Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Croydon validation appeal allows nine HMO units

An Inspector allows nine HMO units after a Croydon validation dispute over bat surveys, while rejecting both sides' costs claims.

A Croydon validation appeal has succeeded after an Inspector rejected the council’s decision to withhold validation of a residential proposal pending updated ecology surveys. The 20 November 2026 decision also grants outline planning permission for nine HMO rental units at 275 Addiscombe Road. Neither side received the costs award it sought.

Inspector L Francis examined a dispute over whether fresh bat surveys and a preliminary ecological appraisal had to accompany the April 2026 application before Croydon Council would accept it as valid. The applicant used the statutory Article 12 process and appealed when the authority did not determine the application.

The Croydon validation appeal is significant beyond this particular site because a council’s information requirements must be proportionate, consistent with the legislation and assessed against the evidence available when the application was lodged. However, the outcome is not a general right to avoid surveys for protected species.

How the Croydon validation appeal reached an Inspector

The application, reference 26/01173/OUT, sought outline consent for a four-storey building with roof accommodation and nine residential units. Layout and scale were the matters for approval. The decision describes the units as self-contained flats under Use Class C4, while its reasoning identifies nine HMO rental units with communal kitchens and recreation space. That distinction matters: the Inspector’s reasoning proceeds on the proposed HMO use rather than nine ordinary family flats.

Croydon did not validate the April application because it wanted updated bat survey evidence and a preliminary ecological appraisal. The applicant served a notice under Article 12 of the Town and Country Planning (Development Management Procedure) (England) Order 2015. Following the council’s maintained objection, the non-validation notice was confirmed on 13 May 2026 and the statutory non-determination route became available.

A non-validation dispute does not dispense with public consultation or allow the Inspector to ignore material planning issues. The decision records that the council carried out the statutory publicity during the appeal. Inspector Francis then considered both whether the application contained enough information to be determined and whether the development should receive permission.

What the Inspector said about ecology surveys

The council relied on a local validation list adopted in May 2026 and its concern about bats. The application had been submitted in April, and the council did not produce a copy of a list applicable at that earlier date. Its reliance on the May list was therefore uncertain. The Inspector nevertheless accepted that protected species were a genuine material planning consideration, not something an applicant could simply ignore.

Planning history made the Croydon validation appeal unusual. Several live permissions for redevelopment had already been granted, including permissions in April 2026, and a separate appeal relating to 19 flats was allowed on 21 September. Those permissions had used pre-commencement conditions to secure updated ecological and bat evidence. Inspector Francis found no convincing reason that the now-expired demolition consent changed the validation requirements for this application.

The earlier ecological survey dated from 2021, so it could not be assumed to describe the position indefinitely. The Inspector nonetheless considered that the available evidence, the previous decisions and the approach to further surveys in Circular 06/2005 supported an assessment of the present application. The decision found it had been submitted with “sufficient information to enable it to be determined and was valid”.

That is a case-specific conclusion. Where there is a reasonable likelihood of protected species being present and affected, further ecological evidence may be required before a decision. Our guide to preliminary ecological appraisals explains the distinction between identifying a risk and deciding what further assessment is needed.

Nine HMO units receive outline permission

Having resolved validation, the Inspector addressed the planning merits. The scheme would replace an existing building on a substantial plot on busy Addiscombe Road. The proposed accommodation was described in the reasoning as nine Class C4 HMO rental units sharing amenities, rather than conventional separate family homes. The precise authorised layout and use must therefore be read with the decision and approved details.

The council had questioned the effect of activity around the basement parking ramp on neighbouring residents, but the Inspector considered that noise mitigation could be secured through planning conditions. The decision also considered housing policy, transport accessibility, living space, trees, drainage and ecology. Updated bat surveys undertaken during 2026 recorded foraging activity, with mitigation addressed in the planning assessment.

A signed unilateral undertaking was supplied during the appeal, which the council accepted. The Inspector concluded that the proposals accorded with the relevant policy framework and granted outline permission subject to conditions. This was a grant of planning permission following appeal, not merely an instruction for the council to reconsider validation.

Both applications for appeal costs were refused

The Croydon validation appeal also produced two separate costs decisions. Developer Abbas Datoo sought a full award against the council, arguing that its conduct had been unreasonable. Croydon sought a full award against the developer, maintaining that providing the ecology material at validation stage would have avoided an appeal. Inspector Francis refused both requests.

Although the council had treated the applicant inconsistently with the approach to other extant permissions, the Inspector considered that deciding when surveys were required involved planning judgement. The council had explained its position, and the developer would still have had to address the substantive planning issues. The costs of the whole appeal could not simply be attributed to the disputed validation decision.

The council’s costs application also failed because the applicant was entitled to contest its approach and pursue a statutory appeal. The council’s objections on planning merits would have required consideration regardless. Readers can compare the separate legal tests for an appeal outcome and a costs award in our appeal costs guidance.

What applicants and councils should take from the decision

A practical lesson of the Croydon validation appeal is that a local list cannot be assumed to apply retrospectively. Applicants should examine the requirements in force when their application was submitted and ask whether the requested information is reasonable, proportionate and relevant to a material planning consideration. Where a disagreement persists, Article 12 provides a formal route to challenge non-validation.

Equally, the applicant cannot treat a successful validation challenge as a substitute for meeting planning policy or demonstrating acceptable environmental effects. The Inspector could grant permission here because those matters were assessed separately, including conditions and an undertaking. The result depends on the unusually extensive planning history and should not be read as a blanket exemption from ecological work.

Planning Geek’s Article 12 validation dispute guide explains the process, while our validation requirements guide covers the information councils can legitimately request. The Croydon validation appeal shows why the stage at which information is required can be just as important as the information itself.

The appeal (reference 6011675) and both costs decisions were issued on 20 November 2026. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news

Grey belt appeal allows 49 homes

Grey belt appeal allows 49 homes

An Inspector allows up to 49 homes at Wimborne after finding grey belt policy tests met and 50% affordable housing secured.