Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Stables lawfulness appeal fails over occupation proof

An Inspector finds that residential activity at a Leicestershire equestrian holding did not prove four continuous years of dwellinghouse use.

A stables lawfulness appeal in Leicestershire has failed after an Inspector found that evidence of residential occupation did not prove four continuous years of use as a dwelling.

The decision, issued on 17 November 2026, concerns an extension to an equestrian building at Trilogee Stud, Whittington Lane, near Thornton. Inspector M Savage dismissed an appeal against Hinckley and Bosworth Borough Council’s refusal of a certificate of lawful existing use.

The case matters beyond the property itself because the decision examines the transition from the former four-year enforcement rule, what counts as occupation of a specific building, and how contradictory tenancy and planning evidence should be weighed.

Why the stables lawfulness appeal failed

Thortonbury Limited, through appellant Melanie Brewster, sought to establish that a single-storey extension to a stable block had been used as a single dwellinghouse for long enough to become immune from enforcement. The original application was made on 15 May 2025 under section 191 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 and refused on 8 July 2025. The subsequent appeal was brought under section 195.

The application site encompassed stable buildings, a manège and fields, but the Inspector emphasised the importance of identifying the particular building and use in question. It was the extension beside the second stable building, not simply some residential activity somewhere on the wider holding, for which a certificate was requested.

The extension contained bedrooms, a kitchen, sitting room and bathroom at the time of the appeal site visit. Inspector Savage accepted that it provided the facilities for day-to-day living and was, in physical and functional terms, a dwellinghouse. The difficulty in the stables lawfulness appeal was therefore not the layout of the accommodation, but the evidence of when its residential use actually commenced and whether it continued.

Four years or ten years: the transitional question

Changes made by the Levelling-up and Regeneration Act 2023 altered the relevant enforcement time limits in England from 25 April 2024. For qualifying breaches occurring on or after that date, the general period is now ten years. The previous four-year limit continues to apply to qualifying development or breaches taking place before the change, subject to the precise statutory rules.

The appellant argued that residential use had begun in November 2019, so that the earlier four-year period had been completed by November 2023. The Inspector examined that proposition rather than simply applying the current ten-year period to all residential accommodation. For the application dated 15 May 2025, the Inspector identified the need to show the material change of use by 15 May 2021 and continued use without significant interruption during the following four years.

Our guidance on planning enforcement time limits and the four- and ten-year rules sets out the wider framework. In the stables lawfulness appeal, establishing the correct period was only the start: the applicant still needed to satisfy the balance-of-probabilities test.

Earlier planning permission conflicted with the occupation account

The planning history proved important. The appellant referred to a 2015 permission establishing equestrian use and to later applications involving the side extension. Two applications for the extension had been refused in 2018 because of overnight accommodation. A retrospective permission was subsequently granted in August 2019 after the council had observed that domestic appliances had been removed and the rooms were being used as storage.

The Inspector treated the 2019 officer report as evidence of what was happening during that period. An officer had recorded the removal of kitchen and washing equipment and the replacement of patio doors by a metal roller shutter. That evidence was difficult to reconcile with the assertion that the same extension had been occupied as a dwelling throughout the claimed years.

The Inspector also considered whether an extension had been built as an unauthorised dwelling from the outset rather than later changed into residential use. On the facts and planning history, the subsequent use of the extension for accommodation would have constituted a change of use, making the relevant statutory time-limit question material to the stables lawfulness appeal.

Tenancy agreements and life on the wider site

Several agreements and statements supported aspects of the appellant’s account, but did not establish the necessary continuity of residential use within the extension. Tenancy documents described agricultural or equestrian uses. Although they showed that named individuals could occupy the site, they did not establish that those people were using the specific extension as a dwellinghouse throughout the four-year period.

One former occupier described living initially in a horsebox and later in a touring caravan, with the building being used for storage until November 2021. The Inspector also considered court documents arising from a later eviction, but those documents did not identify precisely where on the holding the occupiers had been living at the critical earlier dates.

That distinction is important for anyone making a certificate application. A tenant’s presence, payment of rent, utility bills or operation of a business can be evidence of activity on land, without necessarily proving use of a particular structure as a separate dwelling. Our guide to certificates of lawful existing use explains why a carefully defined use and a coherent evidential chronology matter.

The stables lawfulness appeal also illustrates why an applicant cannot rely on the absence of competing eyewitness accounts when contemporaneous planning documents and other statements actively contradict their chronology.

Could an interruption restart the enforcement clock?

The evidence described an eviction in October 2024 and a new lease commencing in January 2025. The Inspector noted uncertainty over when the new occupier began living in the extension and whether the intervening period was significant. The distinction between use and physical occupation is important: a short absence does not necessarily end a residential use, but a significant interruption may affect whether the required continuous period has been established.

The Inspector did not need to resolve every point about the later occupancy because the central claimed four-year period had not been proved. Similarly, although the council argued that positive deception or concealment should prevent reliance on the enforcement immunity period, the Inspector expressly did not determine that allegation after deciding the appeal on the insufficiency of evidence.

That restraint is central to reading the decision accurately. The stables lawfulness appeal was not a finding that positive deception had occurred. It was a finding that the applicant had not demonstrated the claimed change of use and continuity on the balance of probabilities.

What the decision means for future certificate applications

Inspector Savage found that the evidence regarding the extension was unclear and contradictory, commenting that the appellant has not discharged their burden of proof. The appeal was dismissed and the council’s refusal to certify the single dwellinghouse use was upheld.

For owners, occupiers and advisers, the practical lesson is to build the account around the specific land or building, a defensible start date and evidence showing how it was actually used throughout the statutory period. A stable block, caravan, horsebox and residential extension on one holding are not interchangeable merely because some form of occupation occurred there.

The decision is appeal reference APP/K2420/X/25/3373915, associated with application 25/00490/CLE. The original appeal can be found through the Planning Inspectorate case record. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news