A brewery enforcement appeal has succeeded in Gloucestershire, with an Inspector quashing a demolition notice and granting planning permission for a brewery and taproom at Elmstone Business Park. The decision, issued on 19 November 2026, follows an enforcement dispute over building works, car parking and the change of use of part of the site near Cheltenham.
Inspector Paul T Hocking allowed appeal 3378929 by Clavell & Hind against Tewkesbury Borough Council’s notice, which had required demolition and reinstatement. The Inspector corrected the terms of the notice, quashed it and granted permission for the development carried out at Unit 2, subject to conditions addressing flood safety, foul drainage and surface water runoff.
The brewery enforcement appeal is particularly interesting because the council withdrew its planning objections after receiving additional acoustic and flood risk evidence and considering updated national policy. Yet the appellant’s separate application for a full or partial award of appeal costs was refused. Winning the appeal did not mean that the original enforcement action had been unreasonable.
What the brewery enforcement appeal concerned
The appeal followed an enforcement notice issued on 17 June 2026. The council had alleged that buildings and hardstanding had been erected without permission for a mixed brewery and drinking establishment. Its requirements included demolishing the structures, removing hard surfaces, clearing debris and restoring the land, with six months for compliance. The business park covers around 1.3 hectares and contains several buildings and associated parking.
During the appeal the main parties, without prejudice to their respective positions, agreed a description of what had actually been built and used when the notice was issued. The Inspector substituted a more precise allegation covering an extension to Phoenix House, toilet and kitchen facilities, a car park and a material change of use to a brewery and taproom. The corrected notice referred only to Unit 2, not Units 2 and 3, and had revised restoration requirements. The agreed changes could be made without injustice to either party.
The appellant withdrew several alternative grounds and arguments about the notice’s validity on the basis of the agreed approach to ground (a), which permits the planning merits to be considered through a deemed application. This was not a ruling that every disputed allegation in the original notice was legally void. The central question became whether planning permission could now properly be granted.
Town-centre policy and the business park fallback
In the brewery enforcement appeal, the Inspector considered whether the use would significantly harm the vitality and viability of existing town centres. The council had initially raised retail and town-centre concerns, but accepted that the updated August 2026 National Planning Policy Framework changed the relevant policy balance. The Inspector referred to Policy TC3, under which a sequential test does not apply to small-scale rural development such as the scheme in question.
That meant the council’s adopted Local Plan policy RET4 was materially inconsistent with the revised national approach and carried very limited weight in this assessment. An existing permission, reference 15/00968/FUL, also provided a fallback for other potentially town-centre uses on the site. The council accepted that the brewery and taproom would not produce an unacceptable effect on the vitality or viability of established centres.
The precise classification of brewing activity was not assumed from the name of the business alone. In the separate costs decision, the council explained that it had needed the appellant’s acoustic assessment before accepting that the brewery use could fall within Use Class E rather than a more intensive Class B2 activity. That distinction helped it assess the fallback and the policy consequences. Our Use Class E guide explains why the operational character of a proposed use matters.
Flood risk evidence changed the position
Flood risk formed the second substantive issue. According to the appellant’s costs submissions, which said the council now accepted the point, the business park buildings themselves were within Flood Zone 1, although the existing access passed through Flood Zone 3. The council had originally objected to the drinking establishment on flood safety grounds. Updated assessment material and a technical note provided in October 2026 helped the parties reach common ground.
The Inspector accepted conditions requiring arrangements to safeguard users during flood events, appropriate foul drainage and details of hardstanding and surface water runoff. Permission was therefore granted with controls rather than on the basis that flood risk could simply be ignored. The surface water condition requires evidence about pre-development and post-development runoff and, where necessary, measures to avoid an increase.
For businesses seeking to regularise an existing use, the brewery enforcement appeal shows why late technical evidence can still matter. An appropriate flood assessment and acoustic report can change a council’s position, but providing them earlier may avoid prolonged enforcement proceedings and unnecessary professional expense. The outcome is not a general authorisation of hospitality uses on flood-sensitive rural sites.
Why the costs application still failed
The separate costs decision provides the other half of the story. Clavell & Hind argued that the council had issued a defective notice, withdrawn its objections too late, and unreasonably pursued town-centre and flood risk objections. The appellant sought a full award of costs, or alternatively a partial award. The Inspector refused both.
He noted that the parties had cooperated in correcting the notice and that “it is not unusual for a notice to require correction”. The revised allegation and requirements had been agreed without injustice. The Inspector was not persuaded that the council had behaved unreasonably simply by issuing the notice in the original form, despite the earlier withdrawn notice and subsequent negotiation.
The chronology also mattered. The acoustic assessment arrived on 16 July 2026, updated national policy followed on 17 August, and adequate flood evidence was provided on 5 and 12 October. The Inspector considered it reasonable for the council to insist on those documents before conceding its objections. Without an enforceable permission, development would have continued without the controls now agreed.
The brewery enforcement appeal therefore illustrates the difference between a successful ground (a) planning appeal and the additional test for costs. The applicant must show unreasonable behaviour causing unnecessary or wasted expense, not simply that a notice was later quashed. Our guide to costs awards explains the test, and our enforcement notice guide covers the appeal grounds.
What the permission actually allows
Following the corrections, the Inspector quashed the notice and granted permission under section 177(5) of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 for the building extension, ancillary facilities, car park and use of Unit 2 as a brewery and taproom. The three agreed planning conditions require practical evidence and follow-up action on flood safety, foul water disposal and surface water. The notice no longer requires the demolition or cessation steps it had originally demanded.
The key lesson from the brewery enforcement appeal is to distinguish an enforcement notice’s description of a breach from the planning merits of the development as actually carried out. Both may change during an appeal, but negotiated changes and eventual permission do not retrospectively prove that the council acted improperly. The separate refusal of costs is an important part of the outcome.
The official appeal is recorded by the Planning Inspectorate. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase, alongside the separate decision refusing the application for costs.


0 Comments