Two flat amalgamation appeals in London have been dismissed after Planning Inspectors concluded that turning two existing homes into one would cause an unjustified loss of housing. Decisions issued on 12 November 2026 concerned The Little Boltons in Kensington and Chelsea and Braeside Avenue in Merton.
At The Little Boltons, the proposal would have absorbed a one-bedroom basement flat into an existing four-bedroom upper flat. In Merton, two purpose-built maisonettes containing two and three bedrooms would have become a single five-bedroom house. Both Inspectors found that the proposed larger home did not justify losing a separate dwelling.
The flat amalgamation appeals illustrate that retaining the same residential floorspace is not necessarily enough to protect a scheme from refusal. Demand for smaller properties, housing mix policies and the quality of the existing flats were more important than the owner’s preference for a single house.
Why the flat amalgamation appeals mattered
Combining two flats into one house does not always need planning permission, but neither is every amalgamation automatically outside planning control because the alterations are internal. The issue is whether the change of use is material in its planning context. Once permission is required, the planning merits of losing an existing dwelling must be assessed against the relevant development plan.
Planning Geek’s guide to combining two houses or flats explains why the question of whether an amalgamation constitutes development is different from whether permission should be granted. These two November decisions concerned refusals of planning permission, not determinations that every flat merger requires consent.
Both boroughs have adopted policies intended to maintain the supply and appropriate mix of homes. Neither Inspector suggested that merging flats was always unacceptable. Each instead asked whether the particular loss of a separate home could be justified under the borough’s policies and housing evidence.
The Little Boltons: why the basement flat mattered
Inspector M Cryan dismissed appeal 6010162 against Kensington and Chelsea’s refusal of application PP/26/00900. The property is a substantial semi-detached house containing a one-bedroom flat at the front of the lower-ground floor and a four-bedroom flat occupying the rest of the building.
The appellant argued that the basement accommodation was poor because of restricted outlook and access by external stairs. Policy HO1 of the borough’s 2024 New Local Plan Review resists losing residential units by amalgamation, although its supporting text recognises a narrow exception where the existing homes are substandard, meaning that both are significantly below the minimum size standards for even a studio and lack adequate natural daylight and ventilation.
The Inspector accepted that the basement flat had some limitations, but found that it was around 53 square metres, exceeding the development plan minimum for a one-bedroom two-person flat. A large bay window served the living space and two windows served the bedroom. There was no substantive evidence that the flat suffered inadequate natural daylight.
The Inspector therefore found insufficient grounds to describe the basement flat as “substandard” within Policy HO1. Its shortcomings were moderate rather than exceptional. The flat amalgamation appeals show why simply describing a basement unit as awkward or less attractive than a larger home is unlikely to establish a policy exception.
A lawful development certificate granted in May 2022 confirmed that an internal reconfiguration reducing the basement flat’s size, with the residual floor area incorporated into the upper flat, did not require planning permission. The Inspector found that, whatever the timing of the original subdivision, recombining the two flats would still mean the loss of one self-contained dwelling.
The existing upper flat was already a family dwelling
The Kensington proposal was promoted as creating a family-sized house, but the four-bedroom upper flat already had a garden and enough accommodation to serve a family. Inspector Cryan explicitly noted that it was “already a family-sized dwelling”. Combining the units would enlarge that home rather than add another family-sized dwelling to the borough’s stock.
The development plan indicates a requirement for seven times more one-bedroom properties than homes with four or more bedrooms. The Inspector considered the loss of this smaller unit harmful to the supply of housing needed locally, even though no residential floorspace would disappear.
The property was within The Boltons Conservation Area, but the Inspector accepted that the proposal would have little external effect and would preserve its character. The dismissal therefore resulted from housing loss, not a conservation-area objection.
Braeside Avenue: two maisonettes into one house
The second flat amalgamation appeal involved two purpose-built maisonettes on Braeside Avenue, Wimbledon. Under application 25/P3382, the owner sought to combine two-bedroom and three-bedroom homes into one five-bedroom house, with alterations to the porch and rear gardens.
Inspector B Plenty dismissed appeal 6010574 on 12 November. The site visit was undertaken by representative J Reed, whose recommendation the Inspector considered before reaching the final decision. The existing building would remain residential, but the number of separate homes would fall from two to one.
Merton Policy H11.2 supports improvement of the housing stock without a net loss of dwellings. The Inspector concluded that the loss of one unit conflicted with that objective, despite the owner’s argument that housing supply targets could be met and that no floor area would be lost to another use.
Policy H11.3 seeks a borough-wide mix of approximately 33% one-bedroom, 33% two-bedroom and 34% three-bedroom or larger properties. The proposed merger would eliminate the existing two-bedroom unit and replace a three-bedroom family home with a five-bedroom property. The Inspector found that this would modestly worsen the mix of available homes.
Why earlier approved mergers were not comparable
The Merton appellant referred to previous flat-merger permissions across the borough. Some involved replacing two small flats with a family dwelling, while others addressed substandard accommodation or restored a building’s historic character. Inspector Plenty concluded that those benefits did not arise at Braeside Avenue.
Both existing maisonettes complied with relevant space standards and offered good accommodation. The site already contained a three-bedroom family home. The owner’s wish to live in a larger house long term and receive older family members was a personal benefit, but did not outweigh the housing loss.
The Inspector also considered that approving a similar merger without sufficient justification could make it harder to resist cumulative housing losses elsewhere. That was a concern about the realistic consequences of comparable proposals, rather than an assumption that precedent alone decided the appeal.
In the flat amalgamation appeals, the fact that a proposed five-bedroom dwelling would be attractive or useful to the owner did not mean it provided a net new family home. The loss of a two-bedroom dwelling was still counted as an adverse effect on supply and mix.
National planning policy did not outweigh the housing losses
Both Inspectors considered the revised National Planning Policy Framework published in August 2026, including Policy S4 on proposals in settlements. At The Little Boltons, Inspector Cryan also considered the Framework’s Policy HO7, which gives substantial weight to homes meeting evidenced accommodation needs. The Inspector found that enlarging an existing family flat while losing a needed one-bedroom unit did not meet those needs.
In Merton, Inspector Plenty considered the private benefits of a larger home but gave them limited weight against the loss of a separate dwelling and the adverse effect on housing mix. The flat amalgamation appeals therefore turned on local housing evidence and the development plan, notwithstanding the national presumption in favour of sustainable development.
What owners should learn from the decisions
The principal lesson is that housing supply is measured partly by the number and types of separate dwellings, not just the amount of residential floorspace. A proposal may keep every room in residential use and still reduce the number of homes available to different households.
Owners considering an amalgamation should first establish whether the change is material development requiring permission. Where a planning application is necessary, evidence about the condition, daylight, accessibility and size of the existing flats may be crucial if an exception for substandard accommodation is relied upon. Borough-level demand for different property sizes must also be considered.
The flat amalgamation appeals do not impose a universal ban on creating one larger dwelling from two flats. They show that the benefits need to be sufficiently strong, and particular to the site, to justify losing a smaller home. The Planning Geek London Plan guide explains how strategic policy interacts with the borough Local Plans that influenced these decisions.
The flat amalgamation appeals were decided on 12 November 2026. The Little Boltons decision, appeal 6010162, and Braeside Avenue decision, appeal 6010574, are available on AppealBase for Kensington and Chelsea and AppealBase for Merton. Both decisions are also on the Planning Inspectorate’s appeal pages for appeal 6010162 and appeal 6010574.


0 Comments