Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Biodiversity condition appeal fails over timetable

An Inspector accepted revised landscaping and a 12% habitat uplift at a Cheshire storage yard, but rejected the condition discharge without an implementation timetable.

by | 17th November 2026 13:21 | AppealsEcology

A biodiversity condition appeal has been dismissed after an Inspector found that a refrigerated trailer storage operator had supplied acceptable landscaping and habitat proposals, but no timetable for putting them into effect. The decision concerns a site at Lostock Gralam, near Northwich in Cheshire.

Inspector R Major issued the decision on 17 November 2026, refusing to approve the details submitted for a landscape and biodiversity enhancement scheme required by a condition attached to an earlier enforcement appeal permission. The current appeal arose because Cheshire West and Chester Council had not determined the operator’s application to approve the details within the prescribed period.

The biodiversity condition appeal illustrates an easily missed distinction. The Inspector accepted a proposed biodiversity uplift of approximately 12% and the reduction of existing earth bunds, but still refused to discharge the condition because the submission contained no programme showing when those improvements would be delivered.

Why the biodiversity condition appeal arose

The site at Moss Lane had previously received permission, on appeal, for use as a Class B8 storage and distribution area for refrigerated trailers. That permission followed an appeal against an enforcement notice and was subject to several conditions, including a detailed requirement to improve the site’s landscaping and biodiversity.

Condition 2 called for an enhancement scheme covering planting, boundary treatment, access and circulation areas, parking and the treatment of existing earth bunds. It also sought a demonstration of no net loss of natural assets using a biodiversity metric, supported by habitat assessment and an implementation timetable. The approved works were then to be carried out to that timetable and retained.

The condition included a mechanism requiring the permitted use to cease and trailers to be removed if specified requirements were not met. The latest decision did not itself establish that this mechanism had been triggered. It determined whether the submitted details were sufficient for the condition to be approved.

The council had failed to determine application 26/00119/DIS within the prescribed period. Inspector Major considered the scheme on its merits, with little substantive opposition evidence beyond comments from the council’s Principal Natural Environment Officer. This biodiversity condition appeal was therefore not an opportunity to reopen the principle of the trailer storage use.

The reduced bunds and planting were acceptable

The proposal would reduce existing earth bunds, some between two and 2.5 metres high, to about 1.25 metres. It would also create low internal mounds, retain existing trees, scrub and grassland, add native shrubs and trees, and provide dark green mesh fencing and vehicle circulation details.

The earlier enforcement appeal Inspector had required removal of the high bunds because of their adverse effect on the countryside, but had expressly allowed for the possibility of modest low mounding to screen the site. Inspector Major found the lower bunds and planting acceptable in that context.

On the information supplied, the landscaping scheme and its maintenance arrangements were satisfactory. The problem was not the proposed planting species, the appearance of the lowered bunds or the absence of a landscape management plan. It was the lack of a programme saying when the planting and other enhancement works would actually be implemented.

A separate issue arose over the ecological baseline. The submitted biodiversity plan and statutory metric gave the existing site a habitat score of 16.89 units and projected 18.92 units after the proposed works. That equated to an uplift of about 12%, calculated from the site’s existing condition.

Why a 12% uplift was not the problem

The council’s ecology officer argued that the metric should instead be measured against the site’s pre-development condition. There was also concern about a priority deciduous woodland habitat designation and woodland elsewhere on the site. However, the Inspector noted that little information had been supplied on how the submitted scheme would affect those habitats.

The previous enforcement appeal had established that the statutory biodiversity net gain regime did not apply to permission granted following a successful section 174 ground (a) enforcement appeal. The Inspector also referred to Policy N2.3 of the August 2026 National Planning Policy Framework, which says decision-makers should not give weight to development plan policies requiring biodiversity gains beyond the statutory framework, including for exempt development.

That does not make the bespoke condition disappear. It required commensurate biodiversity enhancement using metric evidence and habitat assessment, but did not specify a pre-development baseline or a particular percentage uplift. For this biodiversity condition appeal, Inspector Major found the submitted approximately 12% increase against the existing-site metric satisfactory.

It is important not to confuse this result with an ordinary planning permission to which the statutory 10% biodiversity gain condition applies. Planning Geek’s biodiversity net gain guide explains the statutory regime and its exemptions. This application concerned compliance with a separate condition actually imposed by the previous Inspector.

Both aspects of the scheme failed at the final delivery stage. The condition required an implementation programme for landscape works and an overall timetable for the landscape and biodiversity measures. The application included maintenance information, but not the dates or stages when the improvements would be delivered.

A missing timetable defeated the application

The Inspector wrote that “This timetable is a fundamental requirement of the condition”. Without it, the authority or Inspector could not be satisfied that the approved planting and biodiversity measures would be carried out.

The biodiversity condition appeal was therefore dismissed, despite the Inspector’s positive assessment of the physical landscape proposals and biodiversity metric. There was no finding that the projected 12% uplift was too small, nor that retaining lower earth mounds was automatically unacceptable.

The distinction is practical. A plan may show what will be planted, where habitats will be enhanced and how landscaping will be maintained, yet fail the terms of a condition that separately demands a delivery schedule. An application that omits a required element can be refused even if its technical design is otherwise satisfactory.

What a discharge application must contain

Applicants should read the precise condition against every drawing, ecological report and management plan before submitting. A simple schedule should identify when each intervention will take place, how its completion can be checked and how the stated maintenance obligations will operate. Planning Geek’s guide to discharging planning conditions explains why the decision is about satisfying the wording of the condition, not reconsidering planning permission itself.

For councils, the decision also shows the value of responding to a discharge application rather than leaving the Inspector to determine an appeal on a limited record. Cheshire West and Chester offered no substantive case explaining why the revised bund and planting proposals should fail, but the missing timetable was sufficient to decide the application.

This biodiversity condition appeal, reference 6010018, was decided on 17 November 2026 by Inspector R Major. The proposal related to the storage yard operated by WS Storage Solutions Limited at the former Associated Octel site. The decision is published on the Planning Inspectorate appeal page. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news

LDC costs appeals split over council mistakes

LDC costs appeals split over council mistakes

Two lawful development certificate appeals produced different costs decisions despite council mistakes, highlighting when unreasonable behaviour causes wasted appeal expense.