A Wigan HMO appeal has succeeded after an Inspector allowed a five-bedroom shared house on Pagefield Street, despite the borough-wide Article 4 Direction which removed the normal permitted development route from a family home to a small house in multiple occupation.
Inspector I Radcliffe issued the decision on 16 November 2026, overturning Wigan Council’s refusal of planning permission for a five-person Class C4 HMO. The home had been converted but was unoccupied, and the Inspector required changes to one bedroom and formal management arrangements before use could begin.
This Wigan HMO appeal is an important contrast with two recent local refusals. The concentration, parking and internal amenity tests did not disappear simply because the new use would provide lower-cost shared accommodation. Here the evidence and a revised layout were enough to clear them.
Why the Wigan HMO appeal needed permission
Wigan’s borough-wide Article 4 Direction was made on 15 July 2025, confirmed on 21 August and took effect on 31 August 2025. It removed the Class L permitted development right for changes from a Class C3 dwellinghouse to a Class C4 HMO. The council’s published Direction details confirm that timetable.
Work on the Pagefield Street conversion had started in spring 2025, before the Direction took effect. But the Inspector recorded that the conversion had not been fully completed by 31 August. At the site visit the renovated and furnished accommodation was still empty, with no indication that tenants had occupied it.
Starting alteration works before the Direction commenced was therefore not the same as having an established C4 use. This is an important distinction for landlords considering whether an existing use is protected when permitted development rights are withdrawn. The rules are explained in Planning Geek’s guide to Article 4 and material change of use.
HMO concentration fell within the local threshold
Wigan’s March 2022 HMO Supplementary Planning Document says permission will not normally be granted where HMOs would exceed 10% of properties within a 50-metre radius. Although other HMOs existed nearby, the council confirmed that there were none inside the 50-metre circle around this property. The Inspector therefore found no excessive concentration under the guidance.
In the Wigan HMO appeal, the Inspector then found that the proposal, as a residential use in a residential area, would not harm residential character or the composition of the community. Additional movements by occupiers were not automatically an unacceptable source of disturbance.
That is different from the earlier Park Road HMO appeal, where the Inspector was concerned about the immediate arrangement of existing HMOs and the effect of placing an ordinary house between them. A percentage policy is a starting point, not a substitute for examining the nearby properties and the likely impacts.
Parking and the small rear yard were acceptable
The house has no off-street parking, and roadside spaces are already heavily used. But the Inspector gave weight to the nearby bus route on Park Road, local shops, the walkable town centre and a proposed secure store for four bicycles. Those factors meant the five HMO occupiers were not automatically expected to produce five additional cars.
Inspector Radcliffe concluded that the proposal “would not materially increase the demand for onroad parking”. The comparison was with an ordinary household potentially containing two adults with cars. The Wigan HMO appeal therefore shows why a council needs evidence of likely additional parking pressure rather than relying on the number of separate tenancies alone.
The only outside space was a small enclosed rear yard. Its high walls would offer privacy, while its southerly orientation and practical layout provided space for sitting, bins and the bicycle store. The Inspector accepted that this could serve five residents without forcing regular use of the pavement as overflow amenity space.
Objections had also raised fears about anti-social behaviour. The Inspector acknowledged those concerns, but noted that the police had not objected and considered that an enforceable management plan could address possible nuisance. The approval was not an unconditional acceptance of any future management arrangements.
A revised lobby solved the bedroom problem
There was a genuine internal amenity problem. Bedroom 2 on the ground floor opened directly from the communal living and dining room. The Inspector considered the shared area likely to be busy during the day and evening, with cooking, television, conversation and doors opening and closing. Without mitigation, that could disturb the person sleeping in the adjacent bedroom.
During the appeal, the applicant submitted an amended ground-floor plan introducing a lobby between the bedroom and the shared space. The Inspector accepted the revision after considering fairness to the parties. That lobby was considered a sufficient acoustic and privacy buffer, and a condition requires it to be completed before occupation.
This was the decisive difference from the earlier Kimberley Street Wigan HMO refusal, where an unacceptable bedroom relationship was not adequately resolved. For applicants designing small HMOs, usable bedroom sizes alone do not settle the question. The position of doorways and shared rooms matters too. Planning Geek’s HMO planning policy guide addresses these assessments.
Why the Wigan HMO appeal was allowed
The grant carries four conditions: compliance with the approved plans, construction and retention of the Bedroom 2 lobby, provision and retention of four secure cycle spaces, and approval of a management plan before the HMO use commences. The plan must deal with anti-social behaviour, inspections, tenancy allocations and the management and maintenance of the outdoor amenity area.
In the Wigan HMO appeal, the Inspector also recognised that the accommodation would widen housing choices for people on lower incomes and others seeking flexible accommodation. Construction work and the spending of future residents in local shops were additional benefits, though these carried only moderate weight. There was no identified harm substantial enough to outweigh the scheme’s benefits.
The Wigan HMO appeal decision is confined to this five-person layout and the evidence considered. It does not mean Wigan’s Article 4 Direction is ineffective, or that every C3-to-C4 application below 10% concentration should be granted. It demonstrates that a well-supported planning application can succeed after permitted development rights have been withdrawn, provided the actual policy and amenity issues are resolved.
The decision was issued on 16 November 2026 under appeal reference 6010887, following application A/25/099664/FULL. The full decision is published on the Planning Inspectorate appeal page. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase.

0 Comments