Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Hackney pergola appeals fail over corrugated roof

Two Hackney pergola appeals failed over a corrugated roof that harmed a listed Georgian terrace despite preserving the conservation area.

by | 16th November 2026 16:47 | AppealsHouseholder

The Hackney pergola appeals have both been dismissed after an Inspector found that a corrugated metal roof on a garden structure harmed a Grade II listed Georgian townhouse. The decisions concern planning permission and listed building consent for a pergola already erected in the rear garden of a home in Sutton Place, east London.

Inspector Ann Veevers issued the linked decisions on 16 November 2026 following a September site visit. Although she found that the works preserved the character and appearance of the Clapton Square Conservation Area, she reached a different conclusion about the special architectural and historic interest of the listed building itself.

The Hackney pergola appeals underline an important distinction for owners of historic buildings: a structure may have little impact on a wider conservation area yet still be unacceptable because of its effect on a listed building and its setting. The simple timber framework was not the main problem. It was the reflective corrugated roof covering.

What was built at Sutton Place?

The appeals concern a property forming part of the Grade II listed terrace at 1 to 4 Sutton Place, which dates from the late eighteenth or early nineteenth century. The terrace is characterised by London stock brick, sash windows, historic architectural details and long, relatively narrow rear gardens bounded by brick walls.

A timber pergola had been erected in the rear garden. It consisted of four corner posts and timber roof battens covered with corrugated sheeting, positioned to one side of the garden. The adjoining property and the remainder of the terrace formed part of the setting the Inspector was required to consider.

The owner, Sophie Leonard, appealed Hackney Council’s refusal of planning permission, application 2025/1832, and its separate refusal of listed building consent, application 2025/2000. Inspector Veevers considered the two matters together in one decision letter, although each was a distinct statutory appeal.

The Planning Geek guide to pergolas and planning permission explains why the status of a garden structure depends on its physical form, location and the planning constraints affecting the property. The Hackney pergola appeals involved the additional controls applicable to a Grade II listed building.

Why the corrugated metal roof mattered

The Inspector accepted that the timber structure was modest. Its position left much of the garden open, and the longer views from the house towards the rear remained largely intact. Nevertheless, the roof projected above a relatively low boundary wall and could be seen from parts of the neighbouring garden and upper windows.

The corrugated sheeting reflected daylight and appeared visually at odds with the traditional brickwork and planted garden. The Inspector contrasted this roof with other modest garden structures nearby, which tended to use materials more sympathetic to the historic setting.

In the decision, Inspector Veevers described the corrugated sheeting as “visually harmful”. She considered that the material weakened the historic building’s architectural interest and its relationship with the garden. That assessment did not depend upon the pergola being especially large or permanently altering the fabric of the house.

The appellant argued that the pergola replaced an earlier structure and offered a more durable, weatherproof covering. However, the previous structure apparently did not have a covered roof, and the Inspector considered that other, more sympathetic materials could provide the same practical shelter without the identified heritage harm.

The Hackney pergola appeals also addressed a suggestion that the structure did not touch the listed building. The Inspector noted that the pergola was at least secured by screws to a boundary wall, but went further: even if there had been no physical attachment to the listed structure, harm to its setting could still justify refusal.

Conservation area preserved, but listed building harmed

One of the most useful aspects of the decisions is the distinction between the two heritage findings. Clapton Square Conservation Area was designated in 1969 and includes Georgian buildings, historic street patterns, mature trees and garden spaces. The Inspector considered the significance of the conservation area as a whole, not just the appearance of one private garden.

She found that the pergola did not remove meaningful amounts of planting or undermine the spacious, verdant character visible from Walled Garden Walk. On that basis, its presence did not harm the conservation area’s overall character or appearance. The relevant statutory duty under section 72 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 was therefore satisfied.

However, the Inspector identified a separate, low level of harm to the special interest and setting of the Grade II listed terrace. The listed building duties under sections 16 and 66 required significant weight to be given to preserving that special interest. The fact that the broader conservation area was unharmed did not cancel the harm to the listed building.

Readers assessing historic properties should distinguish the two controls rather than treating a conservation area designation and listed status as interchangeable. Our guide to permitted development rights for listed buildings explains why ordinary assumptions about changes to homes and gardens cannot simply be transferred to listed properties.

Why the benefits did not outweigh the harm

The owner said the previous pergola had become unsafe and unattractive, and that its replacement offered weather protection, shade and privacy for people using the garden. The Inspector accepted that such benefits could make the garden more comfortable, particularly in poor weather.

But those benefits were largely private rather than public. The property and its garden already had a viable residential use without the pergola, and there was no convincing evidence that the corrugated covering was the only practical way to achieve the stated objectives. The absence of significant overlooking or daylight harm to neighbours was neutral rather than a reason to grant permission.

The Inspector considered the listed building harm to be low in degree, but nevertheless deserving of considerable weight under heritage policy. The private benefits, together with the limited wider economic and social benefits of investment in the property, did not outweigh that harm. She also found no clear and convincing justification for the metal roof’s effect on the listed building.

The Hackney pergola appeals therefore failed on their particular heritage consequences, not on a general rule banning pergolas or all corrugated roofing. Materials and their relationship to historic architecture can be decisive, even where a garden addition is small, reversible and screened from public view.

Planning and listed building appeals both dismissed

The Inspector dismissed planning appeal 6006567 under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 and listed building consent appeal 6006562 under section 20 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990. She concluded that the pergola failed to preserve the listed terrace’s special interest and that the limited benefits did not outweigh the harm.

For a homeowner planning a similar structure, early consideration of roof materials, proximity to historic walls, visibility from neighbouring listed properties and the character of the building’s setting may avoid a difficult retrospective application. A pergola that looks relatively unobtrusive in an ordinary modern garden may be assessed differently beside an important historic terrace.

The Hackney pergola appeals are also a reminder that the outcome of one heritage test does not determine another. The Inspector found no conservation area harm, yet the distinct statutory protection of the listed building was enough for both appeals to be dismissed.

The Inspector’s decision for both appeals is also available on AppealBase, with references 6006562 and 6006567.

0 Comments

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news