Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Listed building enforcement notice upheld after restoration

A Westminster listed building enforcement notice survives appeal despite restoration works, with the Inspector rejecting an excessive-requirements challenge.

by | 17th November 2026 13:21 | AppealsEnforcement

A listed building enforcement notice at Leinster Gardens in London has survived an appeal even though an unauthorised rear extension had already been removed by the time the Inspector visited. Westminster City Council’s requirements were upheld on 17 November 2026.

Inspector A A Phillips dismissed appeal 3376777 against a notice served on 19 November 2025. The notice concerned a triangular first-floor rear extension, an opening from a communal landing and a metal door. The appellant argued that the required reinstatement went further than necessary.

The listed building enforcement decision matters because later remedial work does not by itself establish that a notice was excessive when issued. The Inspector considered the actual restoration requirements, not simply whether the structure was still standing at the appeal site visit.

Why the listed building enforcement notice was served

Westminster’s notice identified unauthorised changes to a building on Leinster Gardens in Bayswater. The alleged works included a triangular rear extension beside an existing back addition and lift extension, together with an opening connecting the extension to the communal landing and a metal door. The appeal did not determine whether a different design would have been acceptable.

The notice required the first-floor addition and internal linking door to be removed, the affected areas to be put back in accordance with the identified pre-works drawing, and associated debris to be cleared. It required appropriate matching materials, finishes and external and internal detailing. The stated compliance period was 12 months.

Those steps are significant. A listed building enforcement notice can require physical restoration, rather than merely asking an owner to submit a fresh application. Planning Geek’s guide to listed building enforcement explains the separate statutory regime and the substantial differences from ordinary planning enforcement.

The appellant, identified in the decision as Mr Mukarram Syed of Crest Commercial Limited, challenged the notice on section 39(1)(g) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990. That ground asks whether the requirements are excessive for restoring the building or addressing the statutory purpose; it does not ask the Inspector to grant listed building consent on the merits.

Restoration had taken place before the site visit

At the site visit on 4 November 2026, the Inspector saw that the unauthorised extension had been removed and the property restored in accordance with the drawing identified in the notice. The unauthorised internal door had also been taken out and replaced by a white-painted door. Those observations are important but do not mean the appeal was automatically successful.

The listed building enforcement appeal therefore turned on a narrow legal and practical question. Had the council demanded more restoration than was justified by the works alleged in its notice? Inspector Phillips decided that the removal and reinstatement requirements were proportionate to the condition the council was seeking to recover.

This is distinct from an appeal where the council has required demolition of lawful historic fabric, or restoration of features which were missing before the alleged breach. The starting point has to be evidenced carefully. Photographs, dated surveys and original drawings are often crucial in defining what the relevant pre-works condition actually was.

In this case, the notice referred to a specific drawing, LON98/05 P2, and identified the parts to be removed. Inspector Phillips considered those requirements against the actual unauthorised first-floor addition and the altered doorway. The decision contains no finding that Westminster had demanded reconstruction beyond the necessary pre-works condition.

Later consents did not make the notice excessive

A further point arose because relevant planning permission and listed building consent had subsequently been implemented. That development did not determine the appeal. Inspector Phillips explained that, when the council served the listed building enforcement notice, there was no certainty that those later permissions would be implemented.

The Inspector therefore concluded that Westminster could not rely on the future implementation of the consents to achieve the restoration it considered necessary when the notice was issued. The council had been entitled to use its enforcement powers to require the identified works to be undone.

On the ground argued, the Inspector found that the notice’s requirements went “no further than necessary” to restore the building to its previous condition. That finding addresses the extent of the required work, rather than making a wider ruling about the merits of any subsequent application.

The listed building enforcement challenge failed and the notice was upheld. The decision does not establish that the extension remained standing at the time of the appeal decision. Quite the opposite: the visit recorded its removal. Nor should the appeal’s dismissal be presented as evidence that the later consents were invalid or ineffective.

How listed building enforcement appeals differ

A trap for practitioners is to confuse the grounds of an ordinary planning enforcement appeal with those governing listed building enforcement. In an ordinary section 174 appeal, ground (g) concerns whether the time to comply is reasonable. Under section 39 of the listed building legislation, ground (g) concerns whether the requirements exceed what is needed. The letters do not map across.

That distinction matters when deciding what to plead and which evidence to submit. A complaint that the works are unnecessary needs evidence addressing the building’s prior condition and what the notice requires. An argument that contractors cannot complete restoration in time raises a different ground and requires a different chronology and supporting documents.

Planning Geek’s ordinary enforcement appeal grounds guide sets out the seven familiar Town and Country Planning Act grounds. It should be read alongside the listed-building guide, not substituted for it. The two statutory appeal regimes serve related but different purposes.

The listed building enforcement example also demonstrates why carrying out remedial work during the life of an appeal does not necessarily settle a legal challenge to the notice. Compliance may remove the physical harm, while the separate question of whether the council originally demanded too much remains for the Inspector to decide.

What the Leinster Gardens appeal establishes

There was no detailed review of the heritage merits of the later permission and consent. The only substantive issue determined in this appeal was whether the council’s restoration demands were excessive under section 39(1)(g). The narrow scope is what makes the outcome useful to owners, agents and local authorities considering similar notices.

The listed building enforcement decision offers a practical lesson for both sides. Councils should specify the unauthorised works, use clear reference drawings and require only the steps needed to put matters right. Appellants should identify precisely which demand is unnecessary, and why, rather than treating subsequent compliance as proof of an overreaching notice.

Inspector Phillips dismissed appeal APP/X5990/F/25/3376777 on 17 November 2026. The site was in Leinster Gardens, London, and the notice had been issued on 19 November 2025. The case is listed on the Planning Inspectorate appeal page. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news