A commercial building appeal has been dismissed at Church Farm, Marton, after an Inspector found that a commercial building proposed to replace an agricultural building would be disproportionately larger and harmful to important heritage assets.
Inspector Andrew McGlone dismissed appeal 6013070 on 18 November 2026. Cheshire East Council had refused an application to demolish a farm building and construct a replacement for flexible commercial use beside the Grade I listed Church of St James and St Paul.
The commercial building appeal is notable because an existing Class R prior approval provided a credible fallback for commercial use, but did not overcome the size of the proposed replacement or its effect on a listed church and scheduled monument.
Why the commercial building appeal failed
The proposal concerned a two-storey agricultural building behind commercial premises at Church Farm on Congleton Road in Marton. The building had blockwork at low level and timber boarding above. Its setting included established trees, the Grade I listed parish church, and a Grade II listed cross in the churchyard that is also a scheduled monument.
The application sought a new replacement building for flexible commercial purposes. The Inspector assessed its scale and relationship to the countryside as well as the effect on the significance of the nearby designated heritage assets. Those were separate tests, and the proposal failed both.
The commercial building appeal was not simply a dispute about whether a building could be used by a rural business. The existing Class R change-of-use approval was a real fallback, but the appeal scheme involved demolishing and reconstructing a larger building, with its own visual and heritage effects.
The difference between materially and disproportionately larger
Cheshire East’s policy PG6 allows exceptions for certain replacement buildings but assesses whether the new development is materially larger than what it replaces. Policy RUR 13 requires consideration of height, footprint, floor space, form and other dimensions. It defines the existing building by reference to the structure at the time of the application.
The Inspector accepted that the proposed ridge and eaves heights alone would not make the replacement materially larger. However, its increased footprint, width, length, floor area and volume taken together would. A staggered building line and revised materials were not enough to change that conclusion.
National policy in the August 2026 National Planning Policy Framework required a separate assessment. Policy S5(1)(c) referred to buildings outside settlements being replaced by structures that were not disproportionately larger, a broader test that also allowed consideration of their visual and spatial effects.
In this commercial building appeal, the Inspector found the proposed two-pitched-roof form and greater eastern extent would change how the building was experienced from approaches to Marton. Screening from some viewpoints did not eliminate its impact where it remained visible. The replacement was disproportionately larger under national policy.
This is a useful reminder that a proposal can have comparable height to an existing building yet still fail a scale test. Its footprint, bulk, overall volume and wider setting matter. A local policy’s materially-larger threshold and the Framework’s disproportionately-larger test also need to be read on their own terms.
Class R fallback did not rescue the scheme
The appellant had an extant prior approval for a Class R change of use of the agricultural building to flexible commercial use. That right had not been implemented at the time of the appeal. Inspector McGlone nevertheless accepted that there was a real prospect of the fallback being carried out.
This distinction was important because Policy S5(1)(c) generally expects the replacement building to be in the same use as the existing structure. The Inspector emphasised the policy’s wording, ‘should be’, rather than ‘must be’. With a realistic Class R fallback, the intended commercial use could be treated as consistent with that aspect of the policy.
But the fallback could not justify the replacement’s additional harm. The permitted change of use would affect the existing building; it did not create a right to build a larger successor. The Inspector considered the appeal scheme to be more harmful than the available fallback.
Our Class R guide to agricultural buildings explains what the change-of-use right can authorise and why physical building works may need separate permission. The commercial building appeal demonstrates the practical importance of keeping the two routes distinct.
A Grade I church and scheduled cross carried particular weight
The nearby Church of St James and St Paul is Grade I listed, while its churchyard cross is both Grade II listed and scheduled. The historic relationship between Church Farm, the church and associated buildings formed part of the context in which the proposal was assessed.
The Inspector found that the proposed building’s scale and mass, and the five large shuttered openings on each flank, meant it would be read and understood as a large industrial building
, harming the rural setting of both assets and so their significance. Noise and activity were not a separate source of harm, because the Class R fallback would bring the same flexible commercial uses to broadly the same location.
The commercial building appeal therefore required attention not just to the new structure’s own design, but to what its setting contributes to the significance of those historic assets. A change outside a listed building’s boundary can still be harmful if it alters that relationship.
The planning balance was conducted under both the relevant local heritage policies and the current national Framework. Although a commercial use could deliver an economic benefit and make productive use of the land, the Inspector found that those considerations did not outweigh the identified heritage harm.
Planning Geek’s guide to heritage significance and harm explains how the August 2026 Framework approaches the setting of designated assets, the weight attached to their conservation, and public benefits.
What rural applicants should take from the decision
The commercial building appeal shows why applicants need to measure and explain the difference between an existing agricultural structure and its proposed replacement. Drawing comparisons only between ridge heights, or relying heavily on screening, can overlook the wider scale of development that policy requires to be examined.
A lawful or realistically implementable fallback can be valuable evidence, particularly where it establishes that commercial use could take place without the disputed proposal. But it should be demonstrated clearly, including the extent of the works and use actually available. A fallback is not a blanket permission for a more intensive redevelopment.
Heritage assessment also needs to begin before the proposal is fixed. Where a Grade I listed building or scheduled monument is close by, the applicant should identify which elements of its significance depend on setting, test the effect from relevant approaches and explain any design alternatives.
The commercial building appeal was dismissed because the proposal failed the countryside scale and heritage tests, notwithstanding the accepted Class R fallback. The Planning Inspectorate appeal record gives the official reference. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase.

0 Comments