A Bunbury housing appeal has been allowed for up to eight homes on village-edge land in Cheshire, despite conflict with the settlement boundary and limited harm to countryside character.
Inspector F P Tinsley granted permission in principle on 17 November 2026 for land at Heath Villa, School Lane. The appeal, brought by RHB Homes (Cheshire) Ltd against Cheshire East Council, concerns a site where a materially larger 34-home scheme had previously been dismissed.
The decision is particularly interesting because the council could demonstrate only 3.3 years of deliverable housing land, even though its latest Housing Delivery Test figure showed 213 per cent delivery. Those two measures answer different questions.
Why the Bunbury housing appeal succeeded
The application proposed between one and eight dwellings on two fields behind existing homes on School Lane, with an indicative layout showing eight detached houses. Most of the land is outside the defined settlement boundary. Bunbury is a Local Service Centre, but that designation did not remove the normal countryside policy restrictions on development beyond the boundary.
The Inspector accepted that the proposal conflicted with the Cheshire East strategic policies directing new homes towards defined settlements. It also involved limited harm to the character of land where open countryside extends into and through the village. However, the extent of that harm was central to the overall balance, not an automatic reason to dismiss the appeal.
The Bunbury housing appeal succeeded because the Inspector considered the smaller site’s relationship with existing houses, the remaining open space and the substantial housing supply deficit. The benefits of adding homes carried more weight than the identified harm and development plan conflict.
Eight homes compared with an earlier 34-home refusal
A previous appeal had considered a substantially larger site, including this land, for 34 dwellings alongside a school car park and an access road. That Inspector found significant harm to local character. The new decision does not overturn the earlier outcome or treat it as irrelevant. Instead, it explains why the eight-home proposal is materially different.
The larger scheme would have removed the undeveloped gap more comprehensively. Here, most of the land forming the countryside gap would remain. Inspector Tinsley considered that nearby gardens extended to similar depths into the countryside and that the appeal land had a visual and functional connection with the village.
Although houses would alter an undeveloped parcel, their presence would not materially change the established settlement pattern at this scale. Detailed design, precise siting and landscaping would still need to be considered at the second stage. The Inspector was therefore able to identify limited rather than significant character harm.
For a landowner looking at the Bunbury housing appeal, that comparison is one of the most useful parts of the decision. An earlier refusal is an important material consideration, but a smaller proposal needs to be assessed against its own effects and the policy circumstances at the time.
A 3.3-year housing supply despite 213 per cent delivery
Cheshire East could demonstrate a 3.3-year supply of deliverable housing sites, below the usual five-year benchmark. That shortfall was material to national policy supporting housing that contributes towards evidenced needs. The Inspector attached substantial weight to the benefit of up to eight additional dwellings.
At first glance this might appear inconsistent with the Housing Delivery Test result published on 17 August 2026. The district recorded 6,508 dwellings delivered against a requirement for 3,061 over the preceding three years, or 213 per cent. But the Inspector distinguished historic completed housing from the forward-looking availability of sites capable of delivering the next five years of homes.
As the decision explains, I attach substantial weight to the provision of up to eight additional dwellings
. That short quotation captures why the current shortage mattered even after strong past delivery. It was not assumed that the unusually high historic rate would necessarily continue.
The Bunbury housing appeal therefore shows why a favourable Housing Delivery Test result does not, by itself, demonstrate an adequate future housing land supply. Conversely, the supply shortfall does not mean every village-edge parcel must be approved. The decision still weighs the nature and scale of actual countryside harm.
Neighbourhood plan supported a smaller housing scheme
The Inspector identified a conflict with strategic settlement and countryside policies, including policies PG6 and PG9. By contrast, the proposal accorded with the relevant housing provisions of the Bunbury Neighbourhood Plan. Its policy H2 threshold for greenfield sites was 15 dwellings, and the plan’s minimum requirement for 80 homes was not a ceiling on additional housing.
This did not mean the neighbourhood plan displaced the wider development plan. The Bunbury housing appeal was decided by weighing the different policies and material considerations. The Inspector placed significant weight on meeting housing needs and concluded that the modest countryside harm did not substantially outweigh those benefits.
More generally, anyone assessing land near a settlement boundary should examine the relevant local and neighbourhood policies together. Planning Geek’s guide to settlement boundaries explains why being just outside a line on the policies map is important but is not always the end of the planning assessment.
Permission in principle is not approval to build
This appeal concerns permission in principle, often shortened to PiP. It is a two-stage consent route that answers only whether the location, land use and amount of housing can be accepted. The Inspector granted a range of one to eight dwellings, rather than authorising the precise eight-house arrangement suggested by the indicative plan.
Details of access, design, layout, drainage, biodiversity, landscaping, neighbouring amenity and other technical matters remain to be tested through a technical details consent application. Residents had raised concerns on many of those matters, but the decision makes clear they should not be treated as finally resolved by the first-stage permission.
Nor could the Inspector simply add normal planning conditions to the permission in principle. The Planning Practice Guidance makes that distinction explicit. Our permission in principle guide sets out the process and explains why technical details consent remains necessary before the development can proceed.
In the Bunbury housing appeal, the distinction was particularly important because some objections concerned the future road arrangement and the loss of hedgerows. Those issues may still materially influence what can be built, even though the principle of up to eight homes has been established.
What the decision means for similar village-edge sites
The Inspector’s final balance accepted both countryside policy conflict and limited harm to character. Nonetheless, the village relationship, neighbourhood plan provisions and housing supply shortage were sufficient material considerations to justify a decision other than in accordance with the development plan.
The important lesson is not that small rural housing sites now automatically receive consent. The Bunbury housing appeal illustrates an evidence-based comparison: how much countryside would actually be lost, whether the remaining open land preserves settlement character, what the adopted policies require and how strong the current housing supply evidence is.
The decision is appeal reference 6013411, following Cheshire East application 26/0976/PIP. It may be viewed through the Planning Inspectorate appeal record. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase.

0 Comments