The farm access appeal at Thurston in Suffolk has succeeded after a Planning Inspector granted permission for a field gate and highway entrance that did not qualify for permitted development rights. Inspector Chris Preston allowed enforcement appeal APP/W3520/C/25/3368355 on 16 November 2026 and quashed the notice issued by Mid Suffolk District Council.
The Council’s notice, issued on 25 April 2025, alleged that the new access onto an unclassified road had been created without planning permission. It required the landowner to stop using the entrance, remove the gates and permanently close the access within three months. The appeal was brought under ground (a), asking the Inspector to grant planning permission for the development as carried out.
The farm access appeal is particularly useful because the Inspector separated two questions that are often confused: whether the works benefit from the General Permitted Development Order, and whether they are acceptable if planning permission is required. The first question was answered no, but the appeal succeeded on the second.
Why the farm access appeal needed planning permission
The entrance was formed on land at the Planche, Church Road, Thurston, near Bury St Edmunds. The owner said it was needed for occasional access by large vehicles serving horse paddocks, and to help UK Power Networks maintain four electricity pylons and their high-voltage cables. The Inspector had no reason to doubt those stated purposes.
Part 2 Class B of Schedule 2 to the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) (England) Order 2015 can authorise the formation of an access onto an unclassified road in specified circumstances. But this is a qualified right: the access must be required in connection with development permitted by another relevant class of that Schedule, excluding Class A of Part 2.
Here, the continuation of horse grazing did not amount to a new act of development, even though the land use could be agricultural. Inspector Preston explained that the continuation of that use was not itself an act of development. Nor was another qualifying permitted development operation identified that required the entrance. The access therefore needed planning permission, rather than benefiting automatically from Class B.
That distinction matters to landowners contemplating a new field entrance. The Planning Geek guide to Class B access onto a highway explains the scope and conditions of the right. An unclassified road is not a blanket exemption from planning control.
How the Inspector assessed highway safety
The farm access appeal then turned on the actual likely use of the gate and the road conditions. The entrance sits on the outside of a sharp bend on a lightly trafficked country lane. Vehicles approaching the bend would be travelling slowly, while the access position provided reasonable views along the road when leaving the site.
In the farm access appeal, the Inspector observed weeds growing across the compacted surface near the new gate, suggesting that it had been used infrequently. Another access farther along the lane was open and a horsebox was visible within the paddocks. These observations supported the view that the original entrance would remain the main point of everyday access.
A large vehicle entering from one direction might briefly obstruct the carriageway, but the Inspector considered that traffic approaching the bend would have sufficient time to stop. The Inspector also recognised that occasional movements by large farm vehicles on narrow rural roads are not unusual. On the evidence presented, the new entrance would not cause unacceptable highway danger.
Importantly, the Inspector distinguished the present occasional-use field gate from an access serving new houses. Earlier proposals for two dwellings at the land had been dismissed, and one of the previously submitted plans showed a more formal access in the same general position. That did not mean such a design was required for the limited use now under consideration.
Why the proposed access conditions were rejected
The Council proposed conditions requiring the access to be completed to the more formal design associated with the earlier residential application and requiring visibility splays as demanded by the Highway Authority. The Inspector found neither necessary for this development.
In particular, the visibility condition failed to specify what splays would be required. It was therefore imprecise. The Inspector was also satisfied that the existing views from the entrance were adequate for its limited intended use, so the extra work was not needed to make the scheme acceptable.
There was a suggestion that some of the access had been constructed on land belonging to the Highway Authority. The Inspector treated ownership and private highway rights as separate from the planning merits. Granting planning permission did not settle any proprietary rights or prevent the Highway Authority considering its own legal position.
Enforcement notice quashed on ground (a)
Because the access was acceptable in highway-safety terms, Inspector Preston granted planning permission under the deemed application arising from section 177(5) of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990. In the decision, the Inspector concluded that “the creation of the access has caused no harm to highway safety”. The enforcement notice was quashed and the appeal succeeded on ground (a). This was a grant of permission, not a finding that those works had always been permitted development.
The farm access appeal also demonstrates the importance of stating the planning grounds clearly. The owner did not need to establish immunity from enforcement through the passage of time or prove the works were lawful without permission. Instead, the appeal directly addressed the acceptability of the existing entrance and succeeded on that basis.
For readers dealing with enforcement, our overview of permitted development rights explains the distinction between development authorised by the GPDO and development that must be assessed through an application for permission. The difference can determine both the evidence needed and the remedy available.
What the Thurston decision does not authorise
The Inspector made clear that a gate acceptable for occasional horse and utility access might not be suitable for intensive use. A future development in the paddocks would need to be considered on its own merits, and a new proposal could alter the highway assessment substantially. This decision does not grant advance consent for such development.
The farm access appeal is therefore a useful practical example rather than a universal rule. A landowner can fail to qualify for a permitted development right yet still secure permission on appeal. Equally, approval for a low-traffic entrance cannot be assumed to justify higher traffic levels, another use of land or the physical rights needed to carry out works on highway-owned land.
The appeal was decided on 16 November 2026 by Inspector Chris Preston. The official appeal record is on the Planning Inspectorate website, reference APP/W3520/C/25/3368355. The full decision is also available on AppealBase.

0 Comments