Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Petrol station appeal fails at Barlby roundabout

Inspector rejects the Barlby roadside service proposal after finding unsafe roundabout access, underrepresented traffic, daytime noise and countryside harm.

A petrol station appeal for a roadside service development beside the A19 and A163 roundabout at Barlby, North Yorkshire, has been dismissed over highway safety, noise and landscape concerns.

Inspector J Hobbs issued the decision on 17 November 2026 following a two-day hearing in August. Valli Forecourts Ltd originally proposed heavy goods vehicle refuelling as part of the scheme, but later removed that element. The proposal before the Inspector involved petrol filling, car washing, a retail kiosk and electric vehicle charging beside York Road, as the project’s history was also reported by Forecourt Trader.

The case is a useful reminder that attractive elements such as electric vehicle charging and investment do not necessarily rescue a mixed roadside proposal when its access geometry and supporting evidence fall short.

Why the petrol station appeal failed

The proposed development would have added a fourth arm to the three-arm A19/A163 roundabout. The Inspector found that the proposed exit would partially overlap the existing northbound A19 exit, creating confusing vehicle movements. A two-lane site exit would encourage some left-turning traffic to cross the roundabout very briefly, while other vehicles would be directed across existing hatched markings. Drivers might change lanes unexpectedly or enter the wrong path.

Neither the potential alteration of road markings through a legal agreement nor the possibility of redesigning the traffic island at the site access overcame those fundamental concerns. Although a section 278 highway agreement could secure detailed works, the Inspector considered that available space would not permit a sufficiently large island to slow incoming vehicles. This was an essential problem with the submitted arrangement, not simply a detail to be left for later approval.

On that basis, the petrol station appeal failed a key highway safety test. In the Inspector’s words, the proposal would increase the risk of collision, independently of the additional congestion issues.

Outdated traffic counts undermined the forecast

The transport assessment relied on a roundabout traffic survey undertaken in February 2022. The appellant used forecasting software to model conditions in 2026 and 2029, but the Inspector was not satisfied that the resulting figures reflected actual growth. Traffic counters on the A19 suggested annual average daily flows had increased by approximately 11 per cent north of the junction and 17 per cent to its south between 2022 and 2025.

The evidence did not allow the Inspector to produce a precise replacement traffic forecast. Nevertheless, the differences were important because the southern roundabout arm was already approaching its theoretical capacity in the appellant’s model. With more realistic traffic growth, capacity could be reached or exceeded during the morning peak, and queues might extend further towards York Road.

The petrol station appeal therefore illustrates a practical problem for developers relying on traffic surveys carried out several years before determination. A recognised modelling method cannot compensate for an unrepresentative traffic baseline where the consequences for road capacity are material.

Noise, washing bays and neighbouring homes

Residential properties on Weighton View Drive and Pastures Close face towards the site. The appellant’s original background noise readings were taken in November 2021, while a longer survey commissioned by an interested party was conducted in June 2026. The two sets of results differed substantially, particularly during the daytime and overnight periods.

Inspector Hobbs preferred the more recent and longer survey as a better reflection of prevailing conditions. Applying that background to the appellant’s noise model produced predicted daytime activity eight decibels above the representative background level. Jet washes, mechanical car washing and plant serving the retail kiosk would introduce different and more localised noise than traffic on the A19.

Operating-hour restrictions might reduce some disturbance, but they would not remove the daytime harm. The Inspector did not, however, find that the predicted night-time noise or light spill would cause equivalent harm. In this petrol station appeal, the distinction matters: the decision did not treat every objection to the development as proven.

Countryside location and the retail kiosk

The undeveloped land forms a green buffer between the edge of Barlby and the A19. The proposed buildings and hard surfaces would have occupied much of the plot, with a relatively limited area of soft landscaping. The Inspector found that a largely hard-surfaced facility operating around the clock would erode the semi-rural character of this village-edge location.

The local plan’s settlement strategy directed most development into defined settlements, while allowing certain activities outside those boundaries where justified. That is why the site’s location and evidence of demand mattered. Our guidance on settlement boundaries and planning applications explains the wider distinction between a settlement edge and land treated as countryside.

The scheme included electric vehicle charging, which the Inspector recognised as a benefit, but there was little convincing evidence of a need for the complete mixed-use roadside facility at this particular location. Existing filling stations at Escrick and Selby were relevant to that assessment.

The retail kiosk raised a separate policy question. Although the local plan contained restrictions on retail provision outside development limits, the Inspector did not find harmful effects on the vitality or viability of existing retail centres. The petrol station appeal was not dismissed on the basis that a national convenience retailer would necessarily damage Selby or Barlby’s shops.

How the August 2026 national policy was applied

The hearing followed the publication of the revised National Planning Policy Framework on 17 August 2026. Both main parties agreed they had been able to address it without further consultation. The Inspector considered the national policies supporting private investment and electric vehicle charging, and attached substantial weight to the economic benefits of the proposed facility.

However, some older local policies governing roadside services and out-of-centre shops were more restrictive than the new national provisions and received very limited weight where materially inconsistent. The proposal still failed the relevant national tests concerned with highway safety, design and noise. That reasoning is important: a proposal may gain policy support in one respect without overcoming a serious conflict elsewhere.

The broader approach is considered in our guide to the presumption in favour of sustainable development. In this petrol station appeal, Inspector Hobbs found that the positive contributions were substantially outweighed by the adverse effects. The appeal was consequently dismissed.

Officer support did not determine the outcome

Council officers recommended approving the original planning application, but North Yorkshire Council’s Selby and Ainsty area planning committee refused it in November 2025. At the time Councillor Stephanie Duckett described the scheme as not wanted and not needed, as reported by Forecourt Trader. The subsequent appeal decision was issued on 17 November 2026. The Inspector noted that members are entitled to depart from professional officer recommendations where they have sound planning reasons for doing so.

For applicants considering a similar site, the decision draws together several points. Junction access must work safely in its actual geometric setting; traffic and acoustic evidence must represent present conditions; and the need for a mixed roadside scheme must be demonstrated rather than inferred from a single beneficial component.

The full decision concerns appeal reference 6007900 and North Yorkshire Council application 2021/1176/FUL. It can be checked through the Planning Inspectorate appeal record. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news