and evidence applicable at the time. It could not authorise the later 30-flat conversion.
An earlier Class MA decision at Griffin House in Hammersmith had considered servicing and a car-free agreement, but it did not establish a universal approach. The Inspector distinguished its site context from Eyot Gardens, with its restricted passing width and close relationship to the A4 junction.
Although 30 homes from office accommodation would be a positive outcome in housing terms, the benefit could not displace a mandatory prior approval requirement. The Class MA appeal was dismissed on transport grounds despite the successful arguments on contamination and natural light.
Practical lessons for office conversion proposals
The decision shows why applicants should test realistic refuse and servicing activity, survey existing road movements where necessary and measure clearance against parked vehicles. A swept-path diagram showing that a vehicle can technically manoeuvre does not necessarily prove that the surrounding road network will operate safely.
Our Class MA permitted development guide sets out the eligibility requirements and the precise matters that can be examined at prior approval. The wider General Permitted Development Order guide explains how the national permission interacts with detailed conditions.
The decision is available from the Planning Inspectorate appeal record, reference 6008157, decided by Lewis Condé on 5 November 2026. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase.

0 Comments