Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Leicester commencement appeal: trenches fail test

Inspector rejects hand-dug trenches as lawful commencement of an eight-storey Leicester student scheme, applying five established court authorities.

A Leicester commencement appeal over a proposed eight-storey student accommodation building has failed after an Inspector decided that shallow trenches dug by hand had not lawfully started construction. Inspector John Whalley dismissed Urbanite (Leicester) Limited’s appeal on 16 November 2026, refusing a certificate of lawfulness for the site between Highcross Street, Great Central Street and All Saints Open.

The developer said a T-shaped excavation made before the permission expired in August 2025 was a material operation sufficient to preserve the scheme. The Inspector accepted that the trenches had been dug in time, but could not match what he saw on the land to the approved foundation drawing. He regarded the operation as disconnected from how the eight-storey building would actually be constructed.

The Leicester commencement appeal matters well beyond one vacant city-centre plot. Planning law allows surprisingly modest works to begin a permission, but size is not the only issue. What was done must genuinely be an operation comprised in the approved development. The decision draws on five court judgments, each dealing with a different aspect of that distinction.

The permission and the deadline

The original planning permission, Leicester City Council reference 20210523, was granted on 12 August 2022 for purpose-built student accommodation, with communal space and a roof terrace. A subsequent permission, reference 20222242, varied conditions to accommodate changes including more student rooms, a substation, altered entrances, drainage, cycle storage and servicing arrangements. The amended proposal retained a condition requiring development to begin by 12 August 2025.

Three pre-commencement conditions, numbered 5, 6 and 14, required details to be approved before building started. Those details had been approved by 10 June 2025, so the disagreement was not primarily about outstanding condition discharges. It concerned whether the work claimed as commencement was actually part of the authorised building. The council’s earlier conservation advisory panel record also provides background on the proposed variation.

On 9 July 2025 the developer applied for a certificate of lawful existing development, reference 20251156. Leicester City Council did not issue a decision within the required period, and the applicant appealed under section 195 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990. Unlike a conventional planning appeal, the question was not whether a fresh building ought to be permitted but whether the earlier permission had already been lawfully implemented.

Why the Leicester commencement appeal was dismissed

Urbanite said its workers had excavated a T-shaped trench on 21 June 2025. The stated dimensions were approximately four metres by three metres and 600 millimetres deep. The developer said the excavation was for a ground beam supporting a ground floor slab and part of the external walls, and that the method of digging should not prevent it from counting as commencement.

During his site visit on 9 November 2026, the Inspector examined the excavations against drawing 088-ROS-00-FN-GA-S-01125, revision C02, showing selected foundation ground beams. He found the marks did not make a recognisable T corresponding to the plan. They were also further into the site and slightly south of the location indicated on the drawing.

Whalley found no corresponding evidence of a properly set-out foundation layout or footing levels. The construction management information anticipated mass-fill beams and pads, with piling not expected to be required. He considered the roughly cut trenches unlikely to serve any useful function in a properly organised programme of ground preparation and foundation construction. The likely need to clear and prepare the site could mean they would be filled in before meaningful work began.

The Inspector described the excavations as “a minimally token act, a virtual sham”, finding they were not a genuine implementation of the permitted scheme. That is an important finding of fact about these particular trenches. The reason was not simply that a pickaxe had been used, or that the excavation was small. The work lacked a credible physical relationship to the approved foundation layout.

Five court judgments explain the legal test

The Leicester commencement appeal relied on F G Whitley & Sons v Secretary of State for Wales (1992) 64 P&CR 296, an authority on whether works carried out inconsistently with a permission can lawfully implement it. The correct inquiry is into the permission and the operations relied on, rather than assuming any activity before an expiry date is sufficient.

Malvern Hills District Council v Secretary of State for the Environment [1982] JPL 439 demonstrates that even pegging out an approved estate road may satisfy the statutory definition. Equally, the operation must really be the beginning of the development authorised. The subsequent Thayer v Secretary of State for the Environment and Wycombe District Council [1991] 3 PLR 104 concerned limited access works, including an opening in a hedge. Neither decision imposes a minimum volume of excavation or requires foundations to have been completed.

Two further authorities add a subtle but significant qualification. In East Dunbartonshire Council v Secretary of State for Scotland [1998] ScotCS 46, the Scottish Court of Session rejected a separate requirement to prove an intention to complete the development. Riordan Communications Ltd v South Buckinghamshire District Council [2000] 1 PLR 45 applied a related objective approach in England. Those cases do not make unrelated works lawful; they distinguish physical compliance with the permission from speculation about a developer’s future intentions.

The legal question under section 56 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 is whether a material operation comprised in the approved development began in time. In Leicester the Inspector was not persuaded that the works on the ground were the ground beams or other authorised operations shown on the plans. His use of the word “sham” should therefore not be mistaken for a free-standing rule that starting work mainly to preserve permission is unlawful.

Discharged conditions did not solve the foundations problem

One notable aspect of the Leicester commencement appeal is that the developer had secured approval for its three pre-commencement details before digging. That removed an obvious obstacle to implementation but did not establish that a qualifying material operation had taken place. For the Leicester commencement appeal, compliance with conditions and the character of the work are related but distinct questions.

The Council’s Building Control team questioned whether the hand-dug trench could support the proposed eight-storey building and said a qualified structural engineer would need to confirm the foundation design. The council itself acknowledged that commencement under the Building Regulations is a different test from commencement for planning purposes. The Inspector’s conclusion rested on his own assessment of the layout, appearance, likely construction sequence and the planning drawings.

A practical warning for expiring permissions

A Leicester commencement appeal about foundations offers a wider lesson for developers facing a deadline. A small material operation can be enough, but it needs to be shown on the relevant approved drawings, match the permission being implemented and be supported by credible contemporary evidence. Survey records, setting-out plans, dated photographs, contractor instructions and inspections can be more valuable than retrospective assertions that a trench was intended as a foundation.

The distinction is especially important where a later section 73 permission varies an earlier approval. Applicants should check which operative permission and approved plans they intend to implement, whether the time limit remains unchanged and whether pre-commencement conditions have been satisfied. Planning Geek’s guide to making planning permission extant explains the wider rules and why an apparently modest start should not be treated casually.

Inspector Whalley dismissed appeal APP/W2465/X/25/3374782 and declined to issue the certificate. His decision does not grant a fresh planning permission or make a separate ruling about some different building method. It decides that the evidence of these excavations failed to establish lawful commencement of permission 20222242. The case record is on the Planning Inspectorate appeal page. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news

Priors Farm housing: 850 homes backed

Priors Farm housing: 850 homes backed

Wokingham councillors back 850 Priors Farm homes, but major affordable housing and highways obligations remain subject to linked decisions and a legal agreement.