Mast prior approval has been granted for a 20-metre telecommunications pole on Kingsway in Stretford, Greater Manchester, after an Inspector accepted that the need for improved coverage outweighed limited harm to the streetscape.
Inspector K Mee allowed appeal 6015717 on 18 November 2026, overturning Trafford Council’s refusal under Part 16, Class A of the General Permitted Development Order. The proposal includes six antennas, two dishes and three equipment cabinets on the footway.
The mast prior approval decision is useful because it draws a firm boundary around what councils can examine under this permitted development route. The installation’s siting and appearance mattered, while the need for network improvements and realistic alternative locations shaped the planning balance.
What the mast prior approval covers
JET Infrastructure proposed a 20-metre Orion monopole with associated telecommunications equipment on a wide stretch of pavement near Stretford’s shopping centre. The area has recently been improved with cycling infrastructure and landscaping. A multi-storey car park, supermarket service area, commercial frontages and existing street equipment are nearby.
The appeal concerned the siting and appearance of infrastructure under Schedule 2, Part 16, Class A of the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) (England) Order 2015. The applicant was seeking the approval required by that regime, not a fresh determination of whether the principle of telecommunications development was acceptable.
That distinction shapes a mast prior approval case. As the Inspector explained, the assessment must be made ‘solely on the basis of its siting and appearance’, taking representations into account. Policy concerns can inform those matters, but cannot turn the prior approval process into a conventional planning application covering every issue.
Planning Geek’s Part 16 Class A guidance explains permitted development rights for electronic communications code operators, while our prior approval guide deals with the wider procedure and its limits.
A prominent mast but limited visual harm
The Inspector accepted that a 20-metre pole would be prominent along Kingsway and visible from several public viewpoints. The mast would rise above nearby lighting columns, which were described as being around 12 metres tall. A light-grey finish and linked green cabinets would give it the practical appearance typical of this equipment.
However, the site was not an isolated residential street. The shopping centre car park, commercial development, large trees, signs and existing telecommunications infrastructure already contribute to its visual context. The cabinets would be placed near the rear edge of the pavement, leaving generous space for pedestrians and the separate cycle route.
The mast prior approval was therefore not allowed on the basis that no harm would occur. Inspector Mee expressly recognised some harm to character and appearance. The finding was that the harm was moderated by the surroundings and was not so dominant as to prevent approval when other relevant considerations were weighed.
This matters where councils refuse telecommunications proposals by referring to design policies alone. A policy conflict can be relevant, but its weight depends on the specific prior approval issues and the evidence about why the installation must occupy that location.
Seventeen alternative sites were considered
The central counterweight to visual harm was the technical evidence. The appellant wanted to maintain and improve network coverage, including introducing 5G services. The existing rooftop installation about 350 metres south supported only 4G and faced constraints on upgrading.
The appellant explained that upgrading the rooftop site would need separate approval from the Building Safety Regulator, with unacceptably prolonged timescales, alongside the safety and operational constraints of working at height on a residential building. The Inspector found no substantive evidence that this was incorrect. The appellant also confirmed that the existing nearby mast lacked the structural capacity for the equipment needed for both operators’ 5G networks, and the Inspector was satisfied that the sequential approach had been applied appropriately.
The appellant’s supplementary site assessment examined 17 alternatives. The reasons for discounting them included inadequate roof heights, the need for more visually intrusive lattice masts, competing redevelopment proposals, signal interference from trees, proximity to homes and underground services.
In the mast prior approval decision, Inspector Mee considered that analysis persuasive. No alternative site had been advanced by the council, and the evidence indicated that the chosen location and minimum practicable equipment would achieve the network improvement with less harm than the realistic options.
Health concerns and highway safety
Representations had also raised health and wellbeing concerns. The appellant supplied a certificate demonstrating design compliance with guidelines from the International Commission on Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection. The Inspector found no sufficiently authoritative evidence to justify applying a different standard in these circumstances.
The Inspector also considered references to other planning decisions and legal proceedings, but was not persuaded that they altered the assessment of this particular site. The balancing exercise remained focused on the mast’s siting, appearance and substantiated network requirements.
The highway issues were less contentious. Although the cabinets and pole would be on the footway, its width was sufficient for pedestrians. Visibility for drivers would not be impaired and the separate cycle route would remain unaffected, in line with the local highway authority’s position.
There was no free-standing highway safety objection capable of changing the mast prior approval balance on the evidence before the Inspector. This was an important factual distinction, given the proposal’s position beside recently improved public space.
Conditions and the wider planning lesson
The decision also addressed controls. The Inspector found that the permitted development regime did not provide a general power to add bespoke conditions beyond the deemed conditions already applying to electronic communications operators. Those include compliance with the approved details, a five-year commencement period and removal when equipment is no longer required.
For applicants, a mast prior approval appeal can be won by presenting credible technical coverage needs, a proportionate design and a properly evidenced alternatives exercise. Generic assertions that a mast is essential will be less persuasive than an explanation of why particular rooftops, existing structures and other plots cannot work.
For local authorities, the lesson is to identify the precise visual or siting harm and then test the operator’s evidence in that context. The Inspector did not say that a 20-metre pole would always be acceptable in a town centre. A narrower pavement, different nearby buildings or realistic less harmful alternative might produce a different decision.
The mast prior approval illustrates how the benefits of digital infrastructure can outweigh a recognised localised visual impact under the established statutory procedure. The Planning Inspectorate record carries appeal reference 6015717. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase.

0 Comments