Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Class Q farm appeal fails over future farming noise

Norfolk Class Q barn conversion refused despite acceptable daylight, after the Inspector considered potential future farming noise and disturbance.

A Class Q farm appeal for three homes at a Norfolk poultry farm has been dismissed because a proposed conversion would leave residents too close to agricultural buildings that could resume more intensive activities. The decision was issued on 17 November 2026 and concerns Doles Poultry Farm near Great Yarmouth.

Inspector H Whitfield rejected the prior approval appeal after considering the possible effects of noise, odour, machinery and poor outlook on future occupiers. The site was not operating as an intensive livestock farm when inspected, but the remaining buildings were capable of other lawful agricultural uses and there was no enforceable arrangement preventing them.

The Class Q farm appeal provides an unusually clear distinction between noise caused by new dwellings and the effect of existing or potential farm noise upon those dwellings. The Inspector found the scheme acceptable on natural light and on the noise that the homes themselves would generate, but not on the separate Class Q location and siting test.

Why the Class Q farm appeal was dismissed

The proposal concerned the conversion of an agricultural building into three single-storey homes, with partial demolition, new windows and doors and a proposed 1.8-metre acoustic fence. Mr Geoff Perry appealed against Great Yarmouth Borough Council’s refusal to grant prior approval on application 06/26/0091/PAD. Inspector Whitfield visited the site on 10 November before dismissing appeal 6013443.

Class Q, in Part 3 of Schedule 2 to the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) (England) Order 2015, can permit qualifying agricultural buildings to become homes. It does not, however, mean every proposed conversion is automatically acceptable. The local planning authority can examine the particular prior approval matters prescribed by the Order, including whether the location or siting makes residential use impractical or undesirable.

In this Class Q farm appeal the building was closely surrounded by other agricultural buildings, particularly alongside the proposed second and third homes. Although poultry and livestock rearing had reportedly ceased, the surrounding buildings were structurally capable of being used for more intensive farming again. The appellant said the business was now engaged in game processing and storage, but the Inspector was not satisfied the future range of lawful activities had been adequately restricted.

A draft undertaking did not protect future residents

The appellant offered a draft section 106 unilateral undertaking intended to stop livestock being kept on parts of the site during residential occupation. It was incomplete and not accompanied by a plan demonstrating control of the wider farm buildings and land. The Inspector could not treat it as a final enforceable restriction preventing farming next to the proposed homes.

The Class Q farm appeal therefore had to be assessed against potential, not just currently observed, agricultural activity. The Inspector considered that farm vehicles, machinery, livestock noise and odours could cause a degree of disturbance beyond the sound levels recorded during the assessment period. There was little physical separation between future living rooms and the farm surroundings.

That is not an argument that a farm will necessarily resume intensive activity tomorrow. It is an evidential point: a proposed residential conversion cannot rely on neighbouring agricultural buildings remaining quiet indefinitely when they could lawfully be brought back into fuller use.

Why the winter noise survey was insufficient

The submitted noise impact assessment drew on measurements taken between 26 November and 3 December 2025. It identified early-morning livestock vocalisations from about 3.45 am and suggested enhanced insulation, acoustic glazing, ventilation and fencing could control internal noise. An updated report also sought to rely on a May survey at another farm in North Suffolk as evidence of year-round conditions.

The Inspector was not persuaded that the short winter survey represented the full range of possible activity throughout the year. Nor had the appellant demonstrated that the other farm was sufficiently comparable. Even if acoustic glazing and ventilation could control measured noise inside the homes, residents would still wish to open windows and use outdoor space during warmer weather.

In the Class Q farm appeal the Inspector emphasised that the location and siting test covers the overall living environment, not just whether a numerical internal noise target can be met. The decision observed, The fact that future occupants would be aware of the relationship with the farm does not mean a comfortable living environment would be provided.

Acoustic fencing and outlook

The appellant reduced the length of some proposed acoustic fencing in amended plans, and the Inspector accepted those drawings and an updated noise report without finding procedural unfairness. But a high fence would still stand close to living areas in Units 2 and 3, creating a deadening effect on their outlook.

Alternative fencing might reduce that visual harm, but it was not established that an effective alternative could also preserve adequate privacy and separation from adjoining farm activities. The Class Q farm appeal consequently failed paragraph Q2(1)(e), which addresses whether the building’s location and siting make conversion impractical or undesirable.

Planning Geek’s Class Q barn conversion guidance explains how prior approval requirements differ from the underlying right to change the use of an eligible agricultural building.

Two other prior approval objections did not succeed

The council had also raised natural light. The Inspector found that the shortened fence would no longer stand directly outside the affected bedroom windows, and a suitable boundary treatment could be secured by condition. All habitable rooms could therefore receive adequate natural light, satisfying paragraph Q2(1)(g).

A separate and important distinction concerned paragraph Q2(1)(b), which addresses noise impacts of the development itself. The Inspector said this did not deal with farm noise affecting the new residents, which belonged under the location and siting assessment. Three new dwellings would not, on the evidence, cause unacceptable noise to neighbours. The Class Q farm appeal failed despite those findings in the appellant’s favour.

The decision also noted possible recreational effects on the Breydon Water Special Protection Area. The Inspector considered that any necessary application under regulation 77 of the Conservation of Habitats and Species Regulations 2017 could be made after prior approval, so the absence of that separate application did not determine this appeal. Planning Geek’s Habitats Regulations Assessment guidance sets out the separate protected-site process.

What the decision means for farm conversions

Inspector Whitfield dismissed the appeal, which concerned three homes at one agricultural building, not an enforcement notice or a full planning application for an entirely new housing estate. The Class Q farm appeal demonstrates why a proposed conversion can meet some prior approval matters yet fail another that is independently decisive.

Developers considering a similar proposal need credible evidence about the lawful uses and likely activity of adjoining farm buildings, rather than relying solely on how quiet they appear on a winter inspection. A signed, accurately defined and enforceable restriction, where appropriate, has a different status from a draft commitment that does not cover the wider holding.

The Planning Inspectorate record identifies appeal 6013443. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news