Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Braintree stables appeal fails as AI costs claim rejected

Essex equestrian scheme refused over landscape, grazing and drainage. Both costs applications failed, including a disputed AI allegation.

A Braintree stables appeal has been dismissed after an Inspector found that a proposal for four horses would spread extensive hardstanding across an open Essex field, with inadequate grazing and unresolved drainage evidence. The decision concerns land beside Millbrooks Farm in Colne Engaine and was issued on 17 November 2026.

Inspector Billy Pattison upheld Braintree District Council’s refusal of permission for stables, a manège, a new access and associated works. Although he accepted that equestrian facilities could be appropriate in the countryside, this particular scheme did not meet the local policy tests for grazing, suitable off-road riding routes and protecting the Colne River Valley landscape.

The Braintree stables appeal also produced two unusual costs decisions. The applicant and council each sought an award against the other, but both applications failed. The council suggested that the applicant’s appeal statement might have been prepared using artificial intelligence, an allegation for which the Inspector found no substantive supporting evidence.

Why the Braintree stables appeal failed

The appeal concerned application 26/00649/FUL, submitted by Mr M Hartley, for land bordered by Mill Lane and Colne Park Road. The proposal included a stable building, a manège, access improvements and a change of use to equestrian land. The Inspector visited on 28 October 2026 before determining the appeal under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990.

The surrounding Colne River Valley landscape has an open rural character, with fields, limited built development and mature hedgerows along local roads. The Inspector did not object to the presence of stables as such. Rather, he was concerned about how the particular amount of hardstanding and access works would affect views and landscape character.

The Braintree stables appeal involved approximately 3,650 square metres of development, including a substantial area of hardstanding. Although hedges would screen many close views, a proposed six-metre-wide entrance from Colne Park Road would expose that area. The Inspector concluded that the hardstanding would be a dominant, urbanising feature, causing moderate harm to the local landscape.

That distinction matters: the decision did not find significant harm to an important landscape under one policy criterion, but it did identify conflict with other local plan policies requiring development to respond to local character. A finding of moderate harm can still be decisive when considered alongside failures against site-specific equestrian criteria.

Grazing and safe riding routes were insufficient

Braintree’s Local Plan Policy LPP51 sets criteria for new equestrian facilities. The available grazing area was about 1.48 acres, while the proposal provided stabling for up to four horses. The Inspector considered British Horse Society guidance suggesting around 1.1 to 1.5 acres of permanent grazing per horse a reasonable benchmark in the absence of other guidance, while recognising expressly that the guidance itself is not planning policy.

There was no convincing land management arrangement showing how the shortfall would be overcome. The Inspector also considered the local roads relatively busy, and the evidence did not establish that suitable off-road routes could safely accommodate riders in accordance with the policy. The Braintree stables appeal therefore failed relevant grazing and route-access requirements as well as the landscape assessment.

For anyone considering stables or a manège, the important distinction is between agricultural and equestrian use. Planning Geek’s guide to agricultural and equestrian land use explains why simply keeping the countryside setting does not remove the need to examine the planning status of the use and associated works.

Drainage evidence could not be left to a condition

The scheme would introduce extensive hard surfacing. The drawings identified a possible soakaway, but the Inspector found that its position was unexplained in relation to the sloping land and the drainage report provided very limited technical detail. The material also did not make clear who had prepared the assessment or what qualifications they held.

Importantly, the Inspector decided that this was not a missing detail that could simply be resolved by imposing a planning condition. The appellant had not first demonstrated that the soakaway could infiltrate water adequately or that runoff could be managed without increasing flood risk elsewhere. The Braintree stables appeal accordingly failed the relevant surface water and flood-risk policies.

Biodiversity net gain was not a reason to refuse

One part of the appellant’s case did succeed. Updated ecological material, including a biodiversity metric and habitat plan, was considered at appeal because the Inspector concluded that admitting it would not prejudice anyone: it updated the evidence rather than fundamentally changing the development.

The Inspector accepted that the scheme was capable of meeting the mandatory 10% biodiversity net gain requirement. Even if some gain could not be delivered on the site, statutory routes to off-site units or credits remained available. The Braintree stables appeal is a reminder that the statutory biodiversity gain condition is generally addressed after planning permission, and refusal solely on an unproved assumption that a biodiversity gain plan cannot be approved is often inappropriate.

Planning Geek’s biodiversity net gain guidance explains the distinction between satisfying planning considerations at decision stage and obtaining approval for the biodiversity gain plan before starting development.

Both costs claims failed, including the AI allegation

The applicant alleged that the council had relied on unsupported assertions, had not properly considered technical submissions and had raised highway concerns that lacked support. Inspector Pattison found that the council had explained its landscape objections and had not actually refused the scheme on highway grounds. He also accepted that the council was entitled to decide whether late information required further consultation.

The council’s counterclaim argued that the applicant had pursued inaccurate points and raised the possibility that the statement of case had been prepared using artificial intelligence. Inspector Pattison wrote, I have not been provided with any substantive evidence to indicate that the appellant’s Statement of Case was prepared using AI. He also found no substantive evidence that the council had incurred unnecessary expense from having to deal with the inaccurate highway allegations.

Neither side therefore met the test for an award of costs: unreasonable behaviour causing unnecessary or wasted expense. The Braintree stables appeal illustrates that an inaccurate allegation, or a suspicion about how an appeal document was prepared, does not automatically justify a costs award. What matters is the evidence of unreasonable conduct and expense actually caused by it.

For the procedural distinction, Planning Geek’s guide to costs awards in planning appeals explains the separate questions of unreasonable behaviour and wasted expense. In the council’s costs decision, the Inspector noted that the relevant procedural guide requires parties to disclose the use of AI when creating or altering appeal documents. He did not find that this requirement had been breached on the evidence before him.

What happens after the dismissal

The Inspector dismissed the planning appeal and refused both full costs applications in separate decisions, all dated 17 November 2026. No planning permission arose from this appeal. A revised proposal would require its own proper consideration, including landscape impact, sufficient horse-related land provision and a substantiated drainage strategy.

The Braintree stables appeal is especially useful because the refusal was not an objection to horses in the countryside. It was a conclusion about this layout, this amount of hardstanding and the evidence offered for the proposed use. The accompanying costs decisions underline how closely the Inspector examined what each party actually said and whether the conduct had financial consequences.

The Planning Inspectorate appeal record identifies reference 6010289. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news