Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Class Q appeal fails because approved future access was not ‘existing’

A Staffordshire Class Q appeal fails because an approved future highway access had not actually been built when the Inspector visited.

The Class Q existing access requirement has defeated an appeal at Hollywood Farm in Staffordshire because the agricultural building lacked suitable access to a public highway. A separately approved entrance was still unbuilt when the Inspector visited.

Harrowby Estates wanted to convert a redundant pole barn into one dwelling beside Uttoxeter Road, near Stone. Inspector Alison Fish dismissed appeal 6011939 on 2nd October 2026, backing Stafford Borough Council’s refusal of application 25/41644/PAR.

The Inspector accepted that the new access would probably be completed before anyone moved in. But the Class Q existing access requirement asks whether suitable access is already there. Permission to create it in the future did not meet that test.

The approved access had not been built

Hollywood Farm comprises a farmhouse and a group of former agricultural buildings on the southern side of Uttoxeter Road. The pole barn sits beside the farmhouse, towards the southern edge of that complex.

The proposal included land immediately north of the barn for parking and a garden. The submitted plans showed the proposed dwelling being served by a new access from the classified B5027.

That entrance already benefited from a separate grant of planning permission. The issue was therefore not simply whether an access could obtain permission. It was whether the building actually had the suitable access required to use Class Q.

At her site visit on 22nd September 2026, Alison Fish saw construction activity across the wider site, including work to convert other buildings. The frontage hedge had been removed, but the approved access connecting the site to the road had not been provided.

An access further east was being used for construction deliveries. However, there appeared to be no dispute that this did not provide a suitably located, safe access for residential use of the Hollywood Farm buildings.

The plans showed that eastern access being reinstated as verge. On the evidence before the Inspector, the works for the separately approved entrance were needed to provide suitable access for the site.

What the Class Q existing access requirement says

The decisive provision was paragraph Q.1(p) of Schedule 2, Part 3 of the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) (England) Order 2015, as amended. This is an England permitted development route.

Under the Class Q legislation, development is not permitted where the building lacks suitable existing access to a public highway.

There are two connected questions here: is the access suitable, and does it already exist? At Hollywood Farm, the existing eastern access did not satisfy the residential suitability requirement, while the approved suitable access had yet to be constructed.

Explaining the wording in paragraph 10 of her decision, Inspector Fish said: “The word ‘existing’ means something that is already present”.

Her finding was that the suitable access shown on the drawing was not already present. The building therefore failed Q.1(p), and the proposed development did not constitute permitted development under Class Q.

Our main Class Q guide explains the wider agricultural building conversion route. This decision concerns one specific limitation within it, rather than a finding that the barn failed every Class Q requirement.

Why likely future construction was not enough

The Inspector did not dismiss the practical explanation for the construction sequence. She accepted that there were reasons for completing access works towards the end of construction.

She also accepted that, in all likelihood, the entrance shown on the plans would be in place before the proposed dwelling was occupied. That is an important part of the story: the appeal failed despite that expectation.

It would be easy to read an approved access drawing and assume the highway issue had been resolved. Here, however, the permission and drawing described something that could be delivered. They did not establish that the building already had suitable access.

The difference matters when assembling a prior approval application. Evidence of a separate planning permission answers a different question from evidence of an access physically connecting the building to the highway.

The decision should not be stretched into a rule that every existing Class Q access must remain physically unchanged forever. It does not decide the acceptability of every widening, resurfacing or other improvement to an entrance that already exists and is suitable.

Nor does it establish that an access used by construction vehicles must automatically be suitable for a home. The eastern entrance was being used, but its suitability for the proposed residential use was not accepted.

Class Q gateway tests come before planning benefits

Alison Fish acknowledged that an additional dwelling would bring benefits. Those benefits could not overcome the failure to meet the GPDO requirement.

This was an appeal against refusal of the approval required under Class Q. The Inspector’s task was to determine whether the proposal complied with that permitted development route, rather than to undertake an unrestricted planning balance for a full application.

Once the building failed Q.1(p), arguments favouring the additional home did not supply the missing entitlement. The Inspector expressly treated the appellant’s other considerations as irrelevant to the issue she had to decide.

For owners and advisers, that is the costly trap. A scheme may have a convincing construction programme and offer an additional home, yet still fall outside Class Q because a threshold requirement has not been met.

We have also covered a recent Class Q prior approval appeal. Each decision needs to be read against its own facts and the particular requirement being considered.

Planning Geek analysis

For me, the useful lesson is to check the site as it actually stands, alongside the approved drawings. A permission in the file and an entrance on the ground are different pieces of evidence.

Before committing to a Class Q submission where access is an issue, we would want to establish the existing route to the public highway, its suitability for the proposed residential use and whether the proposal depends on an entrance that has yet to be built.

If separate access works are needed, their planning permission, conditions and any highway authority requirements also need checking. Obtaining permission alone should not be treated as proof that Q.1(p) has been satisfied.

Completing an access would not, by itself, guarantee that a later Class Q application would succeed. Every other relevant limitation and prior approval requirement would still need to be assessed. This appeal did not grant an alternative scheme or pre-approve a resubmission.

Planning Geek can advise on the planning route and coordinate with appropriate highways specialists where technical access evidence is needed. The practical value is identifying this issue early, before a promising barn conversion reaches refusal or appeal.

Read the decision

You can read the Hollywood Farm appeal decision here. Appeal 6011939 was dismissed on 2nd October 2026 by Alison Fish BA (Hons) DipTP MRTPI.

The short decision is particularly useful because it separates permission for future access from the suitable existing access required by paragraph Q.1(p).

0 Comments

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news